No for Me to IPKKND 3 without SaRun *Comment on PG 5* - Page 5

I totally agree with you and support you on this matter.No to ipkknd 3.

Finally ipkknd 3 forum is opened & feeling good now free from negativity bez I'm really tired of ipkknd 3 discussion.

Honestly,if you dont think you'll like IPK3 then u should just not watch it.

It's been years now,since Ipk ended...some of you guys shouldn't be so upset about this now.

This is my humble opinion,i dont mean to diss anyone..but being this upset about a Show is clearly not the best for anyone.

For me IPKKND is synonymous with Sarun and ArShi. No matter how many versions PH or CH make using IPKKND's name and playing Rabba Ve, the only IPKKND for me will always be Arnav and Khushi s story. Barun and Sanaya were brilliant and unforgettable in the roles of Arnav and Khushi even after so many years. I have not watched season 2 and will not watch season 3 either. But if Barun and Sanaya come back as Arnav and Khushi, I will definitely watch and will fall head over heels in love with ArShi all over again. Hope it happens.

Otherwise for me also 'No Sarun No IPKKND '.

Originally posted by: Nenapinku

Finally ipkknd 3 forum is opened & feeling good now free from negativity bez I'm really tired of ipkknd 3 discussion.

Hi Alisha,
you have PMed me, asking to support you if you are right..

Well I am
going to write few facts here... hope you will get your answers there...

Coming to
first line of your post.. "Heyyy Everyone... Since News about IPKKND 3 has came I Have seen
GulKhan was able to break ArShi STARDOM.. What do you mean by "I Have seen GulKhan
was able to break ArShi STARDOM.. ??????

How will Gul break Arshi STARDOM????😲 I am impressed with your words!!!😆

But I have One Thing for You Guyzzz That Here So Many Peoples are as ArShi Fans
neither Barun or Sanaya Fans... So stop Bashing each other...

Who actually started the bashing game ????

Gul is getting bashed ...bcz she did not casted Sanaya opposite Barun... Calling her names, bad-mouthing etc..etc..etc... Some saying Gul is jealous of Sanaya... What is the base of such idiotic comment ??? Is Gul any actress to be jealous of Sanaya??? In IPKKND, Sanaya was not SP's choice during her first audition... It was Gul who called her for the second time ... why? Because Sanaya fitted in her vision of Khushi... Also there is a misconception over Gul's one reply to some certain fan/fanclub...that she bashed Sanaya.. Why will she do that??? That too in such situation when she is already facing bashing from fandom?? Maximum people being members of such fanclub have fake ids, she actually meant that only.. But like Khushi said to Arnav once.. "Apne
wohi samjha jo aap samajhna chaha " Same applies to Sanaya fans actually...

Then coming to bash Barun... " how could Barun agreed for IPKKND without Sanaya? Again a illogical question... Barun signed the show bcz he was given a choice to choose the character.. which he liked and most importantly is going to be finite series... But yes I would be happy to see Barun and Sanaya in a show together... But if Sanaya is not casted, that is not Barun's fault for him to lose respect in many LOYAL fans' eyes...'

Next coming to title, Barun did said in an IV that when he was offered the role, that time it was not decided to call IPKKND, tentative title is something else... Here let me remind you guys one thing,
that all the BG music, Songs, Title are intellectual property of Production houses and the channel for TV serials.. They have the copyright to their own creation like you guys have to your stories... They can use it for their own benefit, we are no one to question them on using Arshi's song to other couple despite how much we are emotionally attached to it... Itna Arnav and Khushi ka
loyal bhakt ho.. then you must remember Business decisions cannot be taken emotionally...

Next,many were saying we are disappointed on Barun, why??? bcuz he chose the character in such a show which belongs to Arshi/Sarun and that too without Sanaya!!! Kinta bara paap kar dia !! God!! What do you mean by belongs to Arshi/Sarun? Kya do alag insaan ka same name nehi ho sakta!!! Show ka Naam choose karna is not in his hand, then why all these accusations thrown at him???

Suppose you got a job you wanted, but someone of your friend didn't get the job there only, will you leave your job and walk out??? Or many friends/family don't like/approve the company's name, will you leave then just because that name can't be the company's where you are working???? Read and think while answering these questions...

Also tell me have not a film name used more than once??? Kya tab bhi itna logo ka hungama tha??? Ek film mein, the song is made for those characters in film right?? Then how can they be used in other shows and many of you writers also use film songs... why do you use it??? The way you guys are trying to boycott and all, then how you use a song which is exclusively for a film character{in your own words}?? Explain me please...

Let me explain why
you use it... bcz the lyrics of the song suits the situation of the story.. correct me if I am wrong...

