11714daughter thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
Hello fellow Arshi fans:


What an episode? A new wonder for us, the viewers as well as members of the Gupta and Raizada families, who were present at the temple! What wonderful acting by all the cast and crew. We also had them resolve the mysteries of Anjali talking to air and so forth as well, did the creatives not? We are getting some great episodes that one would like to see over and over again, just like the ones that we got before Payal and Aakash got married. Yet we feel the tension mounting higher and higher, and we know that we are going to have an explosion like the last time as well. We will have a brief analysis of this episode; however first, there was one other thing we wanted to mention here as well. A lot of people are wondering as to the necessity of this wedding:
Here is our take on Arnav and Khushi's Marriage:
Wedded or Not:

A number of you mention that they are already married and as such do not need this wedding again right now. Well we are going to look at all the different ways that a couple can get married in Hinduism, as layed out in the Mausmriti or Manava Dharma Shasra. There are eight types of marriage described in the ancient Hindu text of Manusmriti (Laws of Manu) or "Manava Dharma Shastra":

Rite of Brahmana (Brahma) - where the father of the bride invites a man learned in the Vedas and a good conduct, and gives his daughter in marriage to him after decking her with jewels and costly garments.


Well Arnav and Khushi were not married in this way, as Shashiji never invited Arnav, never gave his daughter in marriage to him after decking her with jewels and costly garments, and neither is Arnav learned in the Vedas and a good conduct.

Rite of the Gods (Daiva) - where the daughter is groomed with ornaments and given to a priest who duly officiates at a sacrifice during the course of its performance of this rite.

Arnav and Khushi certainly never got married in this manner either.

Rite of the Rishis (Arsha) - when the father gives away his daughter after receiving a cow and a bull from the bridegroom.

Shashiji did not give away Khushi and neither did he receive a cow and a bull from Arnav.

Rite of the Prajapati - (Prajapatya) where the father gives away his daughter after blessing the couple with the
text "May both of you perform together your duties".

Now this one was certainly not fulfilled, as Shashiji would have to be involved and bless them, which since he cannot speak is out of the question.

Rite of the Asuras (Demons) - when the bridegroom receives a maiden after bestowing wealth to the kinsmen and to the bride according to his own will.

Arnav did not bestow any wealth to the Gupta Parivar, and certainly not to Khushi according to his own will, so this one was not the way Arnav and Khushi are married either.

Rite of the Gandharva - the voluntary union of a maiden and her lover, which arises from desire and sexual intercourse for its purpose.
Of course then we have the one way that some viewers are thinking was the way they got married. According to this, the union has to be voluntary, which here it was not, not from Khushi's side, as she was blackmailed into this, and the second requirement was not then nor even now has been fulfilled, so they are not married in the Rite of the Gandharva.

Rite of the Rakshasa - forcible abduction of a maiden from her home after her kinsmen have been slain or wounded and their houses broken open.

We know that Arnav did not kidnap Khushi from her home, and her family has not been slain or wounded and the Gupta house has not been broken open by Arnav.

Rite of the Pisaka - when a man by stealth seduces a girl who is sleeping or intoxicated or is mentally imbalanced or handicapped.
Arnav and Khushi certainly are not married in this manner as Khushi was not seduced stealthily or otherwise, let alone the fact that she was not sleeping, intoxicated, mentally imbalanced or handicapped.

There is one other rite ofmarriage in Hinduism, which is outlined as follows:


Groom kidnapping, colloquially known as Pakaruah shaadi or Jabaria shaadi, is a phenomenon common in the western parts of Bihar, and eastern Uttar Pradesh states in India, wherein eligible bachelors are abducted by the bride's family and later forcefully married, to avoid heavy dowry costs. Considering the traditional regard for the marriage sacrament, most such marriages are not annulled. Additionally, the groom may suffer criminal charges under Indian dowry law, and end up fighting lengthy legal battles.

This Rite was also not performed as Arnav was kidnapped, however not so that he can marry Khushi, but so that he can be killed, and if we go back to their original wedding day, then it would seem that it was more like Khushi was almost kidnapped and forced to marry, not Arnav.

