Mr LM has selective memory - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

75

Views

7.7k

Users

41

Likes

606

Frequent Posters

samin6 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#31
I think I better ask the MODs to close this thread, because here I was praising SARUN and the cast and it seems those who state themselves as fans are convinced without following the show closely that it was a crappy show where Sanaya was treated badly, Barun was given poor cloths, The story was badly written etc. Why exactly did you then watch this show?
srija.singh04 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#32
Are u kidding me!!!!!!!!!!!
Khushi's character didn't receive half the attention that ASR's character got. And plz don't even talk of her dresses and makeup, we all know she is very pretty and would have looked amazing with nice makeup and dressup, which she would receive only occasional like on diwali or karwa chauth, otherwise she was dressed in those f**king tent suits.
And Mr.LM was talking about the characterization of the characters and thats true, ASR had the hellicopter scene, his relationship with his family members were well defined untill the very end, while Khushi's family laid ignored, and no one can deny that Sanaya was the root of the show, she kept it running when others left it for their own personal sakes. Sanaya Irani made Khushi without much help from any huge prop or many serious scenes, she made Khushi memorable, but ASR made BS. Bas!
samin6 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#33

Originally posted by: srija.singh04

Are u kidding me!!!!!!!!!!!

Khushi's character didn't receive half the attention that ASR's character got. And plz don't even talk of her dresses and makeup, we all know she is very pretty and would have looked amazing with nice makeup and dressup, which she would receive only occasional like on diwali or karwa chauth, otherwise she was dressed in those f**king tent suits.
And Mr.LM was talking about the characterization of the characters and thats true, ASR had the hellicopter scene, his relationship with his family members were well defined untill the very end, while Khushi's family laid ignored, and no one can deny that Sanaya was the root of the show, she kept it running when others left it for their own personal sakes. Sanaya Irani made Khushi without much help from any huge prop or many serious scenes, she made Khushi memorable, but ASR made BS. Bas!


I watched Khushi for Sanaya and her acting not her dresses and makeup. Khushi was not Mr Martyr or Mahaan like other Bahus she was our Khushi which as she herself said" Humara naam hi Khushi hain." after Arnav had hurt her the most. So that was the exact line which made me understand her acts. She would smile no matter what and made us smile with her weird sense of humor. The focus was ARSHI and I loved how a couple who had very different views of love- Khushi for whom love meant a soft spoken person like Shyam and Arnav for whom- Love did not even believe in love fell and a partner like Lavanya who is well dressed not only fall in love but also support each other through every antics. That was the beauty of IPKKND. Their sweet love for each other and how they changed for each other. We did see Arnav wearing Kurta for Khushi only and Khushi wearing a western outfit for Arnav. But she did set her foot when it came to short dresses. That made me realize the line which they would not cross.
Pashna thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#34
I disagree. Khushi's role was a complete mess at the end and she was a regular girl next door and this role has been don before many times by other actress but no one comparable to sanayas acting. Arnav's role is by far the best written role in TV..period. Grooming is something an actor has to show interest in and barun completely neglected this part which also comes under actors duty! How come all the other shows male leads look good in terms of grooming and only barun looked tired, oily and unkept? Why would SP or PH ignore their most loved charector? U think they can't afford a makeup artist?

Sanaya did full justice and more to Khushi's role which was not so special compared to Arnav.
LM is not a time pass, he directed the show and know more than us.
Edited by pashna - 12 years ago
.RudraParo. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: samin096

I think I better ask the MODs to close this thread, because here I was praising SARUN and the cast and it seems those who state themselves as fans are convinced without following the show closely that it was a crappy show where Sanaya was treated badly, Barun was given poor cloths, The story was badly written etc. Why exactly did you then watch this show?

