Isha in the Semi-Finals(?) [All discussion here]

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

ashumylove

@ashumylove

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#181

Wow ...isha is such a greedy lady, she knows very well that it is unfair to enter into semifinals directly without giving single performance for 3 consecutive weeks. Still she won't back up.

Also, She came on the stage with fractured hand whenever it is time to appeal for votes. Now when she is safe for this week already, she did not show her face.

Quote

3283

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

#182

Someone thinks broken elbow and dislocated elbow is one and the same 😲 And I thought I was done hearing lame statements !!!

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Me_Anonymous

@Me_Anonymous

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#183

Originally posted by: bhavya
@me -anonymous
And a score of zero how could it beat... A score of above 25...

... why don't they directly give her a trophy and tell all other in the competition to pack ur bags and go and find some other work as u ppl are not good dancers compared to isha we gave u so many weeks chance but no one could prove that u are a dancer...?

Where is fairness and morality in isha saving... ?

If we like ishas dance that does not mean she should be given a chance to move up the success ladder ...

If so than there should not be any elimination this week and also in coming week...

Don't u think karans wahis elimination is so unfair...and his fan following and his score was no where less than isha... Agreed may be out of sympathy ppl voted for isha... Than what was about the score.. Can it be done equivalent to ishas zero score...

Where is fairness come in ishas saving till semi finals...

I understand yours and a lot of others who share your sentiments on this topic and I respect it too. I guess, I am the only one here who can't make up her mind whether Isha should have left or stayed😭.

About Isha being saved this week - then I made another topic to enquire about the whole elimination process that is it 50% voting and 50% scores or 60-40 or 30-70 or anything else - I also enquired about how the eliminations were done this week and this is what the people there confirmed:

This week's elimination combined total scores from Week 12 and Week 13 episodes so Isha did have 60 makrs - not 0 as previously thought. Unless we know for sure we can only speculate how the elimination is counted. But if Isha had 60 marks then voting and marks combined togehter COULD have saved her on the 50-50 basis. But that is not the impression I got from previous eliminations where those with high scores were eliminated over those with lowest scores.

Oh sorry, I didn't understand this statement earlier. I thought you were talking about Isha's morality. I can see now you were referring to the Channel and the Judges decision. Sorry, my bad😳

That is a very good point and I think the Channel should have considered this option too. At least this way no one else would have been eliminated either and it would have been fair to everyone - Isha and other contestants (to some extent in the sense that they didn't get eliminated).

The only reason I can come up with is that if Isha leaves (on her own or eliminated as per JDJ5 rules - no performance so out) then whoeever wins will always have this tag "What if Isha had not got injured?", "What if Isha had been in the finals?" - not that "Isha would have been the winner" but just the "What if...?" bit so I think the Channel want the winner to feel like a winner instead of a second-choice-by-accident. In that respect, I think Isha should stay in the competition. At least the winner (whoever it might be) won't feel like a looser because one of the strong contenders had to pull out due to injury.

It's not a show about dancing only, is it? It's about the whole package - the whole performance so others not being good dancers is not really the issue. They are - some are better than others in terms of dance only - but it's the whole performance that gets marked. If it was purely dance then a lot of those who were eliminated earlier would not have been.

But Isha did NOT score 0, did she? She had 60 while Karan had 104. Like I said earlier, unless we know for sure the total number of votes each contestant got we can never be sure how Karan Wahi was eliminated.

About fan bases - I don't think we can really find out whose fan base is bigger - see not everyone from each contestants fan base votes. So we'll never know who got how many votes unless the channel gives an acutal number to us, the viewers. I know I would really like to know the voting numbers and then do my own calculation to see if they really follow the 50-50 rule

Quote

Me_Anonymous

@Me_Anonymous

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#184

Originally posted by: bhavya
@Me- anonymous one more point... I think it was last Wednesday ..isha was not able to move her hands ... And i think tomorrow she will perform ... So okie... In between this 7 days gap... Isha should also practice ...?

So she must be obviously rehearsing now... A broken hand can be healed so easily?

We have sympathy for her broken hand ..but how can a broken elbow can be healed so fast?

