JDJ is scripted right ??

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Daebak

@Daebak

Trailblazer

+ 7

Posted: 12 years ago

#111

Originally posted by: -Chandramukhi-

Why would they choose Gauhar over Hard then if she was that good 😕

Well going based on your choice, does Isha fit in that growth viewpoint of yours ???

P.S: Lets discuss in the AT since we are going off topic

Coz the face off are not based on over all performances...

Gauhar had a better concept...and it was based on that one dance they both did as the dance off...Both were VERY good...it was just that...U HAD to pick one...and based on that dance..it was Gauhar that day...

Isha ko AT me discuss karenge...But shez been consistent till she danced and shown variety...I am not her janam janam ki fan to support her if I didnt like her😆😆😆😆 I started watching this season happily coz I didnt have any favorites...Having favs in the show is always a burden...

Like last time Ragini was...I used to feel soo bad for her😆😆😆😆 But still vote nahi karti thi main usko harr week...coz she was very average...everyone knew she wont make it to top 5...😆😆😆

Quote

Maria

@-MariaMars-

Sparkler

+ 6

Posted: 12 years ago

#112

Originally posted by: -Chandramukhi-

You think those people will show up here on this topic to show off some more of their hypocrisy, I highly doubt it.

On a side note: Vandu is hilarious

😆😆😆😆 No ways dear.. They are not going to show up definitely... 😛

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

mahi

@larki_punjaban

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#113

Originally posted by: -Chandramukhi-

@ bold, that's why she got maximum 30s in the history of JDJ. Imagine if she had done your so called dancing, what would have happened to this stage. Sarcasm intended.

You wanna hate someone, do it with fairness, but guess asking the wrong person here

this statement belongs to after her injury not before my dear friend

i dont hate her ihv never mention that i hate her

and moving body without bones doesnt mean to me dancing im sorry for that!!

Edited by larki_punjaban - 12 years ago

Quote

-GayabCat-

@-GayabCat-

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#114

Originally posted by: -MariaMars-

😆No ways dear.. They are not going to show up definitely... 😛
<div>

and u guys call me a dramaqueen as am too cutie teen.. I should name u guys it rather than me. Buahahaha

Vandu is hilarious
Where r the guys when u expect them to.come bt they dnt

Quote

Me_Anonymous

@Me_Anonymous

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#115

Originally posted by: togepe30
Arey KSG ka supreme drama hua tha...
The judges used to insult him left right and centre...coz people better than him were getting out and he never used to come in danger thanx to voting...

So many times the judges have indirectly taunted him and asked him to leave on his own...

The first chance they got they made him leave...top 3 me se they made him leave on Day 1 of finale week and Gauhar and Baichung danced off in finale...! Gauhar messed up sumthing...so Baichung got the advantage of it...Kuch toh hua tha...she missed a lift or fell or sumthing...dont remember !

But KSG ka bahut tamasha bana diya tha from the 3rd week they had started targetting him...these judges are lenient...That time it was Farah and two other...Farah band baja deti hai...shez not like Remo at all...If she was here...Bharti ki bhi baja deti wo !

[note: I am pointing to you in this post but talking generally here so please don't feel like I am being rude or disrecpectful toward you😳]

But that wasn't his fault, was it? (the judges should have realised it too) I guess the judges wanted him to justify his staying in JDJ through hardwork and dancing and not just votes.

I did watch a few performances from last seasons (as sometimes references to old seasons are made) and watched this one performance of KSG where the judges were commenting or rather should I say bullying him with a capital 'B'.

See I am fine with constructive criticism but some Judges like Saroj Khan take it to another level altogether. She has this "I am the Best" and "I am Better than you" thing about her. From other celebs interviews and her own too at times, I got this feeling that she thinks she is like above any other human being on earth.

I like these judges (KJo, Madz and Remo) because when they criticise (which is not very frequent and it should be, or perhaps they don't show it on TV) they do it with the respect one deserves as a person, as a human being. They point out the good things (even in a bad performance) and they say the bad things too; only this way can a person improve.