@bold: Now there's a good idea!
How do you know we didn't follow the show? Exuse me but I am a diehard IPK fan and I watched the show from beginning to the very end, but I doubt you did. Yes the show was crappy (in the last few months; not the show we had in the beginning. That was IPK!), Sanaya wasn't treated with justice-as in her role was rubbish- and Barun was given poor clothing!
800734 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#36
disagree...
Ignorance towards Khushi character was clearly visible in many occasions...
Sanaya had as much as tiredness and dirk circles as Barun...but she was professional enough to hide...period
GodhuliLogon thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#37
i totally agreed with LM.. her character did not have the grand touching the way ASR's char was sketched .. we all know khushi's char was butchered even in the last dayz of IPK..

so disagreed to this post .. but loved whatever LM ji told about her .. :)
CDlove thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#38
I compeletly disagree that Barun was not provided a make up man to do his make up. All other male characters in the show seemed to look well make-uped, groomed and attired from NK to Akash to Babuji to all those extra men seen in office scenes and such. So why not Barun?
Either Barun was not interested in wearing make up, refused to wear it or didn't have the time for it. I noticed this trend of him looking oily and unkept during the last few months of the show. Maybe he lost interest in the role he was playing altogether hence the lack of need to groom himself.
Which ever it is I fail to understand how he started to look so shabby and unkept towards the end. Isn't it the actor's job to atleast get a shave, wash his face well and get a hair cut? I dont understand why LM or any one else never commented on his shabby appearance (maybe they did) and asked him to get his act straight but I believe it's an actor's job to groom himself and look in par with the character he is portraying. I remember Sanaya once commenting on how adament he is about even getting a hair cut. So I rest my case.
About Khushi not getting the importance she deserved, is open for interpretation. The show itself was centered around ASR, portrayed from the eyes of the male protagonist most of the time, so there's no argueing ASR got much much more importance, scope and depth to his role compared to Khushi.
It was always about his pain, his happiness, his bond with his sister, his love for Khushi etc. Khushi was just his love interest on the way. If she had been given as much importance, they would have highlighted her bond with Payal, Her bond with her family especially bauji, her happinesses and focussed more on her pain and suffering which NEVER happend. While Arnav howled in pain at Shyam's betrayal, we didn't even know how Khushi felt after the forced marriage. It was all swept under the carpet and was never portrayed in a proper manner
I dont think LM was talking about the screen space of Khushi because I think Sanaya was working the most hours and was having most of screen space in the show. It was the 'importance' the story writers gave to the character he was talking about and it pales a lot in comparison to Arnav's.
Edited by CDlove - 12 years ago
sanju01 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#39
Khushi's character was never given any justice in the show.She was the only one who would always think about others happiness before her own yet she got lot of pains and trouble.She was always shown to be sacrificing and easily forgiving people and that's the weakest point of her character.
There were many circumstances where she would have reacted strongly but she didn't.Instead we always saw a forgiving and submissive khushi.
When Arnav called khushi characterless,that was the time she could have reacted strongly.Instead what she did!Even after being called a loose character,she still went with her husband to his house to suffer more humiliations from him.Her self respect was not important for her,clearing arnav's misunderstanding was more important for her.In those scenes,she was behaving as if she is the culprit.Why couldn't she tell Arnav,"I am not bad.Ur thinking is bad.I am not going to prove myself innocent.To hell with ur thoughts and ur misunderstandings.Get lost!"Any normal girl,no matter how much she loved her husband,would definitely react like this.After all,one's self respect is more important than anything else.But she easily forgiven her husband.
Then after the 6 months were over,arnav was literally forcing her to come back but khushi didn't react even though she didn't liked it.He was blackmailing her,forcibly touching her,trying to kiss her,etc.That was horrible.For some,it might be romantic but actually those scenes were pathetic.Even then also khushi easily became submissive.That time also they showed her weaker side.
I agree with everyone.Even though sanaya worked very hard,she never got her due.Everybody was drooling over each and every part of body of barun.Nobody was looking at sanaya.In fact,people even are saying that sanaya is popular because of barun otherwise she is nothing.That's the biggest insult to sanaya.
Jammy- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#40
I am just going to comment on the working hours. These guys already know how this industry works. People should think twice before taking up an acting job. It usually means a 15 hour shift. The problem is the episode banks. If the PH doesnt have a bank, it's obvious that the team has to put in more hours. The whole behind-the-scenes management sucked big time, thats the bottom line.

Related Topics

Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine · 2 years ago

Walking through the memory lanes of the secretive doors of our remembrance, looking for forgotten benchmarks of our lives, we can find...

Expand ▼
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine · 1 years ago

Though the years passed swiftly as the days, our love remains new. It’s so good to be here to celebrate this day with all of you . I still find...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".