What is Sooo Mahaan about Sid??

fanfare.1 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#1
Can someone explain what has Sid done so great in this track to become MAHAAN??😆 I'm just talking about this Shabnam track (maybe he have been Mahaan earlier, lets put that aside). I have read so many post taunting Sid of being Mahaan for helping Shabnam - Ayesha, but I'm not getting clarity about the reason.😕

Shabnam was brought to Patel house by DD. It was her Mahanata to give shelter to a bechari b'coz Shabnam don't have a place to go and goons are behind her. All of a sudden after knowing she is her step daughter and her husband cheated her, all of her goodness and social service went out of the window and she want to throw Shabnam - Ayesha out of her house at night🥱 Now, the fact remains that they still don't have anywhere to go and something bad can happen when a young women and girl kid roam around on road at night. In such a situation a man with some common sense questioned the decision and prevented them from leaving, considering the fact that the girls have a relation with the family. What is so Mahaan about it??😕 And from the precap, he didn't force his decision on Patels and took Shabnam - Ayesha to his house and provided them a shelter, may temporarily till he makes some other arrangements. What is the Mahanata in that ??😕 Its not like he offered to marry Shabnam to take take care of her🥱 If DD's act of giving shelter to unknown person is not mahaan, how is Sid's act of giving shelter to supposedly a relative in the family a mahaan deed??

Again, Sid stopped Roshni from attacking Shabnam and physically assaulting her. I don't see anything Mahaan in that too.. Any person in sense would stop their wife from pouncing on someone and attacking them like mad for whatever reason. Roshni's anger and hatred is at its own place but trying to pysically harm someone is another thing. If a man pushes a women and does things to Shabnam like what Roshni does u call it domestic violence, physical abuse, torturing women etc.. People are creating uproar on social media about a promo in which the king husband pushing wife Rani in the show Ek Tha Raja, and that push was not a quarter of Roshni's abuse😆 There is so much voices for womens right in shows but when Roshni attacks it is bravery👏, just b'coz a women is attacking a women😲 This is the same forum where someone was claiming Sid is commiting domestic violence and emotional abuse on Roshni b'coz he suggested adoption after her miscarriage🤣 I don't know why those people are not calling this domestic violence🥱 And a husband stopping wife from attacking someone is Mahanata🤢 Then, people want Sid to take Roshni and DD's side, give them time etc.. Give them time for what killing or attacking people🥱 For now he didn't ask them to shower love on Shabnam - Ayesha, just asked them to treat people humanly?? What is so wrong in it??

Now I know Shabnam is evil may all the audience know, so it doesn't matter she is attacked or killed.. But none of the characters in the show know her evilness, for them she is just Shiv's daughter, a member indirectly linked to Patel family.. So, can someone explain what has Sid done so extra ordinary to become Mahaan??😕😕

Edited by daytoday - 10 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

13

Views

1.2k

Users

7

Likes

34

Frequent Posters

madhuharini thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
Ofcourse Shiv moved on in his life after DD left him but the thing is he should ve opened abt this new family to Roshni or atleast DD during his stay in patel's home. For a wife and Daughter, knowing the fact of his husband/dad maintained another family and that too he totally put the whole fiasco out of sight to them is the biggest shock in their life time and they need some time to digest all this😊 In friday epi, he didn't did any mahanta thing but in recent onlocation video, he s advising Roshni to accept Ayesha and Shabnam as behnas and showing lil angry too... This s wht I feel like mahanta😆 Roshni and DD needs some time to come out of the shock and anyone in Roshni's place might also react the way she did... She thought Shabnam played the CD to humiliate her family and so pushed her that way. Sid is also understanding all that and he stood quiet I agree with that. It's humanity that he don't want Shabnam to stay in road at night times, But the thing he wanted DD and Roshni to accept Ayesha & Shabnam is not necessary na😊
Edited by madhuharini - 9 years ago
abinaya98 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
Agree wid u..all we r saying is based on location video as abi said...he s dng so much for a girl..who caused destruction in their family...he should not believe wat is shown to him...he already suffered in misha case..now gibing support to a girl..who they don't know whether she s true or false person😕😆😆
fanfare.1 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: madhuharini

