My Analysis: Please Comment Your Views!

rp5127 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#1

DISCLAIMER: THIS POST IS NOT MEANT TO HURT ANY ACTOR, SHOW, OR FAN, BUT IS SIMPLY A PURELY ANALYTICAL POST! Therefore, I will not mention the names of other shows, but only mention the plots, as I am analyzing plots, not actors or shows. I apologize in advance if this post is hurtful! I am open to discussion and would be happy to reconsider any of my views.


There have been quite a few fans of Jamai Raja who have lately been upset by the fact that Siddharth is still working for the happiness of Roshni, despite the fact that she got married to Neil, and I completely understand the unhappiness that we, as SidNi fans, face. However, we must also take into account that Siddharth is the main character of this show, not Roshni. As the male lead, Jamai Raja is about the ups and downs of Siddharth, the Jamai, not Roshni, the bahu. In a female-centered television world, we see women who constantly wait for men, even though they have an extra-marital affair, women who deal with constant torture from their husband and in-laws, women who continue loving and praying for their husbands despite his distrust on their characters. As a male-centered show, now a man's suffering is shown. Why is it that, as a society, we are okay with watching shows that have a woman suffering, but when a man suffers, it creates such unrest among a fan following? Jamai Raja is a progressive show, and it is displaying Siddharth's point of view.


As a loyal fan of Jamai Raja, SidNi, and NiVi, I would like to make the people of the forum reconsider their views of Siddharth's "mahanta," and compare it to other shows that you may be watching. If a woman can be in pain for a man's happiness, why can't the man? Wasn't this the whole concept of Jamai Raja, that if a woman could take the responsibility of the household, why can't the man?


As I have stated earlier, I am open to discussion, so please do comment your views below.

Humbly,

Roshni

An ardent Jamai Raja Fan

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

763

Users

5

Likes

18

Frequent Posters

babithaj thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Hats off to you for this ost... and I completely agree with the points you have stated... But one thing, mainly fans are upset with the love Roshni has on Sid and vice versa... Cvs call it eternal love, then how could Roshni not knowing his touch and Neil's ... and how could she not understanding him better than anybody else...
nehanv thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Its just my view...i agree with you...but its not about mahaan bahu or mahaan jamai...they can show a balanced view as well...
nehanv thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
As far as sid forgiving roshni is concerned its his true love...actually love should be tht way ...unconditional n forgiving...
as far as roshni is concerned not everybody can love lk sid...sid has accepted her wt her shortcomings
imaginative thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
Like really?😆 Do u think the people in the forum are upset with SID SUFFERING🤣 He can suffer or cry or get beaten up.. It happened in season 1 too and no one cares a damn😆
Here the issue is with bad characterization of Roshni and SidNi love🤢 Sid's mahanata we have seen and there are many Ekta crap shows where doormat bahus do the same.. We accept here the doormat is Sid.. But can u tell me a single show where a heroine wanted to fix her husband with a mental patient, arrange date for them etc etc... These cheap things are done by Sid🥱

I'm not arguing, there are people who like doormat bahu heroine shows, like wise people can enjoy doormat jamai show too. They can show all vulgarity like Roshni romancing 2 man, Sid arranging for their suhagraat etc.. The only issue is Ashvini Yardi shouldn't have advertised it as "Unique show" or "Eternal love"
Even being a NiVi or SidNi fan I will say JAMAI RAJA SEASON 2 is the worst story ever🤢🤢 I have watched many Ekta shows, but only a few have stooped this level🤢

Sorry if I offended LOYAL fans...PEACE
sabreen_06 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: imaginative

Like really?😆 Do u think the people in the forum are upset with SID SUFFERING🤣 He can suffer or cry or get beaten up.. It happened in season 1 too and no one cares a damn😆

Here the issue is with bad characterization of Roshni and SidNi love🤢 Sid's mahanata we have seen and there are many Ekta crap shows where doormat bahus do the same.. We accept here the doormat is Sid.. But can u tell me a single show where a heroine wanted to fix her husband with a mental patient, arrange date for them etc etc... These cheap things are done by Sid🥱

I'm not arguing, there are people who like doormat bahu heroine shows, like wise people can enjoy doormat jamai show too. They can show all vulgarity like Roshni romancing 2 man, Sid arranging for their suhagraat etc.. The only issue is Ashvini Yardi shouldn't have advertised it as "Unique show" or "Eternal love"
Even being a NiVi or SidNi fan I will say JAMAI RAJA SEASON 2 is the worst story ever🤢🤢 I have watched many Ekta shows, but only a few have stooped this level🤢

Sorry if I offended LOYAL fans...PEACE

Agree with u as we are upset with sid bcuz he want to fix her ex wife with mental patient 🤢which is difficult to digest
rp5127 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: imaginative

Like really?😆 Do u think the people in the forum are upset with SID SUFFERING🤣 He can suffer or cry or get beaten up.. It happened in season 1 too and no one cares a damn😆

Here the issue is with bad characterization of Roshni and SidNi love🤢 Sid's mahanata we have seen and there are many Ekta crap shows where doormat bahus do the same.. We accept here the doormat is Sid.. But can u tell me a single show where a heroine wanted to fix her husband with a mental patient, arrange date for them etc etc... These cheap things are done by Sid🥱

I'm not arguing, there are people who like doormat bahu heroine shows, like wise people can enjoy doormat jamai show too. They can show all vulgarity like Roshni romancing 2 man, Sid arranging for their suhagraat etc.. The only issue is Ashvini Yardi shouldn't have advertised it as "Unique show" or "Eternal love"
Even being a NiVi or SidNi fan I will say JAMAI RAJA SEASON 2 is the worst story ever🤢🤢 I have watched many Ekta shows, but only a few have stooped this level🤢

Sorry if I offended LOYAL fans...PEACE


I understand your views, but I really do not appreciate your tone. If you really think JR S2 "is the worst story ever," to use your phrase, why are you still watching? Just my opinion that you should stop watching if you really don't like the show.

Roshni
imaginative thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: rp5127


I understand your views, but I really do not appreciate your tone. If you really think JR S2 "is the worst story ever," to use your phrase, why are you still watching? Just my opinion that you should stop watching if you really don't like the show.

Roshni


Did I tell u somewhere that I'm still watching the show?🥱 I'm not watching but only reading WU.. now whether I come on the forum, read WU or have my opinions about the show is none of ur business. I'm not a new member or new to the show have watched it from 1st epi till 500 epi, so when the story is the worst now u'll always have hope of it getting redeemed. U don't need to advice me on whether to watch the show or appreciate it even when I find the show pathetic.
rp5127 thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: imaginative


Did I tell u somewhere that I'm still watching the show?🥱 I'm not watching but only reading WU.. now whether I come on the forum, read WU or have my opinions about the show is none of ur business. I'm not a new member or new to the show have watched it from 1st epi till 500 epi, so when the story is the worst now u'll always have hope of it getting redeemed. U don't need to advice me on whether to watch the show or appreciate it even when I find the show pathetic.


When people are nice to me, I am nice back. However, when people become rude, I will also be rude back. My life's motto is Newton's Third Law: Every action has an equal and opposite reaction. You started out by being rude, so you got a rude response back. I still do not appreciate your tone and will be honest about it. I have also watched JR from episode 1, and think that the storyline is not the best. However, you being rude to me is NONE OF YOUR BUSINESS.
Edited by rp5127 - 9 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".