Isha in the Semi-Finals(?) [All discussion here] - Page 18

Pppl are here saying ...she broked her arm for publicity ...shez wearing that cast for direct entry in semi finale ...isha salman ...pls see 27 , 30 , 30 , 30 ,30 , 30 , 30 , 30 , 29 , 24 , 26 , 30 ,30 , 30 ...
the pair who has already set records for 10 perfect 30s needs any kind of power n sympathy to reach finale ...rite??? they never even got below 24 n scored lame marks like 19 , 18 and 21 ...
Even if u dislike someone n want to bash them ...for god sake ... go find an actual reason n then bash !!! From the start of jhalak ...both r being rant here everyweek with a new invalid point that doesnt make sense ...she is trained ...she is non versatile...shez expressionless ...salman has got no challenge..salman's choreography is repetative...remo is biased toward salman ..she has attitude problem ...they got 0 n got saved ..salman isha k toh fans hi nai jo unhe vote jarein... so show is fixed ...judges saved her wen she din perfrmed bcoz of an injury...they are eating on their money ...she is not perfrming unfair for others ..grt !!...next week she is perfrming ..oh how can she perfrm ..shez injured ...its must be an act and publicity stunt ... she is faking ... !!!
Some ppl need to stop their ranting train ...but they will not as they have got no shame !!!
I just want an answer from gurmeet , rithvik , bharti ,and rashmi fans individually...If any among of them might have dislocated their elbow ...n wud not have perfrmd for two weeks ..wud ur opinion must have been same ...wud u have objected if judges wud have saved them ...???
Another thing ...the most funniest lines i read in last two three pages ...why bharti is not getting a week off ...uska spasm hai ...nd y gurmeet din got veto ..jab uska ankle mai na jane kya hua tha ...Isha perfrmd her bachata routine n they scored 30 ...she was suffering from fever plus she also got leg injury that week ...salman perfrmd their angelic act ..with a back spasm n just a day b4 he was hospitalised for the same ...he bruised his elbow and knee badly b4 his horror act .. still he perfrmd .. ..
Cant u see the difference between fever , spasm and a disolocated elbow ...
stop putting urself down at that level n mock about her injury ...callling it a drama ..its looking insane ...

^^JDJ is weekly performance based show not ur previous performance based show... What if isha has scored good marks from begining of the show...

If i have scored once in than what about the format of the show which has been set... One week performance u are out...

Now i really understand why pratyusha herself took self exit we use to speak the girl did not had her mind to continue... Its clear now because she never wanted other contestants to feel awkward about her tht because of her rules are bent and being colors girl she is favoured... U need a guts to take the decision like pratyusha...
Kudos to her...

Is jdj a overall performance show...? Or weekly based show ?

What if isha Is a good dancer ofcourse she will be a dancing guru to many ppl as she runs her own school of dancing... Did not she once told that i don't want a injustice done on other contestants .
Atleast sushant on last season told he will take self exit but isha is saying she is attached to jdj forum she wants to win...

She is not yet all thinking of other aspect of its totally unfair on other contestants that's where the morality exists... ?

Originally posted by: bhavya

^^JDJ is weekly performance based show not ur previous performance based show... What if isha has scored good marks from begining of the show...

If i have scored once in than what about the format of the show which has been set... One week performance u are out...

Now i really understand why pratyusha herself took self exit we use to speak the girl did not had her mind to continue... Its clear now because she never wanted other contestants to feel awkward about her tht because of her rules are bent and being colors girl she is favoured... U need a guts to take the decision like pratyusha...
Kudos to her...

Is jdj a overall performance show...? Or weekly based show ?

What if isha Is a good dancer ofcourse she will be a dancing guru to many ppl as she runs her own school of dancing... Did not she once told that i don't want a injustice done on other contestants .
Atleast sushant on last season told he will take self exit but isha is saying she is attached to jdj forum she wants to win...

