Crooner 72 : Eclipse...Updtd - Page 30

Originally posted by: p.sudha

Sejal, Anjali, Suba, Savvy, Anu, Indi, Zonera, SH and to all the wonderful writers out there

Loved each and every word written by you all. Work is not allowing me to quote you individually. Just wanted to say that all of you are

Originally posted by: Nandalala

Good wala morning/evening, guys!!! Khushi, how u doin', gal!? 😊 it's been forever!

Y'all have expressed my own thoughts abt the bashers/pontificators beautifully! Just begs the question: will these ppl ever be happy with what is shown or written? I don't think so...it's a pattern with them, and old habits--no matter how hurtful-die hard...I would rather tune into 20 minutes of so-called 'illogical..nonsense' any day than read what they have to say! 😃

Originally posted by: honeypriya

I never said a word even when people in the forum took direct digs at my post...when they said u obviously know wat,though it was so upsetting...coz it was me or us...and as part of the Forum was adjustable...and here we all bond in this Forum so well coz we love and respect each other - we are friends openly with everyone...

But isnt this Forum mainly for the love of this show - I agree constructive criticism is always healthy- dissecting the script, the scene, performance, making fun of the insconsistencies all a part of this Forum - and we always agree and abide by that...But when it comes to being a "critic" - and under the cap of "the most important one" - then it also comes with a sense of responsibilty - the day you think the show is in dumps - just leave the role...

"It's easy to attack and destroy an act of creation. It's a lot more difficult to perform one."
Chuck Palahniuk

We have always in this Forum wars over positivity and negativity - they co-exist and sometimes we crib and sometimes we understand - like that day the BS interview on FB - the uproar was understandable - he was being professional and hence justified - audience was being sentimental and hence justified.

But when it comes to the storyline - and the show - just understanding the mechanisms and establishing connections is not the role - there are sentiments too attached which should be understood - there is a very thin line between criticism and bashing - if you fall in the 2nd category, then no point watching the show anymore - if you were sticking for the X,Y,Z producer, thats not an enough reason - coz 90% audience doesnt give a damn who the producer or director of a Television show is - the characters, actors and the storyline along with the emotions is all that matters..

Now next thing - Just bcoz you see a personal post of the writer in a social networking site and misinterprete it - you make a huge uproar over it - just forgetting that arent we all responsible member in this Forum esp when we have a big reader base- my views are mine - why should I try impression someone about that - in hindi the word is "thopna" !!!

Critics can build and pull down creations - and that should always be kept in mind...thats why I have always maintained - my posts are just my views and has no inclination of putting down others and their views..you could have never loved something if you can so readily hate it - Shwets, I and you know the extreme depths of love and hate and how things can get ruined because of that - we are living examples 😆

This Forum gives joy and happiness to so many ppl - I will take her name - though usually I dont mention anyone by names for any reason - coz I respect everyone's privacy - but today I feel the necessity - Zoha lost her granny few days back, her mom is in hospital right now- she is going thru a very depressing phase - but this show brings her immense joy and smiles - the moments we love seeing this couple - seeing Barun Sobti like us ,makes her smile too and foregt all the worries - I spoke to her ystrday just before the show started - and all she said was the Forum which we loved or were hapy to be part of has become a bashing and warring zone - dont want to step in there - and she wanted to see ASR and the confession - I have not spoken to her since the epi - but am so sure if she would have seen in her trying times - the episode would have brought her smile and those 3 mins would have given her the joy that a Critic's bashing wont...

SO tell me, the so called critics - do you think just because the tracks change due to certain economics and market reasons (which is not our headaches but the PH's) - all we care is the end product - so the smiles and tears those scenes brought should we start digging and bashing them why they had to make these changes - or just bcoz few individuals didnt find it to their taste - you just go ahead and discredit every other viewer's sentiments - who are so attached to the show - if handful few didnt like it and the rest 98% liked - then bashing that product and those sentiments is what kind of criticism...

We are just normal viewers - and rightly u said and wat I wrote in a crooner last week - dont forget for many people this is their bread and butter - they are not doing it for fulfilling their creative hobbies like us penning down on IF - they might falter, they might conquer - but in a Public Forum...creating an uproar I dont find agreeable.

I never speak out these things openly Shwets u know that - but when people never knowing the actual insider news jump into conclusions - thats very upsetting - I am so happy BS is not net savvy - but I can say one thing our PH are very disappointed at present with the bashing thats going in the Forum - coz there are memebers who lets say are with the PH...and I am not kidding at all...

I am too sleepy and exhausted - so not sure how much sense I made above...and if I should or shouldnt have said anything - I do apologise honestly for hurting anyone's sentiments - this is nothing personal- but just that we are here coz we love the show - there are people around for whom its more than just a show - and when you see something which is close to "EPIC" in the show - the timing to bash and criticise so unjustifyingly is very upsetting...

Thanxx Shwets for bringing this up - this will be stand alone posts from us - we have never got into this controversial zone before and neither do I intend this space to have any of these going further...and yes, you dont need to Edit anything...🤗

Originally posted by: Nandalala

Good wala morning/evening, guys!!! Khushi, how u doin', gal!? 😊 it's been forever!

Y'all have expressed my own thoughts abt the bashers/pontificators beautifully! Just begs the question: will these ppl ever be happy with what is shown or written? I don't think so...it's a pattern with them, and old habits--no matter how hurtful-die hard...I would rather tune into 20 minutes of so-called 'illogical..nonsense' any day than read what they have to say! 😃