If Barun had not been leaving ?? - Page 3

Originally posted by: sulu_123

If arnav's character had been killed off earlier, would the viewers have accepted it ??

If cvs had time, they cud have shown remarriage not happening and then we cud have had a real repentance track for arnav.But we'l never really know what they wud have shown next had barun not been leaving.

what we do know is that amidst it all, we had some lovely moments, lovely dialogues.

Dint heye show how arnav made several attemppts to understand what khushi really likes, failing so many times , yet not giving up. Dint we see him finally realise that for khushi , it was the simple things that mattered?

we had the magical karwa chauth in the sheetal track dint we ? Remember the way arnav protects /helps khushi in the mrs india track.

ofcourse each of us is entitled to their own opinion, but still as i rewatch the swami track or khushi singing 'mausam hai suhana ' it just makes me nostalgic.

i loved the swami track..those were khushi's exclusive way to deal with arnav..atleast there were no melodrama like other serials..IPK is always unique..

I guess problem strtd even b4 kidnapping track..so if Barun leaving problem wasnt there the show wud defo have gone for a separation track and then a re-union !!

Originally posted by: -Catz-

FF/OS are diffrent thing and TV shows are different..they need TRP TRP TRP...

Originally posted by: tiahalder

i loved the swami track..those were khushi's exclusive way to deal with arnav..atleast there were no melodrama like other serials..IPK is always unique..

as people already know

Originally posted by: sulu_123

If arnav's character had been killed off earlier, would the viewers have accepted it ??

If cvs had time, they cud have shown remarriage not happening and then we cud have had a real repentance track for arnav.But we'l never really know what they wud have shown next had barun not been leaving.

what we do know is that amidst it all, we had some lovely moments, lovely dialogues.

Dint heye show how arnav made several attemppts to understand what khushi really likes, failing so many times , yet not giving up. Dint we see him finally realise that for khushi , it was the simple things that mattered?

we had the magical karwa chauth in the sheetal track dint we ? Remember the way arnav protects /helps khushi in the mrs india track.

ofcourse each of us is entitled to their own opinion, but still as i rewatch the swami track or khushi singing 'mausam hai suhana ' it just makes me nostalgic.

you have indirectly defined the problem

superb post...

Originally posted by: bluesz08

OMG! do you think that these peple would accept arnav's exit.They will never accept anyone to come between Arshi whether its Anjali/Shyam/Sheetal and viraf..poor guy got bashed even before coming to the show ...you may have broad views to accept it like me but not all..If so they would have killed Arnav in kidnap track itself making barun's exit easier..now they are getting bashed for respecting fan's views.

👏 Yes more than broad view they also need to know that arhi are fictional character

Originally posted by: bluesz08

Very good analysis! Around the time of remarriage,Barun put down his paper..I strongly feel so thats why they rushed up shyam's revelation.otherwise they would have done it better..
Sheetal and Mrs.India track are only to facilitate Barun's exit..To make Khusi independent they could have showed her as business woman running catering services..they chose fashion world because after Arnav's death she will be the one managing AR designs..Yes they didn't foresee the outrage..Its so fuuny that fans are still asking "Why no honeymoon track?"..Seriously,how can they show HM track when they were already planning for barun's exit..and last one month its mostly Barun's BD we saw..so its not possible to show HM track..even if they show fans will bash them for using BD..Yes so many changes were done in the show because of Actor's unavailability and fan's expectation..and still people are bashing the PH..for what? for listening to fan's views and changed their story for barun because fans wont accept replacement..now also they are bashing the PH for "we ran out of ideas" post..for me the post is nothing but they simply don't know how to move the story without Arnav..and channel is the one who forced them to continue the show after remarriage..its all because of fan's expectation..Why can't they watch the show as it is and discuss about the episode instead of predicting the episodes and tell the writers to "what to do with their stories"..and still bashing the PH as created and destroyed their own show..Its very hard to satisfy these people's expectation..even if they end the show with HM track they will ask for Arshi's kid and their expectation goes on...People who still bash PH are bunch of desperate fans..

@bold very nicely put, from feb the down hill started , i wish sp had not forced ph to give leave to barun and allowed him to shoot for his movie by compromising on the show continuity.

@tm thanks for the post, you made me emotional byreminding so many things, Yes i ave had good time with ipk, except some crap times. But as a daily sows there will be some downs

Originally posted by: Horizon

There was NO Need to reduce Khushi to a school girl or ASR to a one with dormant brain during the hate marriage track. They could have shown some scenes where at least there was some progress in clearing the MU planting a doubt in ASR's head, it doesn't have to be resolved but at least some progress on those lines so that when ASR actually confessed there could have been some scenes that acted as pointers. Yes, we could all analyze, dissect and attribute our own reasons why he confessed that time, but from the makers' perspective there was NOTHING!

that track was just to show
that she s not going to take any shit from arnav
or probably she wanted answers for her marriage
we also need to understand
that she was blackmailed and forced into this marriage
and he hated her and threw her near poolside

so she was giving the same to arnav
what she got
but we never got that and we bashed PH
his hate was through his anger
and her hate was through this irritating behavior
which was fair