She is not yet all thinking of other aspect of its totally unfair on other contestants that's where the morality exists... ?

@bold did she personally told u all ths ..or ur her mind reader...she wanted to quit as schedule was taking a toll on her health ...shez weak ...but b4 she quits ...she got eliminated ...good for her ...isha is a strong woman ...she wants to fight ..she wants to come back ...n wats wrong if she wants to win ...everybdy is dancing their to win ...koi social service nai kar rha ...now ur last 4 words ...suits u the best and ur anti salman isha group !!!
rest of ur words ... as usual doesnt making sense ...

^^what if ... We post anything against isha it does not mean i am a anti isha fan...

Again where i have mentioned and in any group to be labelled as anti isha group...

Funny again...?
This thread is about isha in semi finals... Not about members are in which group... ?
If we post anything on isha why will u start telling u are not isha fan... Does this is isha AT or what ?

No right its a thread on isha in semifinals... Any one can comment on isha it can be favoured on isha and also against isha... It does no where mentioned that only appreciation should be added pls avoid the personnel dictation... To others... Topic should be only around isha.. Not on either u and me here... If i am not wrong...

Originally posted by: salmangirl

@bold did she personally told u all ths ..or ur her mind reader...she wanted to quit as schedule was taking a toll on her health ...shez weak ...but b4 she quits ...she got eliminated ...good for her ...isha is a strong woman ...she wants to fight ..she wants to come back ...n wats wrong if she wants to win ...everybdy is dancing their to win ...koi social service nai kar rha ...now ur last 4 words ...suits u the best and ur anti salman isha group !!!
rest of ur words ... as usual doesnt making sense ...


Leave it Varsha, the person is lecturing that the thread is about Isha and she herself is bringing Pratyashu and Sushant in the discussion didn't she just say that it should be only about Isha not you or me or anyone. Talk about morality 😆😆

You know about "been bajana" 😉 not worth the time yaar !!!

I loved that judges used the VETO on the right person and not someone who didn't know abc of dancing. Thank God judges don't fall for fake drama and know who is worth the VETO. I know she might not even win this thing, but judges by using VETO have proved that she is the most deserving contestant of this stage.

Originally posted by: salmangirl

Pppl are here saying ...she broked her arm for publicity ...shez wearing that cast for direct entry in semi finale ...isha salman ...pls see 27 , 30 , 30 , 30 ,30 , 30 , 30 , 30 , 29 , 24 , 26 , 30 ,30 , 30 ...
the pair who has already set records for 10 perfect 30s needs any kind of power n sympathy to reach finale ...rite??? they never even got below 24 n scored lame marks like 19 , 18 and 21 ...
Even if u dislike someone n want to bash them ...for god sake ... go find an actual reason n then bash !!! From the start of jhalak ...both r being rant here everyweek with a new invalid point that doesnt make sense ...she is trained ...she is non versatile...shez expressionless ...salman has got no challenge..salman's choreography is repetative...remo is biased toward salman ..she has attitude problem ...they got 0 n got saved ..salman isha k toh fans hi nai jo unhe vote jarein... so show is fixed ...judges saved her wen she din perfrmed bcoz of an injury...they are eating on their money ...she is not perfrming unfair for others ..grt !!...next week she is perfrming ..oh how can she perfrm ..shez injured ...its must be an act and publicity stunt ... she is faking ... !!!
Some ppl need to stop their ranting train ...but they will not as they have got no shame !!!
I just want an answer from gurmeet , rithvik , bharti ,and rashmi fans individually...If any among of them might have dislocated their elbow ...n wud not have perfrmd for two weeks ..wud ur opinion must have been same ...wud u have objected if judges wud have saved them ...???
Another thing ...the most funniest lines i read in last two three pages ...why bharti is not getting a week off ...uska spasm hai ...nd y gurmeet din got veto ..jab uska ankle mai na jane kya hua tha ...Isha perfrmd her bachata routine n they scored 30 ...she was suffering from fever plus she also got leg injury that week ...salman perfrmd their angelic act ..with a back spasm n just a day b4 he was hospitalised for the same ...he bruised his elbow and knee badly b4 his horror act .. still he perfrmd .. ..
Cant u see the difference between fever , spasm and a disolocated elbow ...
stop putting urself down at that level n mock about her injury ...callling it a drama ..its looking insane ...