Ofcourse Shiv moved on in his life after DD left him but the thing is he should ve opened abt this new family to Roshni or atleast DD during his stay in patel's home. For a wife and Daughter, knowing the fact of his husband/dad maintained another family and that too he totally put the whole fiasco out of sight to them is the biggest shock in their life time and they need some time to digest all this😊 In friday epi, he didn't did any mahanta thing but in recent onlocation video, he s advising Roshni to accept Ayesha and Shabnam as behnas and showing lil angry too... This s wht I feel like mahanta😆 Roshni and DD needs some time to come out of the shock and anyone in Roshni's place might also react the way she did... She thought Shabnam played the CD to humiliate her family and so pushed her that way. Sid is also understanding all that and he stood quiet I agree with that. It's humanity that he don't want Shabnam to stay in road at night times, But the thing he wanted DD and Roshni to accept Ayesha & Shabnam is not necessary na😊



@bold 😆😆 Ok that is what I asked, I thought I missed something in Friday's episode😆

And about the on location video, Sid was angry saying DD/Roshni tried to kill Shabnam by keeping her in dabba and pouring water (I heard something like that, not sure😕). Maybe DD would have done something. I don't think he was angry for not accepting Shabnam - Ayesha.. I agree it is not right to force DD & Roshni to accept them, but that was not the reason of anger, I suppose..
It would have been understandable if this hyper reaction was after the airing of episode, now no one know in what context he was angry. Anyway, thanks for explaining the reaction was to OLV and not abt the episode😛
fanfare.1 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Abinaya12

Agree wid u..all we r saying is based on location video as abi said...he s dng so much for a girl..who caused destruction in their family...he should not believe wat is shown to him...he already suffered in misha case..now gibing support to a girl..who they don't know whether she s true or false person😕😆😆



@bold That is called foolishness not Mahanata😆 In that case all DD, Roshni, Sid are fools.. They were giving help and support to Ayesha and Shabnam even before the truth was known, without checking about their whereabouts😛
abinaya98 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: daytoday



@bold That is called foolishness not Mahanata😆 In that case all DD, Roshni, Sid are fools.. They were giving help and support to Ayesha and Shabnam even before the truth was known, without checking about their whereabouts😛

Ya..true..DAT..but in d recent epi...rosh nd dd understood she did a plan..but sid didn't na..so may be all thought DAT sid s mahan..dats it..:p
YD.AH thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
i agree with u
but he should not believe all he sees
so many things are deceptive too
he should not expect dd roshni
to accept shabnam so soon
fanfare.1 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: .chandni.

i agree with u

but he should not believe all he sees
so many things are deceptive too
he should not expect dd roshni
to accept shabnam so soon



@bold That's a fact, No one should blindly believe all they see.. But in this show everyone just does that..
madhuharini thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 9 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: daytoday



@bold 😆😆 Ok that is what I asked, I thought I missed something in Friday's episode😆

And about the on location video, Sid was angry saying DD/Roshni tried to kill Shabnam by keeping her in dabba and pouring water (I heard something like that, not sure😕). Maybe DD would have done something. I don't think he was angry for not accepting Shabnam - Ayesha.. I agree it is not right to force DD & Roshni to accept them, but that was not the reason of anger, I suppose..
It would have been understandable if this hyper reaction was after the airing of episode, now no one know in what context he was angry. Anyway, thanks for explaining the reaction was to OLV and not abt the episode😛


lol😆
ok dear, let's see wht will happen😊😛 Also we can see Sid is owner of Khurana builders right, thn why can't he afford Shabnam a room in his hotel or some where other than asking for patels or taking her to his own home😆😕 But butchering one after the other characters is our UNIQUE😆 JR Cvs work na, so we can't expect our characters to use brain always😉😆
YD.AH thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: daytoday



@bold That's a fact, No one should blindly believe all they see.. But in this show everyone just does that..

true

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".