The above are the alternatives to the traditional Indian Wedding ceremony with all that entails, including the saat (seven) pheras. Now we know that the traditional wedding also requires a priest chanting Mantras as well, as the sindoor (vermillion) in the maang (middle parting on forehead) as well as the Mangalsutra. Please note that in certain emergency situations, just the application of the sindoor in the maang has been construed as a wedding, however, that is on a temporary emergency basis only, and once the emergency is over, the full wedding rituals and ceremonies are followed and the couple does complete all the required necessities.

Arnav and Khushi never completed the all the necessities of the traditional wedding ceremony, as they did not have the pheras, nor did they have the Pandit or Priest chant the mantras. However, neither did they comply with the requirements of any of the other 8 alternative ways of marriage in Hinduism, let alone the fact that a lot of the alternatives are not even accepted by society. As such, Arnav and Khushi are not married and only lived together for the past six months.

Another interesting point we would also like to make here is that just for the sake of argument, even if we do say that they were married in one way or another, and please note that we are not saying that then the fact of the matter is also that the marriage has not been consumated; which also would have validated the marriage, however that has not occurred either and might have counted as a Gandharva Rite of Marriage; which almost happened.

Guys, the point here is that in each of these options, consent of both parties is required. And in that original ceremony, Arnav's blackmailing of Khushi does not count as her consent. She had originally refused him, and only later gave in because of the blackmail. And before you say that this is consent, let us say that if a woman does not consent to sex, however she is blackmailed, and so she forcibly agrees, would anyone say that she consented so it is not rape?

Arnav right now is not being forced to go through with this. He is the one who brought it up, he is the one who is willingly doing this to make Khushi happy, a vast difference from "marry me right now or I will break your sister's wedding." Please note we are not saying that a grand wedding was required, but they are having a grand wedding because of Anjali here. What we are saying is that a wedding was required.

We agree that the other pre-wedding rituals were not required, as they did complete them however Arnav is going along with those, so that he can show Khushi and remind her that they did complete them. Just like he reminded Khushi of their previous ring on finger ceremony outside the temple that day, he will do so with each rasam that they go through from here on out.
Now onto the episode analysis:

Garima Escapes Again!

We hear the conch shell blowing and Daadi standing behind Garima; she tries to sneak a peek but is not successful. As Garima stands there she feels uneasy and looks back to see Daadi. Could this be seen as divine intervention for her to run, or is it an indication to her that she cannot keep running? She has to face the past and tell Khushi everything before the trumpet is blown by someone else creating a bigger problem than was expected. Khushi turns to see Daadi and also has the opportunity to hear her very insistent moaning of having missed Garima. When Buaji says that where does Garima disappear to at the right moment this confirms to Daadi that something is wrong, and that this is the woman that she is eager to see. Daadi also pushes home the fact that it was because of Khushi that Arnav had followed her here, that Khushi had set all this up and that she was not new to this stuff.

We do wonder how long Garima can keep this pretense up, and both Khushi and Buaji are getting suspicious. They will now begin to raise questions, or one hopes they would. The precap itself should be a concerning matter and one to be questioned by Khushi and Buaji, now whether they get the right answers or not will be something interesting to watch out for in the next episode.
Arshi Ka Prem (Arshi's Love):

Arnav phones Khushi to ask if her veneration has been completed and she tells him that Khushi is being accused of calling him to her, and he says "so what" and that he does not care what Daadi thinks. Khushi realizes he will work himself into a fit so changes the topic, and she tells him she is getting permission for her wedding from DM which stuns Arnav, until she says it is a ritual, which is like the siren for the battle. He now is alert, and if it is a ritual then he has to complete it no matter what; no way is he letting this one go. Next they might have to go through the entire marriage again simply for the blessings of DM! To the shock of everyone they see Arnav walking up the stairs, this is the same guy that has not stepped into the mandir for years. Everyone looks at him astounded, but the answer for him is simple, "it's a ritual right? So let's complete it", a poor Khushi, eyes gaping and inviting the mosquitoes into her mouth finally recovers and she corrects the name of the ritual he trying to say. He states "we need her permission so that's why I am here." Buaji says Khushi has managed to do the impossible.
We then see the two of them getting the DM's blessing, he looks at her to get an idea of what to do, and closing his eyes he prays, he then sneaks a look at Khushi who is smiling because of what he has done for her, and he knows what makes her happy. For him it is as simple as this, she is happy by a simple thing he has given her and for him that is enough. When she looks at him she sees him smiling, Khushi turns to her DM and tells her that Arnav being in Mandir has come true and then teases her that he is only doing this for Khushi at the same time asks her to keep her blessings on him at all times.