Wow Varsha very well put, it makes me laugh when ridiculous comparisons are happening. Pratyashu got eliminated by votes, It was told to us by channels, phir bhi log peecha nahi chodte, still same old ghisi piti tape bhaja rahe hain. It's so true that love her, hate her but one can't ignore her. No wonder this forum looks dead without her performances😉

I can understand fans writing multiple posts for their favorites, but it looks ridiculous for someone to waste their time and energy on someone they don't even like 😆😆 Badi kadar hai Ishaji ki 😛

Originally posted by: bhavya

^^JDJ is weekly performance based show not ur previous performance based show... What if isha has scored good marks from begining of the show...

If i have scored once in than what about the format of the show which has been set... One week performance u are out...

Now i really understand why pratyusha herself took self exit we use to speak the girl did not had her mind to continue... Its clear now because she never wanted other contestants to feel awkward about her tht because of her rules are bent and being colors girl she is favoured... U need a guts to take the decision like pratyusha...
Kudos to her...

Is jdj a overall performance show...? Or weekly based show ?

What if isha Is a good dancer ofcourse she will be a dancing guru to many ppl as she runs her own school of dancing... Did not she once told that i don't want a injustice done on other contestants .

Atleast sushant on last season told he will take self exit but isha is saying she is attached to jdj forum she wants to win...

She is not yet all thinking of other aspect of its totally unfair on other contestants that's where the morality exists... ?

ahhh I thought I was done commenting on this topic... I think I did mention this and so did a lot of other people that Pratyusha was ELIMINATED - she didn't quit herself. She didn't get enough votes - at least that is what was implied by the way they did the whole elimination thing that episode.

[this section is in response to Isha's 'morality' you talked about]:

You are right - JDJ is a weekly performance based show - but it's a very real part of contestants life too. There are times when we (as in common people) cannot perform to our fullest due to unforseen terrible circumstances like medical reasons and we put forward our previous work to show that we have done this in the past and that if we had the opportunity we could have done this. Why, then, do we not think about unfairness to others? Why is it that when it comes to us, as in it affects us personally, we say things like 'but it's not fair to me either'? Why such double standards now? [this is in no way to say that you, or anyone else on this thread/forum, is like that but I am talking just generally here].

I am by no means defending Isha's stay in the competition. I, too, think it's unfair to other contestants but it's also unfair to her, too.

Having gone through a similar experience as Isha, I can understand where she is coming from (that is presuming she is the one who really wants to stay in the competition and not that she is being made to stay due to contractual committments). It's unfair to her too and I guess that is why she is retiterating on her previous performances - that she has done well before and if this unfortunate accident had not happened she would have given her best now too. How good have her performances been? That differs from individual to individual (but I think, she means the Judges scores and the fact that she is still in due to votes (not week 12,13 though)).

p.s. I remember someone mentioned this being JUST and being FAIR thing in the topic earlier and I have to say, kudos to that person who wrote that because, I think, this statement "do we want to be JUST or do we want to be fair?" sums up this whole Isha-situation.

Originally posted by: Me_Anonymous

ahhh I thought I was done commenting on this topic... I think I did mention this and so did a lot of other people that Pratyusha was ELIMINATED - she didn't quit herself. She didn't get enough votes - at least that is what was implied by the way they did the whole elimination thing that episode.

