~||ViTharv AT 51 #Vividha Sirf Atharva Ki Hai Aur Rahegi||~ note pg67 - Page 7

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.1k

Views

50.1k

Users

41

Likes

2.4k

Frequent Posters

taraka2005 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#61

Originally posted by: -JC-

like there was no emotion when Vivi was talking to Athu today? When he was lamenting the loss of what he thought was family...his despair in finding himself alone...Vivi clearly was emotional but was biting her tears back. He voice went up several notches after the question from Atharv when she accused Suman of all wrong doings.

thank you JC ...ur review abt Viv...is just supporting my view...for a moment i thought only I cld felt the emotion in that scene...m I being Delu ? I asked myself ..πŸ˜†
Even the moment she found out Atharv is not der and in car when they following bua ... I cld see fear on her face...that I might lost him again ...khair it's too early to say smthg about that...ll wait
anu023 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#62

Originally posted by: -JC-


You are saying that Vividha should have sensed that he did all this for her good and she should have imagined him running back to her to marry her after leaving her in the mandap and then she should have also had the 6th sense to know that he got hit on the head again and thats why he didn't return?

She could have confronted sujatha atleast..or tried to find out why atharv did what he did.

She is the same woman who did not care about anything and went looking for her 'ex' in a terrorist prone area.. shr could have done the same for the person she "claimed to love"
πŸ₯±
taraka2005 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#63
Happy Ugadi everyone who celebrates πŸ˜ƒ
-JC- thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#64

Originally posted by: anu023

@jc i somehow feel all the neglect she faced both from draconian dadaji and ramakant-suman had turned bua bitter. If people can say suman isn't wrong..i feel bua isn't wrong either..Bua deserves to be forgiven and not suman..

I am sure if they show a leap of 20 odd years now..aditi would be reflection of kalindi..for she was treat3d the same way as kalindi..

πŸ˜† You are right there. Kalindi has more justification for her actions...which honestly I don't think are to the level of Suman because I think the CVs have masterfully implicated Bua but infact she is not the one to master plan any of this. She is only guilty of greed and taking this last opportunity that presented itself today. If she was capable of this level of planning she would have never lived under the rule of a fool like Suman for so long.

And yeah i did watch the episode..but i.am.sorry vividha looked more concerned for her offender's son than atharv and madhav..

Lets agree to disagree there. I feel you have biased views for anyone who shows sympathy for a character of the other side. And I don't believe in black and white choices, especially where human emotions are involved.

And i think except suman evryone looked plastic..
Though in my opinion.smita is a bad actress ..yesterday she was ok
True that. Smita ji did a fabulous job of depicting Suman's mental state. I was pleasantly surprised. I definitely don't think VSC was plastic. He can't be even if he wants to be. There was not a single frame of his looking less than what a confused and dizzy Raghav's expression should be in the situation. IMHO Shivani too lived up to the situation she was given. The focus of the dialogs was clearly less about Raghav's confusion and more about the blame game. I wouldn't discount Shivani's acting skills for it. Sujatha however lacked the necessary force in her voice or outrage in her face. Instead she seemed to be sad over her sauten's imbalanced state of mind.

-JC- thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#65

Originally posted by: anu023

She could have confronted sujatha atleast..or tried to find out why atharv did what he did.

She is the same woman who did not care about anything and went looking for her 'ex' in a terrorist prone area.. shr could have done the same for the person she "claimed to love"
πŸ₯±


Why would she do that when she has no reason to believe that Atharv is in any danger or that he didn't leave her of his own choice. When someone you love wants to move away from you, you can ask for the reason only to that person, not that person's mother. When someone you love doesn't give you a valid enough reason but still pushes you away, you can only plead until you start loathing yourself for having no self-respect. When someone you love and who claimed to love you enough to fight death for you, leaves you high and dry, you can only imagine that people change and grow apart sometimes as they gain experience and grow wiser.

Vividha tired her best to talk sense to Atharv. She tried her best to understand why he was pushing her away. But Atharv did everything possible to make it impossible for Vividha to keep her faith in him. I don't blame her for not looking for him in 4 years.