I remember NB2 (was it?), Karan-Gauri were one of the participants (I was never an avid Nach Baliye fan either so didn't watch it religiously but did manage to catch a few episodes here and there) and although they got low marks nearly all the weeks, they got saved by votes each time and they were being criticised/bashed too, either by other contestants, on the forum and at times the judges too. It wasn't their fault they were popular and that their fans were willing spend hundreds to vote for them, was it? Why even include voting then? All the celebs and the judges, too, when they sign on the dotted lines of their contracts should remind themselves over and over again that voting and popularity is the name of the game and that its NOT just a dancing show. It's a contest where performances and popularity/voting go hand-in-hand.

[Quote=khamosshhh] Anyways ppl on dis forum too hv been very harsh on Bharti, but dat's another topic altogether.😃[/quote]

Oh yes, I have seen it too and I was quite disappointed there. Not liking her jokes is okay by me but when such criticism turns into bashing is what I despise and hate about people. I don't like her jokes either and tend to skip over them and I haven't watched her this past Sunday's performance either.

Every person has a limit to which they can improve and Karan-Gauri had reached theirs in NB, too. And I was really happy when the judges pointed out to Sushil in this season that he had reached his limit of dancing, it was perhaps in Week 6 or 7, I think. Not everyone is talented in everything and that includes dancing too.

And I think, Bharti too has reached her limit of dancing. Perhaps she might be able to learn more and improve when she recovers from her back spasms.

I only started watching this season of JDJ5 because I didn't know almost all of the contestants and had a neutral viewpoint when it came to judging each performance. I only knew of Gurmeet (as I watched a few Geet...hui sabse parayi scenes on youtube) and had heard of Isha and Pratyusha's name only. I didn't watch Kisna and never watched Balika Vadhu. And I was quite happy in the first 6-7 weeks as I didn't used to visit any forum back then so didn't know so much hatred (to such as extent of even wishing them harm or cursing them) for any one person or celeb could exist (not talking about any one celeb here but all who have been bashed left, right and centre at one point or another). But in week 8 or 9, I think, I started visiting JDJ5 forum for spoilers and now I even get involved in discussions😆😕

back to the original topic of JDJ5 being scripted/or not:

Do I think JDJ5 is scripted? I don't know. There are times when I do think it is and there are times when I think it's not [and it has nothing to do with any one celeb getting eliminated or getting low scores. It's got more to do with my own reasoning/justification of reality shows, in general, being scripted and all].

There are times when I think it's scripted but to an extent i.e. a winner is pre-decided either at the beginning or in the first few weeks of the competition and all the other contestants are informed that they will be in the competition as long as they are survived by scores and votes but that they won't be getting the trophy in the end even if they reacht he finale.

But then, I think, what's the point of having judges then? Would the judges be okay with having someone else dictate their 'professional opinions'? Also, what about the 'pre-planned-winner'. What is s/he gets low scores, and doesn't get much votes either?

I don't know. I am like a pendulum, neither here nor there😆

p.s. another long essay from my side, ahh, aren't I just sooo proud of myself (sarcasm)?😛😆

Edited by Me_Anonymous - 12 years ago

Quote

Me_Anonymous

@Me_Anonymous

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#116

Originally posted by: togepe30
Aur kya yaar !
Kya bolu main abhi toh...Yehi lag raha hai mereko...

Bhindi bazaar style ..

Remo - 10,000 - 1...10,000 - 2...10,000 - 3...Sold to Isha-Salman

Kjo - 20,000 - 1...20,000 - 2...20,000 - 3...Sold to GC - Shampa

Madhuri - 50,000 - 1...50,000 - 2...50,000 - 3...Sold to Isha-Salman

Yay !! Isha Salman to get Veto this time...OMG...GC will not get 30 iss baar...2 judges nikal gaye changul se...

Isha to channel - Mere weekly remuneration se 60,000 kaat ke Madz and Remo ko de dena..

GC to channel - Mere weekly se kuch mat kaatna...I will write them a check from my daily soap money...Mujhe toh mere fans bacha hi lenge...main to 20,000 me nipat gaya...

Bharti to Channel - Agle hafte se gags kam milenge show me...stale jokes..

