Cannot be 'Amazing' unless they come to the point!

Page

Next Last

rightknell11

@rightknell11

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

I respect anyone's decision if they liked the episode today. But I can never call it "amazing" unless two or more of the following is elaborately addressed and/or shown:

1. Arnav's incomplete truth to Anjali.

2. Shyam's truth coming out to at least one amongst: Nani, Dadi, Akash, Mami or Anjali.

3. The uncovering of Garima's and Dadi's secret.

4. The discovery of the cameras.

5. The discovery of the camera purchase on the credit card.

6. The discovery of the shards of broken glass.

7. The discovery that something is wrong with the wiring.

Unless this is addressed, it is very clear that they are dragging. I don't care about the wedding, as the wedding is not integral to the plot, the above listed points are.

I don't even care if anyone does not like my post, but what is happening is a filler, an Arshi crowd-puller and that's all. Story, at the moment, is wandering.

I have not seen the show yet, but can gauge from experience that this is again an Arshi-fan pleaser episode and not the one (yet again) where story is shown as progressing.

Edited by rightknell11 - 12 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

farah007

@farah007

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

it was a total waste of episode.. felt like sleeping... drag drag.. no charm left

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

-sanika-

@-sanika-

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

Actually, if I was an actor or a director and was given this script to work on, i would be completely uninspired and totally confused with the hotch-potch of khichadi they seem to be dishing us these days ...

Quote

rightknell11

@rightknell11

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: -sanika-
Actually, if I was an actor or a director and was given this script to work on, i would be completely uninspired and totally confused with the hotch-potch of khichadi they seem to be dishing us these days ...

Your words are laced with truth, every letter and the spirit of it. Please let me congratulate you that you are one of the 2% or so people on this forum who call spade a spade.

Please continue writing, members like you are a blessing, as only honest feedback can save this show now.

Quote

-sanika-

@-sanika-

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: rightknell11

Your words are laced with truth, every letter and the spirit of it. Please let me congratulate you that you are one of the 2% or so people on this forum who call spade a spade.

Please continue writing, members like you are a blessing, as only honest feedback can save this show now.

Already have yaar. I will just copy paste something I wrote in some other post a few days back:

"Aadat se majboor, I was sitting and trying to figure out logically, why IPk is not working for right now.

What is the exact time it stopped working for me ?
Right from when the Kidnapping tract ended.

There is no logical sequence of anything! This is the biggest turn off for me!

What are the things that didn't work for me ?
Script
Screenplay
Direction
Sets
Acting
Look
Background music

Everything is a huge Khichadi. I am used to better and more polished episodes from IPK

A few scenes that I didn't like
1) ASR apology: There was no sincerity in both actors. And the script and screenplay was a huge hotchpotch!

2) Asr enters mandir: Khushi's dilogues do not make any sense to me. She said "I was sure that one day u will enter the mandir for me" Based on what ...the kabootar incident ? How does it make any sense? And if she was so sure, why is she so surprised that he is doing all this ? This is logically very unappealing !

3)How is arnav entering GH? through the window. Why do they show him entering from the main door then? If Khushi is already at the window, why doesn't she see Arnav entering ?

The list goes on. These questions, I never had when I first watched the show. The episodes were so crisp. So was the detailing. Even in the makeup, eg, the hurt on arnav's hand during the nainital trip was still shown fresh in the hospital scenes and a few scenes after ward which were shot on the same day.

Why are they not paying attention to details these days ?😭"

Sorry for the rant.

Quote

Rishita

@RickyBahl

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 12 years ago

Dont worry of others

we are not purchasable by rabba veys

we want story, logical story

Quote

Nishita Rao

@Nishitarao

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

Agree on few points.. But I don't agree on investigating the camera purchase on the credit card...

If I ever come to know that my credit card has been stolen and is being misused, the only the I am gonna do is cancel the card.. I am not gonna look into who purchased what from the card.. coz it doesn't matter..

If Anjali still had the card and it was being misused, then it would make sense for Arnav to look deeper into the matter.. Since she said she lost it, he just assumed that whoever found it , has been misusing it..

Quote

rightknell11

@rightknell11

Navigator

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: Nishitarao
Agree on few points.. But I don't agree on investigating the camera purchase on the credit card...

If I ever come to know that my credit card has been stolen and is being misused, the only the I am gonna do is cancel the card.. I am not gonna look into who purchased what from the card.. coz it doesn't matter..

If Anjali still had the card and it was being misused, then it would make sense for Arnav to look deeper into the matter.. Since she said she lost it, he just assumed that whoever found it , has been misusing it..

Agreed...probably because I am an accountant I tend to think in those terms..ha ha

But Anjali? forget Anjali, when ten people told her that Shyam was evil, she did not believe them? Do you think she will have that mental acuity to see if her credit card is being misused or not?

This is where Arnav should step in...

Quote

Nishita Rao

@Nishitarao

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: rightknell11

Agreed...probably because I am an accountant I tend to think in those terms..ha ha

But Anjali? forget Anjali, when ten people told her that Shyam was evil, she did not believe them? Do you think she will have that mental acuity to see if her credit card is being misused or not?

This is where Arnav should step in...

Anjali is dumb.. totally agree on that part.. May be Arnav didn't want to make a big deal out of it.. waise bhi she always behaves like she is gonna die any second.. So may be he didn't want her to worry..

Yeah normally when you lose a credit card, you'll get to hear a couple lectures from your loved ones😆