[this section is in response to Isha's 'morality' you talked about]:

You are right - JDJ is a weekly performance based show - but it's a very real part of contestants life too. There are times when we (as in common people) cannot perform to our fullest due to unforseen terrible circumstances like medical reasons and we put forward our previous work to show that we have done this in the past and that if we had the opportunity we could have done this. Why, then, do we not think about unfairness to others? Why is it that when it comes to us, as in it affects us personally, we say things like 'but it's not fair to me either'? Why such double standards now? [this is in no way to say that you, or anyone else on this thread/forum, is like that but I am talking just generally here].

I am by no means defending Isha's stay in the competition. I, too, think it's unfair to other contestants but it's also unfair to her, too.

Having gone through a similar experience as Isha, I can understand where she is coming from (that is presuming she is the one who really wants to stay in the competition and not that she is being made to stay due to contractual committments). It's unfair to her too and I guess that is why she is retiterating on her previous performances - that she has done well before and if this unfortunate accident had not happened she would have given her best now too. How good have her performances been? That differs from individual to individual (but I think, she means the Judges scores and the fact that she is still in due to votes (not week 12,13 though)).

p.s. I remember someone mentioned this being JUST and being FAIR thing in the topic earlier and I have to say, kudos to that person who wrote that because, I think, this statement "do we want to be JUST or do we want to be fair?" sums up this whole Isha-situation.

@underlined: Very well point to bring to others who are only looking through a single perspective while neglecting that of the victim. It must be so difficult for someone to have this huge regret back of her mind when she knew how deserving of a winning candidate she was before her injury.

@pink: Unfortunately it's sad to read people mocking her injury and calling it a drama or fakeness. Whether one is a fan or not, as a human being it is very disappointing to have read such accusations.

The P.S part: I remember reading that as well, kudos to that person for understanding different perspectives and summing it all up 👍🏼

@me -anonymous
agreed to you... But i think isha is already given one week chance and again giving her chance for semi finals...is the problem and votes have saved isha and her zero score can beat up rithwik and karans score is not gone well by JDJ...
And a score of zero how could it beat... A score of above 25...
A rules are bent just because she is hurt ...

And instead of making her to finals and telling she is a good dancer than others... If the judges think so why don't they directly give her a trophy and tell all other in the competition to pack ur bags and go and find some other work as u ppl are not good dancers compared to isha we gave u so many weeks chance but no one could prove that u are a dancer...?

So my again point is... Where is fairness and morality in isha saving... ?

If we like ishas dance that does not mean she should be given a chance to move up the success ladder ...

If so than there should not be any elimination this week and also in coming week...

Don't u think karans wahis elimination is so unfair...and his fan following and his score was no where less than isha... Agreed may be out of sympathy ppl voted for isha... Than what was about the score.. Can it be done equivalent to ishas zero score...

It mean to say that isha voting group has turned out to be bigger than karans wahis...?

Which means now even GC fan base can't beat up ishas fan base?

Where is fairness come in ishas saving till semi finals...

And even if she does well in semi finals and move to finals in top 2 also than if any one else beats her and wins the trophy how can it be justified that... The same isha for whom rules were bent and who is being declared as better dancer than any of the contestants how can she suddenly loose the winning trophy ?

Which means what.. If isha could not win winning trophy if they blame the voters not voted for isha... How can it be ...the same voters who voted for isha not performing and same voters not voting for isha performing in the finale...


So than isha should be winner based on votes and also on performance too..

Her fan base has increased than any other celebrity?

Now if she performs in semifinals also we think both karans , darsheel and next week going to be eliminated contestant are being eliminated in the name of votes again a blind fold ? On viewers and also on eliminated contestants...

@Me- anonymous one more point... I think it was last Wednesday ..isha was not able to move her hands ... And i think tomorrow she will perform ... So okie... In between this 7 days gap... Isha should also practice ...?

So she must be obviously rehearsing now... A broken hand can be healed so easily?

We have sympathy for her broken hand ..but how can a broken elbow can be healed so fast?

It will be a medical miracle or else gods grace...
Even if the elbow is fine... Doctor will always strictly advice not to use that hand roughly for more than 2 months...