And for the similar reason, Rabba ve is being used... And for IPKKND, yeh naming lekar 3 saal pehle bhi yudh hua tha... But did we got any outcome??? NO... So why to waste time
when we know its purely a business decision by channel...

Those who are IPKKND 3 Fans have full right to comment or post but on IPKKND 3 FORUM... Take it as plead, beg, request etc that please do not make THREAD for IPKKND 3... And don't make us to leave India Forum because of You all..

Well said yaar !!! 👏 Many of us were discussing peacefully about IPK3 in just one thread, when many people started making thread to bash only... Then please tell me how we are responsible to make you leave the forum???

Well now we have got our new forum, so will not bother with IPK3, unless someone again makes a thread to chant "No IPKKND 3 Without SaRun...

Sorry to disappoint you but "Humari baat abhi khatam nehi hui"

All of us, we have got too much emotionally attached with Arshi and that's the main reason of this fan war.. But getting this much attached for a fictional character is not the channel/producer/actors' fault to be cursed and bad mouthed so much... No one is talking away Arshi from us... They already have made such a place in our hearts that it can't ever be replaced... So can you tell what's wrong in accepting or either giving a chance to new season??? How could someone accuse those who want to watch the new season of not being Arshi fan??? Who gave them
the right to judge us??? 😡

It is not for that I hate someone... It is because I m deeply in love with original pair And Thier amazing chemistry...

🤣

If you don't hate someone, then why are you supporting without sarun no IPKKND ???

I don't know how so many many people are excited about season3...mana barun is there
but sanaya was also a very integral part of d show..how people can easily forget that..

Why we should not be excited??? I really have not forgotten Sanaya... because I like her also and
will be happy if she win NB.. And first part integral member is not only Sarun but for me the whole cast, everyone had made a impact in my mind... But that does not mean all will be included in the new season too...

Gul shouldn't use RabbaVe as we are emotionally connected to it...

I have given my views on this before...

I Loved Barun and Sanaya also because it was ArShi who made them me to introduce to SaRun.. So ArShi or SaRun will always be my first Prority... And about watching IPKKND 3 I don't think I can never able to watch... At first when News came about IPKKND 3 I was shocked and excited and later when I Read Comment Gul is Bashing Sanaya and said that She was never been approached because Gul thinks She is not fit... So this made Me against to IPKKND 3...

You are making me laugh actually... 😆

Oh God!! Save me please!!!

Now coming to casting Shivani in place of Sanaya', what does it means??? This is different story with different characters where requirements are ought to different, and even Sanaya being versatile actress does not always make her eligible for all type of roles available opposite Barun..

And whatever Story was written... If Barun was casted then Sanaya should have been casted too..

Is there such rule written somewhere ????😲

Its not Barun only who took IPKKND to heights...

We all VERY WELL KNOW THAT... Its Not only Barun or Sanaya but THE WHOLE TEAM you know... then you should start petition for casting others too along with the scriptwriters and directors...

If anyone says that Advay might be son of Khushi... So how could he... Doesn't He will be
lookalike of His Dad..

What are you trying to say????

Whatever But I'm fully against to IPKKND 3... Gul and Barun are behaving as they were only who took IPK to Highest Position... This is unfair to ...

Like Barun said.. "How could someone give verdict b4 seeing the show? You all are just above our understanding with your narrow minded thoughts... What's Shivani's fault that she is casted... I guess the people who casted her are more experienced and qualified to take that decision... Some people are calling her with such bad names!!! Thats really horrible... And the worst thing is
cursing!!! I mean seriously!! What have they done to get cursing like this??? And you are telling we are bashing!!! Honestly I feel if Sanaya is getting bashed then its only bcz of such OTT obsessed fandom always cursing, calling names and bashing around!!!

And Lastly, Arnav and Khushi along with Anjali, Nani, Mami, NK, Akash, Payal, Lavanya, Lakhsmi, Amma, Babuji, Buaji and even Dadi, Shyam, are integral part of IPKKND.. and they all are imprinted in my mind in such a way that no other show can replace their place in our hearts...

But also supporting new season does not mean that we are going to support it blindly, we are just giving it a chance to flourish.. if something don't please us in the show we will surely voice it out.. But bashing someone even b4 the show goes on air is not really fair... And 30 sec clip is not enough to judge someone's acting...

Arnav and Kushi characters belong only to Gul as she created it...it doesn't belong to Barun and Sanaya ...they acted because Gul paid them to act

and please stop acting as if she is the one who took IPK to heights...and stop sending pm's begging for support ...no one is kid here to be preached...everyone can decide who they want to support...so pls keep Your morals to yourself.