Whether her decision to marry some one who came as a baraati to her wedding is right or wrong, is a debate we can have. And I am sure i'll not support that decision. But I can empathize that she did it out of impulse and anger and later regretted it. Does she deserve to eat the fruits of her impulsive decisions...yes. She made a choice and she must face the consequences of it.
Edited by -JC- - 8 years ago
anu023 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#66
I really don't mind being called biased because i know i am not.
I can give a 100 justifications as to why vividha's love isn't as deeper as atharv's .
I don't buy the logic of she could have aborted madhav if she wanted to if her love for atharv is shallow either..
Kailash kashyap and his kids are opportunistic though vividha is a lot better.
What surprises me here is inspite of suman telling her everything starting from why atharv left her or why he doesn't remember anything she still looked disinterested
She was more concerned about "others" and failed to.notice atharv missing until she finished her "oh so mahaan" speech.
Vikram did act well but smita overshadowed everyone
Shivani did not.live upto my expectations.i blame poor writing and direction for that.
Well what was supposed to be an.episode that gives importance to suman-atharv-madhav was made to look something else..
Well lets not argue anymore.
i really can't praise someone because they did good in past. I.live in present and give my opinion.based on present scenario.
-JC- thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#67

Originally posted by: ..sairat..

thank you JC ...ur review abt Viv...is just supporting my view...for a moment i thought only I cld felt the emotion in that scene...m I being Delu ? I asked myself ..πŸ˜†

Even the moment she found out Atharv is not der and in car when they following bua ... I cld see fear on her face...that I might lost him again ...khair it's too early to say smthg about that...ll wait


She was the first one to notice that he was not present. And you are right everything stopped when she realized he is missing. πŸ˜† And yet some people feel that she doesn't care about him. All her detectivegiri gayi tel lene..including her son was left with others..the son that she just saved from the clutches of death...usko chod ke bhaagi Atharv ko bachaane and yet questions are raised on her feelings.
anu023 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#68

Originally posted by: -JC-


She was the first one to notice that he was not present. And you are right everything stopped when she realized he is missing. πŸ˜† And yet some people feel that she doesn't care about him. All her detectivegiri gayi tel lene..including her son was left with others..the son that she just saved from the clutches of death...usko chod ke bhaagi Atharv ko bachaane and yet questions are raised on her feelings.

U don't need to indirectly taunt anyone. Everyone is entitled to their opinion.
And as to seeing world as black and white i am.not a schizophrenic to think.that way. As i already said i live in present and i dont really have to look into how much vividha "loves" atharv. She ran to save atharv like she did to save payal or suman's son earlier.
Everyone is equal to her.

_OrChiD_ thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#69

Originally posted by: ..sairat..

thank you JC ...ur review abt Viv...is just supporting my view...for a moment i thought only I cld felt the emotion in that scene...m I being Delu ? I asked myself ..πŸ˜†

Even the moment she found out Atharv is not der and in car when they following bua ... I cld see fear on her face...that I might lost him again ...khair it's too early to say smthg about that...ll wait


You've missed I said too, πŸ˜† Vividha had some emotion when Atharva said I've no one but screenplay jumped to figuring out the nonexistent murder that everyone was pissed off and Vividha's short-lived emotion gone unnoticed because of lame screenplay.
-JC- thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#70

Originally posted by: anu023

U don't need to indirectly taunt anyone. Everyone is entitled to their opinion.
And as to seeing world as black and white i am.not a schizophrenic to think.that way. As i already said i live in present and i dont really have to look into how much vividha "loves" atharv. She ran to save atharv like she did to save payal or suman's son earlier.
Everyone is equal to her.


Anu please don't take offense at my opinions. I never taunt indirectly. I have quoted your posts where I felt like saying something about what you said. You are not the only one who felt that Vividha lacked emotions or doesn't care about Athu anymore. I made a general statement to everyone who felt that way. And it is not schizophrenics who see the world as black and white. It is highly principled people who believe that everything is either good or bad and there is no scope of confusion or mixed feelings that see the world as black and white only. And you present a good point. Everything is equal to her. She ran to save payal and Ravish too. She also ran to save her son. That must also be because she treats him the same as Payal and Ravish. And therefore there is no surprise that she left her son to go save Atharv. She just runs to save everyone and anyone because she has no feelings for anyone...or she feels equal amount of love for everyone.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".