Arnav says "seeing as we have got the blessing you must be happy now." Khushi smiles and Naani remarks that Anjali would have been over the moon to see Arnav at the Mandir. Payal says to Khushi separately that Arnav is doing this for her. On realizing that Arnav has done all of this for her, Khushi decides that she also needs to reciprocate. She talks to him and tells him that she knew he would come to the mandir one day for her, and when he asks her how, she reminds him of how he helped a little girl fly the doves by paying for them; he is surprised and realizes she was there that day.

Two interesting points to consider:

1. Arnav has stepped into the protecting arms of DM, he is now in a way accepted, whether he actually bothers to turn up to the mandir or to do any of the rituals after marriage, he is still protected whereas Anjali has walked away from the DM. She is no longer in the arms of the DM; she is no longer safe and has moved away from DM in the hope of regaining her husband. (Thanks raani for bringing this to our attention). Also we have seen Khushi ask to have Arnav blessed at all times, and join this with Buaji's raksha dhaagaa it seems he will be protected from future harm (or one can hope).


2. The fact that Khushi is going to do something to make Arnav happy, well here is a thought, what if she buys him a load of plants once again? This will mean a lot to him and will also close the loop where she bought the plants to patch up things between him and Lavanya by selling her mum's bangle.
Anjali:

Anjali sends HP away from home, despite HP saying "in your condition I should not leave you." She gives Shyam tea and asks him to talk with her. He smiles at her and continued to stare at her, feeling satisfied that things are going as he wants them to go.


He tells her she looks beautiful and when she is tense, he then says "you took care of matters, and you made sure HP disappeared so why are you so worried?" She asks him why he wanted to meet her at the RM. He replies that "is it a crime to meet your wife at home?"

She tells him that she waits to meet him more than anything. He then says "I have never been away from you" and in flashbacks we see all the times they met and nearly got caught as well. She says she does not want to talk of the past, and she is sure that it was a misunderstanding. He then says "I also do not want to talk about the past." (double connotations here? The past which exposed and the past we know nothing of?). He then asks her how she is and how her day was and that is why he stays close by. She tells him not to worry for her. She then says she wishes everything would be ok like before and we see Shyam looking at her and then thinking about something.

Points to consider:

1. Will this just be a meeting between the two and he walks off when someone comes home?

2. Or could it be something dire; he has stated whilst staring at the camera that in a few hours they will need to call the doctor, does this mean that whatever was in those tablets should now have spread in her body?


3. Will anyone actually notice that there were two cups and who did the other cup belong to?
NK'S Day Out:

NK's day out and away from RM has been stressed a little too much in the last couple of episodes. We have him informing every one of that, as the excuse of why he cannot go to the Mandir with the family. Also how did Anjali know to ask HP upon her return about NK, when as far as we saw that when Aakash had called her about the trip to the Mandir, he just said that everyone is going to the Mandir?


However, she did ask HP specifically about NK, to which HP replied that he had gone out with his friend and that he will not be returning till evening. We wonder what is so important about stressing NK's being away from home so much for.

Symbolisms:

Daadi: Daadi, when she first arrived was wearing pure white colored saris for the first couple of reel days. However since the last couple of reel days, she has been wearing Beige. The white in the show represents Anjali. And since Daadi is on Anjali's side, we can infer her wearing the white. The point here is that the beige color; is that to emphasize and indicate to the viewers that Anjali is no longer so pure and an innocent party that she was before? We have seen indications of this, in her lying to not only Arnav, but the entire family, in order to meet Skunky. She has even invited the devil into the home with wide open arms.

Naani: Naani in the present day in reel life is wearing yellow, which represents Khushi. We do know and realize that she will be one of Arnav and Khushi's allies in the upcoming war with Skunky. We are also seeing Naani starting to speak up and stand upto Daadi on behalf of Khushi, as we saw in this episode, when she reminded Daadi that coming to the Mandir was Arnav's idea, when Daadi was berating Khushi for telling Arnav about the Pooja, so that he would come to the Mandir to meet Khushi.

Payal: Payal, as we mentioned yesterday in all in green with little flecks of red in there, indicating a very strong and staunch supporter of Khushi, and Arnav, because of Khushi in the upcoming battle against Skunky.

