Judges can't underscore Isha: here's why

Page

Next Last

cl0wn

@cl0wn

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

Firstly, Isha and Salman are my absolute favourites and only they deserve to win the show. However, I tried to understand the psychology of the Isha-haters out here who feel that Isha only does gymnastics-type dances every week and keeps repeating the same thing over and over again but they're amazed how the judges give her a perfect 30 almost all the time. Here's why:

Imagine you're from another country and have never seen any of these contestants dancing and today was the first time you saw each one dance. Pick any one performance of Isha (e.g. Zindagi ka Safar) and imagine watching only that one performance of hers. I'm almost 100% sure that you would feel she's brilliant and instantly give her a perfect 30.

What I'm trying to say is that the judges are supposed to rate INDIVIDUAL performances everytime. And each individual performance of Isha-Salman is PERFECT.

This is exactly the reason why the judges can't underscore Isha under the excuse of repeating acrobatic moves because the flawlessness of an INDIVIDUAL performance weighs higher than versatility.

Ofcourse, I personally don't feel she's that repetitive at all, but for those who do, it's just that she uses a bit of her acrobatics in every dance and that's all. It's her strength. Remember again, each INDIVIDUAL performance counts more than comparing the performance with past performances!

Edited by cl0wn - 12 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

Ajnabee

@*Woh Ajnabee*

Stunner

Posted: 12 years ago

When Karan Wahi can get such praise for his mediocre contemporary performance today (8s and 9s?!?), then the judges have no choice but to give Isha and Salman a 10/10 each time! It's only fair. You might not like the dance forms they choose, but it's really hard to argue that their performances are even slightly flawed.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

-Eris-

@-Eris-

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

Every performance is perfect. 30 to banta hai boss!!

Quote

Rapier

@Rapier

Rocker

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: *Woh Ajnabee*
When Karan Wahi can get such praise for his mediocre contemporary performance today (8s and 9s?!?), then the judges have no choice but to give Isha and Salman a 10/10 each time! It's only fair. You might not like the dance forms they choose, but it's really hard to argue that their performances are even slightly flawed.

Some members have tried that too.😆 @topic: The main reason I think (someone else also pointed this out in a different thread) many people perceive all of her performances to be the same is because many of her performances are of the same pace. Not many of performances were all upbeat. This is not an excuse or a good enough reason to accuse her of not being versatile, because the whole suggestion of this is preposterous, but I believe that this may be the case. People look at Isha doing a slow backflip in her aerial performance, and they see Isha doing a slow backflip in her Paso Doble, and they go "She repeated that move. This performance was just like her aerial dance."🤔 I think this is the mindset.

Quote

RAJ

@MrChatVsNorway

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

I want to see isha wearing a ghagra choli and dance to proper bollywood numbers because she was unconvincing in the bollywood round when for the first time she tried something stereotypical but failed miserably..or let her do kathak or any dance where the music will be upbeat and instead of gymnastic there will be immaculate hand and foot movements ..why isnt she jigging to her own kisna song?wonder why..until then she will remain an incomplete performer in my eyes...

Quote

0o0o0o0o0o

@0o0o0o0o0o

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

Actually JUDGES underscore them by GIVING 30 -- these guys deserve 60 marks for their flawless performances -@@

Quote

khamosshhh

@khamosshhh

Stunner

+ 4

Posted: 12 years ago

Yeah Isha is so aheda of the others tht the judges have no choice but to give her a 30. Also Isha-Slaman hv been given 30s along wid other contastants, when their performaces were way ahead of dem, but marks was it was at par marks. So it's justified if dey get 30.

They r so ahead in the line that for dem the line is a dot, as Joey woud have said.😆😆😆

Quote

3283

Suspended

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: khamosshhh
Yeah Isha is so aheda of the others tht the judges have no choice but to give her a 30. Also Isha-Slaman hv been given 30s along wid other contastants, when their performaces were way ahead of dem, but marks was it was at par marks. So it's justified if dey get 30.

They r so ahead in the line that for dem the line is a dot, as Joey woud have said.😆😆😆

hahahaha, love Joey 😳

And yes I agree with TM's theory, makes sense to me 👍🏼

Edited by -Chandramukhi- - 12 years ago

Quote

cl0wn

@cl0wn

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: rajluvsshvpavti
I want to see isha wearing a ghagra choli and dance to proper bollywood numbers because she was unconvincing in the bollywood round when for the first time she tried something stereotypical but failed miserably..or let her do kathak or any dance where the music will be upbeat and instead of gymnastic there will be immaculate hand and foot movements ..why isnt she jigging to her own kisna song?wonder why..until then she will remain an incomplete performer in my eyes...

Kathak or Bollywood numbers rarely get 10 because besides the hand and leg movements, they've got nothing to show... on the other hand, do some great lifts and sexy dancing and a 10 is guaranteed...I would always choose the latter... they're far more entertaining than a boring kathak or whatever.. lol

Although, I'm 100% sure she will pull one of those out of her hat soon.. and will score perfect on that as well... just that, it's too difficult for anyone to get that kind of a score on such boring dance forms 🤢

Edited by cl0wn - 12 years ago