Originally posted by: Arshika_arshi

Hi Alisha,
you have PMed me, asking to support you if you are right..

Well I am
going to write few facts here... hope you will get your answers there...

Coming to
first line of your post.. "Heyyy Everyone... Since News about IPKKND 3 has came I Have seen
GulKhan was able to break ArShi STARDOM.. What do you mean by "I Have seen GulKhan
was able to break ArShi STARDOM.. ??????

How will Gul break Arshi
STARDOM???? I am impressed with your words!!!

But I
have One Thing for You Guyzzz That Here So Many Peoples are as ArShi Fans
neither Barun or Sanaya Fans... So stop Bashing each other... Who actually started the bashing game ????
Gul is getting bashed ...bcz she did not casted Sanaya opposite Barun...
Calling her names, bad-mouthing etc..etc..etc... Some saying Gul is jealous
of Sanaya... What is the base of such idiotic comment ??? Is Gul any
actress to be jealous of Sanaya??? In IPKKND, Sanaya was not SP's choice during
her first audition... It was Gul who called her for the second time ... why?
Because Sanaya fitted in her vision of Khushi... Also there is a misconception
over Gul's one reply to some certain fan/fanclub...that she bashed Sanaya.. Why
will she do that??? That too in such situation when she is already facing
bashing from fandom?? Maximum people being members of such fanclub have fake
ids, she actually meant that only.. But like Khushi said to Arnav once.. "Apne
wohi samjha jo aap samajhna chaha Same applies to Sanaya fans actually...

Then coming to bash Barun... " how could
Barun agreed for IPKKND without Sanaya? Again a illogical question...
Barun signed the show bcz he was given a choice to choose the character.. which
he liked and most importantly is going to be finite series... But yes I would
be happy to see Barun and Sanaya in a show together... But if Sanaya is not casted,
that is not Barun's fault for him to lose respect in many LOYAL fans' eyes...'

Next coming to title, Barun did said in an IV
that when he was offered the role, that time it was not decided to call IPKKND,
tentative title is something else... Here let me remind you guys one thing,
that all the BG music, Songs, Title are intellectual property of Production
houses and the channel for TV serials.. They have the copyright to their own
creation like you guys have to your stories... They can use it for their own
benefit, we are no one to question them on using Arshi's song to other couple
despite how much we are emotionally attached to it... Itna Arnav and Khushi ka
loyal bhakt ho.. then you must remember Business decisions cannot be taken
emotionally...

Next,many were saying we are disappointed on Barun,
why bcuz he chose the character in such a show which belongs to Arshi/Sarun and
that too without Sanaya!!! Kinta bara paap kar dia !! God!! What do you mean by
belongs to Arshi/Sarun? Kya do alag insaan ka same name nehi ho sakta!!! Show
ka Naam choose karna is not in his hand, then why all these accusations???
Suppose you got a job you wanted, but someone of your friend didn't get the job
there only, will you leave your job and walk out??? Or many friends/family
don't like/approve the company's name, will you leave then just because that
name can't be the company's where you are working???? Read and think while
answering these questions...

Also tell me have
not a film name used more than once??? Kya tab bhi itna logo ka hungama tha???
Ek film mein, the song is made for those characters in film right?? Then how
can they be used in other shows and many of you writers also use film songs...
why do you use it??? The way you guys are trying to boycott and all, then how
you use a song which is exclusively for a film character{in your own words}??
Explain me please...

Let me explain why
you use it... bcz the lyrics of the song suits the situation of the story..
correct me if I am wrong...

And for the similar
reason, Rabba ve is being used... And for IPKKND, yeh naming lekar 3 saal pehle
bhi yudh hua tha... But did we got any outcome??? NO... So why to waste time
when we know its purely a business decision by channel...

Those
who are IPKKND 3 Fans have full right to comment or post but on IPKKND 3
FORUM... Take it as plead, beg, request etc that please do not make THREAD for
IPKKND 3... And don't make us to leave India Forum because of You all..

Well said yaar !!! We were discussing peacefully about IPK3 in
just one thread, when many people started making thread to bash only... To tell
me how we are responsible to make you leave the forum???

Well now we have got our
new forum, so will not bother with IPK3, unless someone again makes a thread to
chant "No IPKKND 3 Without SaRun...</b>

Sorry to
disappoint you but "Humari baat abhi khatam nehi hui.

