.RudraParo. thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
I suppose this is a never ending dicussion: what went wrong with IPKKND? No matter how much of a diehard IPK fan you are, you cannot deny IPK has had one of the worst tracks, and characterizations. The first 8-9 months were brilliant. That show was IPK, the show which became an international hit. Everything about it was phenomenal. But after that, I couldn't recognize it. They destroyed it completely. I feel many things caused the downfall for it, amongst which are:
  • Poorly written storyline
  • Inconsistency in characterizations and storyline
  • Too many spoilers
  • Experimentation
  • Relying on the leads too much
  • Too much concern for what the viewers have to say
Storyline: "Nafrat pas aane na de, Mohabbat door jane na de" <--- This was the tagline for the show. Did they stick to it till the very last episode? No. The concept of the story was brilliant. The angry guy and bubbly girl concept has been done many times before but IPK was different. It created what no other show before had. This show had a lot of potential. They had two brilliant lead actors, with an equally brilliant supporting cast. They started off so well but lost it midway.
Inconsistency: Not only in the storyline but also in characterizations. I think it's safe to say, Khushi was the most inconsistent character? One minute, she would be bold, fierce and intelligent - the Khushi we fell in love with - and the other, she would be a senseless OTT character. A character we all once loved, became the character that would make us cringe. There was absolutely no consistency there. It is hard to believe the Khushi who came with the brilliant plan to expose Shyam, was the same one we saw during the disastrous Sheetal track. Speaking of the Sheetal track, what was the need of comedy in this track? When you are suspecting your husband of having an illegitimate child, do you really do the senseless things Khushi did? This track also had potential. Though many of us were against it, had they carried this out well, it would have gotten us decent TRPs.
Spoilers: I dont blame the spoiler givers, they were doing their job, but really, they were not needed. What annoyed me more were the members constantly asking for those. And no, you cannot say "oh you could have ignored the spoilers if you didnt want to see them" Lets face it, any topic with the word "spoiler" in its title, is very hard to ignore! Plus, we would have 10 other topics on that one spoiler. It would happen many times, the suspense of the future track would be ruined because of their spoilers, resulting in many boycotting the show till the track ended, because we didnt like how it was going to be. I know I was actually looking forward to the Sheetal track to find out what it will be like, but we were told from the beginning that she was a negative character, pretending to be Aarav's mother. That ruined it. Sometimes, a little suspense is actually good! We would have gotten to know of the storyline anyway, so what was the need for spoilers?
Experimentation: This was really annoying. Wasn't Khushi suppose to get bit by a scorpian? And wasn't she suppose to be shot? What was with the CVs constantly experimenting with different tracks? I got really fed up when I would hear about a really good track and Mishti or someone else would come and say, "oh they changed the track, they will be doing something else so please keep watching!" Post marriage track would have rocked, right after I remember, we heard about the scorpian track. Many people predicted that Khushi would get bitten, be in critical condition, and that would be how Arnav and Khushi come closer. But instead, they changed it and gave us "101 ways to annoy Arnav Singh Raizada" đŸ„±
Relying on the leads: It started off with all the characters getting proper screen space. Mamaji, Mami, Anjali, Naani, Payash, the Guptas, everyone came on screen even if it was just a for a few minutes, every character got their screenspace. But then, it was all about Arnav Khushi. I love Barun and Sanaya but I don't want to see them for 25 minutes, 5 days a week! What about Mama and Maami? Payash? They got married and we could have had an amazing post marriage track for them. Their story could have been developed and Akshay and Deepali wouldnt have complained for the lack of screenspace they got. Where did Mamaji go? Instead of bringing in useless characters like Bubbly and Masala mama (where did he go?) they couldnt have shown family scenes between Mama, Maami and Akash, Payal? That could have been a parallel track. Barun complained saying that he is tired. Instead of ending the show, why not reduce his screenspace and utilise the side characters? Why make Sanaya be in every scene? These two lead actors were used way too much!
Viewers: Why were they so concerned with what we had to say? It's completely fine to take feedback from the viewers', infact they should. We make or break this show. We could have easily switched to another show but we stuck to IPK. But they paid us a bit too much attention. Who told Gautam Hedge to go online and write an open letter, defending himself and the CVs/PH? Instead of doing that, he could have used that time to write a damn script! Everytime a good track would start, a bunch of viewers would protest against it, and in a couple of days, the track would end and something else would be shown. The sudden endings, the fast paced tracks left us confused and annoyed. Why couldn't they just alter the track a bit, if the viewers meant that much to them? Why end it altogether? We were practically doing their job for them. If the viewers weren't happy, it would end, if they were, the track would continue. Who were the CVs? Them or us? But then they proved that they couldn't write a script when they went online and wrote "the story has run its course" and asked for ideas. Who does that? Many shows run out of ideas but they dont tell the viewers that! The unprofessionalism of this PH and the CVs is highly disturbing!
IPK was a phenomenal show. It didn't become an international hit for no reason. It had an amazing concept with two of the best actors as its leads: Barun Sobti and Sanaya Irani. They brought the characters ASR and KKG to life, who clicked with the audience, and their chemistry was undeniable. I wish this show had maintained the essence it began with, and the characters weren't butchered.
It doesn't hurt that the show ended. The show was bound to end sooner or later. What hurt is that a show which had so much potential, had two phenomenal actors, such an amazing concept, came down to this. Swami? Miss India? 101 ways to annoy Arnav Singh Raizada? Really?
Whatever happened to this?
Edited by -charisma- - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

