IP REDUX; Modesty Blaise !! - Page 33

Originally posted by: --Anna--

Thank you Shanthi! 😃

I am trying hard to let everyone see that all is not lost yet! There is still hope! For me Arnav's repentance will happen - nahi hoga toh I myself will write a long post cursing them! Let them reach that stage then react.

Originally posted by: tanthya

Yes, Just bec I am not seeing from ur POV does not mean I am not positive ...If I did not have hope..I would not be here clarifying, giving my inputs or pulling the ears of the CV's [yes, GH, ur's too] ...

Originally posted by: --Anna--

Exactly my point Nia Thank you for putting it up so well. 👏

Sathu , I pride myself in being a part of REDUX - and I was very glad when you and Doodhs asked me to take the front page. I have learnt a lot from you guys but I will confess I never have based my analysis on what you have to say. What I write is what I feel - and then I read your analysis and most of the times I do get it when I am wrong in misinterpretation and I may have told you that once as well.

The problem is not at all in the decoding - because you and Doodhs are brilliant in that - and that is why most of us hold onto every word. But today when I read Doodhs post I was disappointed. No - not because she would not write - because I understand her attachment with the show and how thoroughly she has been disappointed with the ILU and the PH - but because her post today did set the panic in. Sorry Doodhs - but I am being frank here. Like I said - I have been getting PM's and the messages on REDUX are a clear picture of what the post has done. Everyone is upset that the repentance is cancelled and there will be no confession. Yes - maybe it will not happen - for all Doodhs says is generally right - but the panic is there even before we have moved towards the future!? Why?! Isnt that losing hope.

REDUX is the only thread people look up to and you and Doodhs are the proud parents and you know the attachment people have with the thread. They take your words for granted and they believe that whatever you say is gonna happen. In all probability it will - but at this juncture when IPK is already in shit - people getting paranoid is not a good idea for it will just lead to PH taking even more drastic and stupid measures than before.

No offence meant to anyone - U both know how much I adore you and your writing but today i felt negativity seep in. I understand the disappointment but I still have hope and I would like to keep that hope alive if nothing else. 😊

Originally posted by: nebuna

anna

i read another post of priya she has source from insiders
she just told that the cvs are working on repentance track
and for sure we have repentance track

Originally posted by: --Anna--

Logic exists if you want to look at the logic!

First who said ASR cannot confess first!?? Wasnt he going to tell Khushi that he loved her on the night of the wedding!? He was - so no his ego is not that big that when time demands it - he will not confess. ---- Recall the promo ... he said he will Justify why "uses farak kyon Padta hain" we in our minds put that as ILU ... if he wanted to say ILU .. in that promo itself they would've shown that ... but no even then he wanted to hide a bit of his feelings for her ... hence the mirror scene

Secondly - redemption is still possible and it will be very much logical if the creatives show it logical. It will be because Arnav said ILU at that moment for he was not sure whether he would get to speak to Khushi again. He did fight to survive - but he did not also want to let go of that chance. It indeed was a confession from heart. Don't you think if thats the reason ASR confessed ... then he should've told her i forgive you ... or i believe in you ... from audience pov both these would be as impactful as nerve racking as the ILU ... he left her with things unresolved .. .. he saw how desperate she was to clear her name ... belief in her is what she wants not ILU ... & for the life of me how can an ILU by ASR lead her to believe he is kidnapped is just force fed ... you are linking two completely disjointed things ...

But if you understand Arnav then you also can realize that Arnav can STILL go back on his words. More so - he never fell out of love from Khushi. That is the main point in play here. He was and is always in love with Khushi - him saying those words at that moment - just shows that he was always aware of his feelings towards Khushi - and he just put it in words. He cut the phone for he was not sure if she reciprocated the same since she became silent. ... This is not a repeat of diwali ..where he makes a pass at a girl & then dumps her cruelly .. will you as the audience accept if he goes back on his ILU ???

Third, Arnav needs to seek redemption from himself more than Khushi - and that will happen - once he realizes his mistake. Remember Nani's words - "if he cannot do anything for the people he loves - he will hurt himself." Khushi will definietly forgive him but for Arnav it will be difficult to accept that he spoiled her dreams and he treated her like crap. Arnav is a man of guilt and regret - if throwing Khushi outside to sleep can make him crawl to sofa - I think I can hope that realizing his sins will make him crawl into darkness. Here i completely agree with you ... he will try to redeem himself in his eyes ... i wrote this yesterday as well ... but more than Khushi ... i hope they focus on how by one impulsive act of his (releasing the fashion show footage) has ruined his sisters life ... ( this should be the breaking point of Arnav) the one person he always wanted to shield has come to shatters because of his action ... Once they both confess to their love ... how they got there will cease to be important ... Remember Khushi has also to redeem herself ... she too made him sleep outside while she dint even crawl onto the sofa but slept peacefully on the bed ?

Now I have given you a logical peek through into it - and it makes sense completely. Rest depends on the PH how they handle it. Ofcourse if they dont handle it in a logical way then we can go and shed some tears over ruining our serial - but judging it when it has not happend and deeming any logic to be impossible - oopsie - I cannot be that negative for a show that I have watched for 11 months.

I am an eternal optimist ... i am not saying i am not happy with the current track ... i am just questioning on what was promised by GUl to us ( search her interview in rangmunch just post ARHI wedding)... cannot be delivered without twisting the logic to fit...

For me execution is much more important .. as time & time again i have felt that writing is good but Mr. Khan has not understood the script given to him ... As script has to be tweaked as per the demands of time, actors, ph, channel , ratings ... but execution of the given word should not be hampered by anything ...

Originally posted by: --Anna--

Loved Loved your take on this.

Originally posted by: sree07

👏

thank god I got to read this before I log off.

With power comes with responsibility. khushi said that 😉

Originally posted by: ranjitha

Sathya
Read through the posts from page 1 today..
You will see so many posts saying that they are disappointed that Arnav's redemption is not happening... I know that CVs are planning for it.. yaha pe kisine keh diya aur sabne maan kiya... Bond paper pe likhke diya hain kisine ki nahin hoga? My point is WAIT.. WAIT TILL that situation comes and then cry !!! kal ko if they show redemption moral of the story will be "we commented on it, hence CVs changed it" and agar nahin dikhaaya toh "maine kaha tha na" type.. Give CVs a chance to show what they want it.. then lets discuss it... if they dont show Arnav's redemption, then I'll come first and rant about it here, for I dont go anywhere else.. this is my second home 🤗 but wait till it happens... REDUX is known for its positivity Sathu... but from past two days I have just seen '😭😡' smileys, thinking about a track that has not happened at all..

Ok I'm done for the day.. guests aa rahe hain ghar pe.. will have to help mom warna maar padegi 😆
Maine maidaan ni choda hain... will continue tomorrow 😆
See ya Sathu 🤗

P.S: this is not just for Sathu.. I'm not used to arguing in REDUX... I've fought a lot in main forums to the level of people throwing chappals at me, but luckily the atmosphere here is great... even if you people feel like throwing chappals, you dont 😆 I've written plenty today andhave not looked back at my posts, not once... so if my tone was harsh, my apologies... I wanted to say all these.. hope you understand, fine if you dont agree 😆