All of us, we have got too
much emotionally attached with Arshi and that's the main reason of this fan
war.. But getting this much attached for a fictional character is not the
channel/producer/actors' fault to be cursed and bad mouthed so much... No one
is talking away Arshi from us... They already have made such a place in our
hearts that it can't ever be replaced... So can you tell what's wrong in
accepting or either giving a chance to new season??? How could someone accuse
those who want to watch the new season of not being Arshi fan??? Who gave them
the right to judge us???

It is not for that I hate someone... It is
because I m deeply in love with original pair<b>

And Thier amazing chemistry...

If you don't hate someone, then how can you support without sarun no IPKKND ???

I don't
know how so many many people are excited about season3...mana barun is there
but sanaya was also a very integral part of d show..how people can easily
forget tat..

Why we should not be
excited??? I really have not forgotten Sanaya... because I like her also and
will be happy if she win NB.. And first part integral member is not only Sarun
but for me the whole cast, everyone had made a impact in my mind... But that
does not mean all will be included in the new season too...

Gul shouldn't use RabbaVe as we are emotionally
connected to it...

I have given my views on this before...

I Loved Barun and Sanaya also because it was ArShi
who made them me to introduce to SaRun.. So ArShi or SaRun will always be my
first Prority... And about watching IPKKND 3 I don't think I can never able to
watch... At first when News came about IPKKND 3 I was shocked and excited and
later when I Read Comment Gul is Bashing Sanaya and said that She was never
been approached because Gul thinks She is not fit... So this made Me against to
IPKKND 3...

You are making me laugh actually...

Oh God!! Save me please!!!

Now coming to casting Shivani in place of Sanaya',
what does it means??? This is different story with different characters
where requirements are ought to different, and even Sanaya being versatile
actress does not always make her eligible for all type of roles available
opposite Barun..

And whatever Story was written... If Barun was
casted then Sanaya should have been casted too..

Is there such rule written somewhere ????

Its not Barun only who took IPKKND to heights...

We all VERY WELL KNOW THAT... Its Not only Barun or
Sanaya but THE WHOLE TEAM you know... then you should start petition for
casting others too along with the scriptwriters and directors...

If anyone
says that Advay might be son of Khushi... So how could he... Doesn't He will be
lookalike of His Dad..

What are you trying to say????

Whatever But I'm fully against to IPKKND 3... Gul
and Barun are behaving as they were only who took IPK to Highest Position...
This is unfair to ...

Like Barun said.. "How could someone give verdict b4 seeing the show? You all
are just above our understanding with your narrow minded thoughts... What's
Shivani's fault that she is casted... I guess the people who casted her are
more experienced and qualified to take that decision... Some people are calling
her with such bad names!!! Thats really horrible... And the worst thing is
cursing!!! I mean seriously!! What have they done to get cursing like this???
And you are telling we are bashing!!! Honestly I feel if Sanaya is getting
bashed then its only bcz of such OTT obsessed fandom always cursing, calling
names and bashing around!!!

And Lastly, Arnav and Khushi along with Anjali, Nani, Mami, NK, Akash, Payal, Lavanya, Lakhsmi, Amma, Babuji, Buaji and even Dadi, Shyam, are integral part of IPKKND.. and they all are imprinted in my mind in such a way that watching any other show can be injustice towards first season... But also supporting new season does not mean that we are going to support it blindly, we are just giving it a chance to flourish.. if something don't please us in the show we will surely voice it out.. But bashing someone even b4 the show goes on air is not really fair... And 30 sec clip is not enough to judge someone's acting...

Arnav and Kushi characters belong only to Gul as she created it...it doesn't belong to Barun and Sanaya ...they acted because Gul paid them to act

and please stop acting as if she is the one who took IPK to heights...and stop sending pm's begging for support ...no one is kid here to be preached...everyone can decide who they want to support...so pls keep Your morals to yourself.

@ amadae
What you actually wanted to write in first part.. I didn't get your words!!!
Well I had not seen Shiavni's acting b4.. So I am not going to comment on that b4 seeing her acting.. I am going to wait for at least 2weeks to a month to give a judgment on her acting as Chandni... But calling her names is heights of narrow minded thinking...

Originally posted by: Arshika_arshi

@ amadae
What you actually wanted to write in first part.. I didn't get your words!!!
Well I had not seen Shiavni's acting b4.. So I am not going to comment on that b4 seeing her acting.. I am going to wait for at least 2weeks to a month to give a judgment on her acting as Chandni... But calling her names is heights of narrow minded thinking...

Originally posted by: amadea

You wrote that
gl who created the character khushi and arnav but gl was the producer
not the writer. he is the writer who created the character
You said that gul who did the casting and chose the actor but who do the casting is the Casting director or the director not the producer

You are trying to say that Gul being producer could not pen down a character or cast someone??? 😲