It will be a medical miracle or else gods grace...
Even if the elbow is fine... Doctor will always strictly advice not to use that hand roughly for more than 2 months...

That thing has me wondering as well. But one thing I can say is that perhaps she is naturally a fast healer. I had a sprained knee ligament and (apparently) internal bone injury which it has been about nearly over one and a half year and I am still not able to use my leg as I used to before. But I was also told that some people recover within a few weeks as well. So I guess it differs from person to person.

But I would have thought that dislocated elbow would have taken longer to heal. And I guess, she would be taking a lot of heavy painkillers before her performance and while practicing. I know I had to before my physiotherapy sessions. I sometimes have to take them now too before exercising and travelling. So perhaps, she hasn't recovered fully but that she has recovered somewhat. I don't know.

This thing has baffeled me as well so I'll wait till next week to make up my mind about how serious was the injury or wasn't that serious.

Quote

3283

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

#185

Originally posted by: Me_Anonymous

That thing has me wondering as well. But one thing I can say is that perhaps she is naturally a fast healer. I had a sprained knee ligament and (apparently) internal bone injury which it has been about nearly over one and a half year and I am still not able to use my leg as I used to before. But I was also told that some people recover within a few weeks as well. So I guess it differs from person to person.

But I would have thought that dislocated elbow would have taken longer to heal. And I guess, she would be taking a lot of heavy painkillers before her performance and while practicing. I know I had to before my physiotherapy sessions. I sometimes have to take them now too before exercising and travelling. So perhaps, she hasn't recovered fully but that she has recovered somewhat. I don't know.

This thing has baffeled me as well so I'll wait till next week to make up my mind about how serious was the injury or wasn't that serious.

You know Aji at the hospitals, I have seen people with fractures or dislocated bones, and you are right it does depend from person to person, also on the severity of the injury. Some dislocated elbows are without any fractures and heal faster, while others have fractures involved, which of course take longer. And as you said we'll have to wait and see if she has recovered fully or just dancing away with somewhat of the recovery consuming painkillers and such. As per the insider, she is still dancing with the cast on, so I am not really sure how is she going to perform.

Edited by -Chandramukhi- - 12 years ago

Quote

Parijatrocks

@Peacefulmind

Trailblazer

+ 5

Posted: 12 years ago

#186

@me-anonymous...

Very well said... And agreed to both ur reply posts...

One thing is clear... Whether isha fan or non-isha fan almost everyone have this doubt of isha injury and the fairness of isha in competition ?
That's it... Just a doubt in mind whatever we argue from rare ends... Nothing is going to affect the JDJ and its contestants...?

Quote

Me_Anonymous

@Me_Anonymous

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#187

^^ exactly. Nothing is going to change anything so we might as well be civil toward each other. But that's why there is this topic so both sides can put forward their arguements - not Isha-fan or Isha-bashers but those for her jump to semi-finals and those against it.

Like I said earlier, I can't make up my mind so I am in the middle (so technically speaking my opinion here is not of that much value with regards to this discussion topic) but I am sure there are plenty others who have made up their mind and are sticking to that side.

Quote

826374

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

#188

Originally posted by: salmangirl
she was ready to quit the show by herself as i read in articles...plus she voted out n then got eliminated ..mark my words...
wat does nonsense means here ... wud u explain ?? they also have fans who votes for them ..ok plus y shud she step herself out ??...shez working hard from last 11 weeks ...to take voluntary exist in the end just bcoz of an injury !!!
this comment is rather more stupid ...recovering period depends upon the degree of injury ...vaise b since the tym she has got injured ...everyone has either broken their hand or legs ...n kuch toh apne rishtedaaron k b haath paanv broken hone ka xample de rhe ... 😆
already explained
pls let her do ...itni chid kyun mach rai aapko ...apne thodi trophy milni hai ... sme other contestant can only dream of getting back to back 30s

im very sure usey votes aa rhey hain ...if no then colours kyu apna loss karega ...what the meaning of keeping a asa cleb jisey vote nhi aa rhey 😕

its very clear esha ko votes aa rhey hain , if no then abhi vo out hoti ...at the end channal wants to earn their money n esha vo de rhi hai