20

Views

9.4k

Users

16

Likes

80

Frequent Posters

Cassiefinora thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
Absolutely agree..👏

After kidnapping track,I was waiting for khushi to get shot and a redemption track(that word is overused in the forum I know)..Nothing of that sort happened..Whatever happened to that track..!!

Character inconsistency has more examples..i will cite 2 of them..forgot the rest..
1)Khushi wanting to have crackers during this diwali .She had lectured Lavanya about the child labour involved in crackers making and how people should stay away from crackers during last Diwali..amnesia amnesia😆..!!

2)Let us assume that guptahouse is a character..😉,during earlier episodes,that was a property owned by buaji.Later it became a rented one..amnesia amnesia😆

Regarding storyline,how khushi is responsible for Arnav's horrible past is not yet clear..It was garima who was the other woman,not Khushi..Past track was a wet cracker..no dhamaka at all !!!..Infact,tagline was not followed at all after the hate marriage..

Spoilers were helpful sometimes but not always..!!

The fact is that the CV's lack self confidence BIG time!!..OR dunno whether it was due to the channel interference..The way the tracks were handled after february was so not IPKKND like..
Asking for track idea through the internet and showing something different in TV didn't look professional..

OK I was ranting over split milk..!!suddenly realizing that the show was over days ago.!!

But I sincerely thank Gul &Co for giving this wonderful show though with some flaws..I will always cherish this show .Arnav and Khushi will be always special for me..

Edited by Archana89 - 12 years ago
Anarocksick thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
👏 a very well written post!

and I agree... I often wonder what went wrong? well today...I have my answers.

No but seriously... it seemed like after the holi track nothing was same, nothing at all. It changed into something else. I couldn't recognize the characters anymore.

I wonder whether they were the same people writing the script who wrote it int he beginning...how can they butcher the characters like this? It's a shame if you look at what we could have had...and we lost it.

...it was already dying and then *BLASSST* and everything got over.

I'm not surprised though... with the way they were going about it...something had to happen sooner or later.

But I still can't believe they forgot to close so many important loopholes and introduced unneeded tracks. It's a pity.

The show failed at so many levels...on it's way to become an EPIC. It's kind of like emperor Humayun's story!
Edited by blahblah16 - 12 years ago
Midnightsorrow thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
Khushi character never get the justice she deserved. After all ASR done to her she was never given a proper redemption track. They turn her into a joker in the Sheetal track it was hard to bear her making a fool out of herself.

I find it hard to digest ASR forgiving Garima so easily that past was a big deal to him. I was actually looking forward to see dark ASR I was never really a big fan of the loveydovey ASR. I thought his character was more interesting when he had mix feelings for Khushi love/Hate even with those mix feelings I find him more caring & Passionate towards Khushi than the loveydovey ASR. Compare ASR back in the days then & compare him now and you will see the differences!