Bharti to Remo - Agar marks theek se nahi diye ...to more sleazy jokes coming your way...

Ye main nahi kehti...LOG samajhte hain !😆

😆😆😆😆😆😆😆
I LOVE this👏👏

but becharay Rashmi, Rithvik or Karan kahan gaye? What about them? I feel sad for them now.😉😆

Quote

Daebak

@Daebak

Trailblazer

+ 7

Posted: 12 years ago

#117

Originally posted by: Me_Anonymous

😆😆😆😆😆😆😆
I LOVE this👏👏

but becharay Rashmi, Rithvik or Karan kahan gaye? What about them? I feel sad for them now.😉😆

Karan toh gaya...😆

Ritwik jaane wala hai...Hez already declared ki baba bahut competition hai...mere se kuch nahi hoga...Anyways...lemme do an extension of it...

Karan - Oh no...Mere toh saale paise BMW ki installment pay karne me ja rahe hain...How do i afford paying the judges...Isiliye bola tha beta...Dont be choosy about daily shows...Jo milta hai le le...Kam se kam roz ke paise toh milenge...Aaj main bhi 1 ya 1/2 judge khareed leta...As it is one is already Ga Ga over me...😉😆😆😆

Ritwik - I have no energy left in me as it is...Shooting for the daily soap and then dancing...I better not spend money on buying these judges...I will save my money and go on a holiday to Hawai after I get eliminated...which is going to be SOON !

Rashmi - I am the colours girl Tapasya...Kaash maine leap ke baad show choda na hota...then I wud be getting spl treatment for free...Now I will have to give back to the channel all that me and Nandish earned out of Uttaran...Damn this is Tina Dutta's saazzish 😆😆😆😆 (Shez at loggerheads with tina)😆

Edited by togepe30 - 12 years ago

Quote

SIDMA4EVER

@SIDMA4EVER

Voyager

Posted: 12 years ago

#118

JDJ is scripted and there is no doubt in it.

Quote

Daebak

@Daebak

Trailblazer

+ 7

Posted: 12 years ago

#119

@Me_Anonymous - I read your essay...LOL...Why did you put that PS note for me...As far as I skimmed through your post...there was nothing demeaning in there...But ek baat hai...If you had not put that PS note I wudnt have read such a long post...

Hahahahahhahahaha !! That note made me wonder aisa kya likha hai isne...ROFL ! U smart girl you...:P

I thought you were saying pretty much the same thing as I was...LOL...I dont care what happens to KSG...LOL...I never said it was his fault...Why would anyone quit...they are being paid per week..its their job...If people are being silly enough to vote then their fault...Saroj I agree is FULL of herself...she even berated Madz once when she refused to do her debut film as a director...She said I taught her everything she knows and blah blah...

As for Karan-Gauri...It was embarassing to see them perform...Thats all I will say...I felt bad for their fans...Hahahaha ! Gauri could not dance at all...and the judges were very harsh on them...I felt horrible for hiten...And I was very happy that I am not their fan...Hahaha !

Quote

Me_Anonymous

@Me_Anonymous

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#120

Originally posted by: togepe30
Karan toh gaya...😆
Ritwik jaane wala hai...Hez already declared ki baba bahut competition hai...mere se kuch nahi hoga...Anyways...lemme do an extension of it...

Karan - Oh no...Mere toh saale paise BMW ki installment pay karne me ja rahe hain...How do i afford paying the judges...Isiliye bola tha beta...Dont be choosy about daily shows...Jo milta hai le le...Kam se kam roz ke paise toh milenge...Aaj main bhi 1 ya 1/2 judge khareed leta...As it is one is already Ga Ga over me...😆

Ritwik - I have no energy left in me as it is...Shooting for the daily soap and then dancing...I better not spend money on buying these judges...I will save my money and go on a holiday to Hawai after I get eliminated...which is going to be SOON !

Rashmi - I am the colours girl Tapasya...Kaash maine leap ke baad show choda na hota...then I wud be getting spl treatment for free...Now I will have to give back to the channel all that me and Nandish earned out of Uttaran...Damn this is Tina Dutta's saazzish 😆 (Shez at loggerheads with tina)😆