Originally posted by: sheeba_hasan
Gawd! The ignorance level of ppl in this forum really baffles me! Let me make it very clear, I'm NOT a die hard fan of Isha n Salman. I like Karan! Lol! But as someone who's trained in these international dance forms, I Thot I shud give my opinion.
The theme was Zara Hatke! Now some contestants like Rashmi n Karan interpreted it as doing a Hatke concept altogether. While most contestants took it as doin something they have never attempted before.
Bharti did Rumba
Gurmeet did zouk
Ritvik did floor contemporary!
Isha did TANGO!!! It's not SALSA!!!
May I ask Wat was so Hatke about ritvik s performance? Was there any story? Or any Hatke concept? And u have seen ritvik do contemporary on this stage. It looked similar to me!!!
Even bharti for tht matter, we ve seen her pull of similar gags before. But no, ppl wud just go ahead n bash Isha! Let's accept it, she is the BEST! And to all those who think this is a stage for non dancers, then only Bharti n Karan deserve to be here! Coz the rest are all trained in some form or the other!
I rest my case!
Cheers!!
All I see in this post is people trying to argue by putting others down in terms of their opinion. I mean really, poking at someone's language or deciphering skills is the way you wanna defend your viewpoints. Sad. And please don't term someone's opinion as bashing.
Anyways, I agree with your points. Most of them did things that where done before. I thought Rithvik had done contemporary in his 2nd or 3rd performance. And the whole concept, i didn't anything new.
In terms of Isha, people will see what they want to see and ignore the rest, it's fine. Even if some of her moves might look similar to you, she has done a different dance form all together, Tango, she hasn't attempted this dance form in her earlier performances. So I think she has stuck to the theme and I liked it and since I am not good at technicalities, I simply trust judges with it.
GC I think hasn't done zouk earlier, so I think he stuck to the theme as well and I liked it. How well he did, leave it to the judges.
Bharti, don't watch many of her performances, so I am not sure if she had done rumba before or not.
Rashmi attempted a new dance form as well. And I love this duo whenever they come on dance. But this time it was an ok performance for me, didn't like it as much. I didn't find the difficulty level, it was quite simple for me and even Remo pointed it out.
Haven't seen Karan's yet, will edit later.
Edited by -Chandramukhi- - 13 years ago