I find all tracks after the kidnapping track very lame. It's just ArHi that always pull the show up the show had very talented actors but the stories after the kidnapping track were all bad. The past track we waited so long for was weak I expected way more from it. The acting from Barun and Sanaya the wedding week was really good that was what got me glued to the screen.

The Shyam exposing to Anjali track should have been longer they didn't plan it right again it was Abhaas acting that overshadowed the scrips.

Crazy4IPK thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
I agree with you in some points and contradict you too.
I believe IPK was a fabulous show till the ending. When a show runs for a long time it becomes inconsistent in some points.I think IPK was less crappier than other Hindi soaps.It's not possible to give amazing episode everyday and come up with beautiful story line all the time. The creatives of IPK sure did so many mistakes,but they rectified it after fan's demand.
If you say the uses of side characters, I really agree that they didn't do justice to the sides as they had the brilliant side characters.
They also failed to show Khushi consistent. I mean the OTT comedy was sometimes too much to bear. And CVs sure did injustice with her look too,.Khushi's old and ugly costumes were so annoying sometimes. As Sanaya herself was so beautiful that she used to look gorgeous even in those potato sacks.
I also feel so many spoilers in some point destroyed the track.
Finally let me say about the viewer's POV. It's very true that IPK's viewers were very possessive for the show. so their input sometimes crossed the limits.Their constant bugging and criticizing sometimes damaged the show and sometimes did good for the show.
But whatever flaws ipk, the PH, CVS and we the viewers had, IPKKND is still the best show of Indian television and Arnav-Khushi is the best couple of the world and so as Barun-Sanaya. And above all IPK's fans are the best fans of the world. They created history to end the show and will make history again to bring it back again insha'allah.

..Anita.. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
I agree with every word
What bothered me the most was the daily spoilers that seemed to come after the kidnapping track

It honestly left no suspense in the show what so ever...also all spoilers seemed to contradict itself and change daily...so it left us confused..so when a fan reads this and does no agree they decide to protest...I rather wait and see what happens ...this might have lead to rushed tracks and unfinished stories...I thought the cv and ph are in charge and not the viewers

And also the open letter saying that the show had run its course...this is the first time I have heard a ph do this...around the time their new show is out as well...I do no know the drama...but it seemed really unprofessional to me

This situation of the she could have been handled better
lazylad8-FauZi thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
It seems like the show and us the viewers were star crossed lovers!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
IamSwapnali thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8
This is such a well-written post.

Will come back & edit :)
733727 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
from movie to gul mismanagement to channel failure to changed script to fans interfering in the script to spoilers and rumors lead to disaster of ipk now we need is to move on.
Erika1 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#10
ME, I started viewing this screenplay,😆 and then bam down the hill it went😭,

The makers couldn't handle the success and fame, nor the critics either, that's my honest opinion, the show got too popular for them, and they hadn't time to regroup and revamp the screenplay, since I read they were shooting the day before it aired.

Related Topics

Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine

1 months ago

#IPKKND/ArShi Poolside Moments/A splishin&splashin’/ I hate you/page 1

A splishin’ and a splashin’! A little bit of pool time is among the unforgettable ones Entangled meetings straight from Kisses to heartbreaks By...

Expand ▌
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine

7 years ago

\\ #IPKKND Rewind //*Kahani Teri Meri*Episodes 170-300/Holi Gifs-pg 75

~Kahani Sirf Teri Meri~ Having you in my arms, a warm heart just cried Never thought of missing when tears were dried Your Eyes left with me...

Expand ▌
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine

9 years ago

IPKKND Ek-Jashn / New Post/ Page 47/Nov 2023

Nov, 30th ...Can we forget this day? When our favorite show "Iss Pyar Ko Kya Naam Doon ..." Ended abruptly. It was painful for all of us not to...

Expand ▌
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine

6 years ago

\\#IPKKND Rewind// "You're mine" / Episode 300 plus

I welcome you with my open heart Because you are my light, my sunshine I don't give a damn of right or wrong With this promise, I"l make you...

Expand ▌
Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon Thumbnail

Posted by: Mysticaldivine

1 years ago

#IPKKND/ Arshi Teri Meri Special/13th Anniversary/ Page 32/2025

Disclaimer : All images and writing belong to Mysticaldivine. Do not use without permission... 12 Years of Teri Meri Kahani 💕 Does she know I...

Expand ▌
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".