We finally leave you with the following poem by Rashdah:

"ILLUSIONS"
Illusions are better than reality
In illusions we can pretend to be happy
Hiding behind a facade we are content,
We cover that which is true with lies,
Wishing them to be true.
We don't see the danger lurking,
The one that will slowly kill us.
All she sees is her lover,
The one she cannot live without,
He is before her,
And the world is right.
She betrays for his love,
She smiles for his happiness,
She dances to his tunes,
What is the devil,
But a murderer in disguise?

Precap:

Khushi and Buaji ask Garima about her absence whilst Garima is trying real hard to run away. Khushi sees her taking out the suitcase and questions her about it, drawing Buaji's attention as well, who is also wondering what is going on.

Question Of The Day:

WHAT IS THE REASON BEHIND THIS IMPORTANCE BEING PLACED ON NK BEING OUT OF RM, AND NOT WITH THE FAMILY? WHAT DO YOU THE VIEWERS THINK IS THE REASON? DO YOU THINK IT IS SIGNIFICANT AND IF SO HOW DO YOU THINK IT IS SIGNIFICANT?
Till the next time…
😃😃⭐️⭐️
Arshi Advocates

Created

Last reply

Replies

7

Views

2.2k

Users

8

Likes

14

Frequent Posters

Jai.Mata.Di thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
AA...What a wonderful view!!!👏 Research on Hindu marriage was fantastic. Indian society gives lots of importance to traditional marriage...So a nice take on it!!⭐️
Miss.Sonja thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#3

22 August: Garima's Great Escape And The Warlord's Electric Entry.

Well, well, rasam number three completed without a glitch and in fact the added bonus for the Warrior Princess that the Warlord entered the temple and carried out the rituals with her. Today marked another day of progress.

The episode began where it had left off, at the temple during the Aarti with Dadi placed behind Garima and the Warrior Princess. Once again, Garima skips away from trouble unscathed, leaving the Warrior Princess and Buaji once again to face the wrath of Dadi Amin. It later transpires that Amma had been called away to deal with Babuji's medication. How long will Garima hide behind the excuse of her husband's ill health? One might consider that it recent times, it has been shown that Babuji's health has gotten increasingly better and his condition has been improving not worsening.

The Warlord and Warrior Princess are learning to share their troubles and worries it seems as we see the Warrior Princess discuss her concerns regarding Dadi. She receives a 'so what' response but communicates her feelings expressing her concerns about Dadi's displeasure, concluding the conversation and changing the topic to that of the next rasam, the Kuldevi Pooja. The Warlord hears rasam and his antenna stand on high alert.

As Nani introduces the girl adorning a mangalsutra and sporting a spot of sindoor as the bride to be, the priest offers her his blessings without batting an eyelid at bigamy. The family get ready to start the pooja and Akash spots his brother climbing the steps. Arnav Singh Raizada had removed his shoes and climbs the steps of the temple much to the shock and delight of his beloved and the other family members.

The Warlord is leaving nothing to chance and is ensuring that he is present for all the rituals in order that his wife may have the wedding rituals fulfilled that she so desires and he can have his wife beside him as he so desires.

The Kuldevi Pooja is completed without a glitch. The Warlord follows his beaus lead and she too, understands the importance of the action he took today just for her. The Warrior Princess once again mentally notes his gesture during her conversation with Devi Maya, acknowledging that he was here just for her. It was quite sweet to watch the Warlord being led through custom and ritual, things that do not matter for him but hoops he was willing to jump through just to see a smile on the Warrior Princess' face.

It was endearing to observe the couple taking new steps in their relationship while finding the opportunity to reminisce about times gone by. The Warrior Princess reminds the Warlord of his meeting with a little girl and some pigeons long ago and the Warlord is surprised to note that his beau had been present to witness his kind gesture. The couple are not only creating memories but sharing and taking a trip down memory lane much as couples do in the run up to their wedding. Reflecting and experiencing is only proving to strengthen their bond further and should stand them in good stead when NK's 'Dhoka' ceremony is complete; this being the revelation of Garima and Dadi's past connection, the Golden Girl's secret meetings with the Silver Tongued Serpent and the Silver Tongued Serpent's rigging of the Palace to render it a Raizada Special Big Brother.

Dadi has once again shown her displeasure at not having met Garima. She takes out her frustrations on the Warrior Princess and remarks in her anger that whether or not she gets to meet Garima, that the Warrior Princess would surely be united with the Warlord. Has Dadi foretold the future. The dialogue appears to hint that Garima will escape Dadi's clutches however this will leave the Warrior Princess alone in arranging her wedding. Who will give her away if Garima and Shashi hot foot it out of town? It remains to be seen.

In the meantime, the Golden Girl crept back into the Palace once everyone had gone. She further instructs HP to take some time off, leaving her completely alone in the house. Once alone, she prepares two cups of tea and as she hands the tea cup across to her guest the obvious is revealed to us and we are presented with a clean shaven Shyam Manohar Jha, dressed appropriately in his colour, blue; displaying a clean cut image that he had sported in the earlier days of the serial. It appears he too, like the Warlord is going back to the start with a twist. This time, Jha's intentions lie in being able to persuade his wife to enable him a meal ticket at the Raizada Palace once more. He places great emphasis on his concern for her health, wanting to only be with her and his Raj kumari and the fact that he did not want to conceal their meetings any longer.

The Silver Tongued Serpent demonstrates the extent of his thrill seeking, meeting the Golden Girl on the edge of poolside, at the gate of Castle Chotte and narrowly escaping the clutches of the Warlord, escaping Mami's observations and enjoying the sneak and meets which had kept his wife enticed, under his spell.

It was interesting to observe the mentioning of roses in recent days; we observe Mami place an order for the wedding, an order of beautiful red roses, a symbol of love. While today, we observe that the rose decorated teacup passing between the Golden Girl and her husband is a decayed brown in colour on the teacup, perhaps suggestive of the decayed and dying love that remains between them; the Silver Tongued Serpent of course only harbouring feelings of love for himself while the Golden Girl hands on to a hopeless dream of a marriage that never was.

All in all it was a brilliant episode for progressing the plotline further. We are now uneasy and yet relaxing into the celebrations and rituals that are leading up to the wedding between our beloved Warlord and Warrior Princess. Garima once again made a great escape from Dadiji and again this did not go unnoticed. How long will Garima hide the truth from all? Will she come clean to the Warrior Princess once home or will she backtrack on the resolution she made before DM? It remains to be seen.

On the other hand, the other 'mother' of the Manor, the Golden Girl is not only lying but betraying her brother, who holds her in high esteem as a mother figure, by sneaking around seeing the Silver Tongued Serpent. It was interesting to note that the meeting took place at the Raizada Palace at the request of the Silver Tongued Serpent. What could be his motive for wanting to meet at the house? Is there more tampering that he wishes to conduct? Has he come to retrieve or has he come to plant?

Either way, he has surely come to deceive and deceive he does for the Golden Girl does not realise the mistake she is making, allowing the man that was ousted for her safety, back into her life and that too without any support or protection of her loved ones. Further, she has inadvertently facilitated the surveillance of the entire house by her husband in order that they may all participate in a Big Brother-esque show, on display at all hours, their every move under scrutiny and observation. Is this what she had envisaged when she had stated that she wanted to be with him all the time? I think not. Will somebody spot the cameras during the wedding preparations? Let us have hope for HP's detective skills. He appears to be the all seeing eye of the manor.

The precap suggests that Garima is packing off somewhere. Will she escape Dadi Amin's clutches and therefore miss the wedding of her dearest younger daughter?

Thank you for taking the time to read this. All comments are welcome as always.

samona24 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
👏superb analysis of the various marriage types in Hinduism. Brilliant analysis as usual! 👏👏'

Sonja, wonderful view and a great addtion to the AA post
👏
Superthree thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
God you do have patience and time to write all that!!!

They believe they are married miya biwi raazi why u bother qazi?
Z_ArShi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
Wow what a wonderful View !!!!!!!!!!!
Really enjoyed reading it :):):)
kbtr thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
tfs. Consider writing an OS.
-Raichu- thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#8
wow thank you so much for clearing all my questions on hindu mariages !!

your post was waesomd !!!

Related Topics

Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon thumbnail

Posted by: Sapnokiduniya · 2 months ago

I am trying to post my OS here and its giving me PHONE NOT ALLOWED error I haven't specified any phone number and I am posting this via laptop....

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".