IP REDUX ; Khamosh Zuban !!

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Kishmish

@Kishmish

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#41

Loved the episode ... Sanaya and Barun were fabulous with their expressions ... waiting to read Tanthya's and Doods analysis ... read the article by Gul ... looks authentic enough ... Doods that was simply DOODALISTIC ... as usual ... Love the way you touch the loop opening and closing 😆 so yes we need for the terrace loop to be closed where A will get to know the actual truth behind the whole thing ... and Khushi's reasons behind hiding the truth from the Raizadas will be revealed ... Loved the new Rabba Vey ... it was really really very effective ...

Edited by Kishmish - 13 years ago

Quote

redwine1

@redwine1

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#42

Originally posted by: tanthya

Hi Redwine..Personally I preferred her in GH, sanaya was brilliant there ..I just wish the PH maintains this consistency throughout instead of pulling such bunnies only when TRP nosedives..

Today without an exception All were Good ..😊

So true ... hope the consistency from PH continues ... well they seem to have gotten up & taken notice of the fans at least (Guls post if authentic) ...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

sree07

@sree07

Rocker

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

#43

Gul responded in IF? Unbelievable! 😲

Well so now we are sure that they read redux everyday!😆

Quote

Prathima

@prathikri

Dazzler

Posted: 13 years ago

#44

Satya , what time do u post in the morning so that i can drop in at that time..
I really dont get the time in the day to read your analysis 😕

Quote

Arnav_Fan

@Arnav_Fan

Explorer

Posted: 13 years ago

#45

Originally posted by: --Anna--

Note to the Creatives
I do not know whether this is going to happen - but I want Khushi to feel the guilt of what her decision led to. We have seen Arnav guilty and regretting his actions time and again - its time Khushi is also shown considering that by hiding the truth - however good she may have wanted to do - she has committed a sin. They are equals in this - and she needs to realize what she had done was also wrong.

Hi Anna:

Loked you analysis and totally agree with your point that Khushi needs to reflect on her own actions. She lost the higher moral ground the minute she seriously thought that Arnav is actively trying to murder her to marry Lavanya. All said and done, accusing someone of being a murderer is way more serious than accusing someone of having affair with a married man. There are after all, laws in every country about murder and murderers. So CVs really need to work on Khushi's redemption too so she can regain some of the moral upper hand she had till this murder fiasco. I really don't agree with her reasoning for keeping mum. As you rightly pointed out, trust of any sort is something that is seriously missing in their relationship.

Cheers.

Quote

tanthya

@tanthya

Inactive

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

#46

Originally posted by: prathikri
Satya , what time do u post in the morning so that i can drop in at that time..
I really dont get the time in the day to read your analysis 😕

12 noon, sweetheart !!😛

Quote

Prathima

@prathikri

Dazzler

Posted: 13 years ago

#47

Originally posted by: tanthya

12 noon, sweetheart !!😛

Thanks Satya , will make drop in around 12 to read ur take 😃

Quote

ananya7736

@ananya7736

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

#48

Hi Ladies,

I never post on Redux, unless I have to praise someone be it Tanthya, Doodhs or Anna. No doubt all the analysis here make me see the episode in a new light.

But today I had to post and stand up for ASR because I cannot have this man blamed completely for what is happening in Khushi's life or his life. Today we all saw Khushi's pain and hurt and rightly so, but in thay everyone forgot what Arnav was going through when he spoke his heart out to her, when he was confused, when he was hoping that Khushi would somehow give him that peace that he is seeking, the urge to know that there is something he is missing in the whole misunderstanding. How he wanted to seek out an answer from her just so he could understand that he was wrong. Arnav wanted to be wrong today - He wanted Khushi to prove him wrong today and she could not. Maintaining her dignity she did not care to explain but where was her dignity when she was going to suicide for a man who deemed her to be worthless and useless!?

If I felt her pain today, I felt his too. They both are going through lot but the last line of Arnav 'U did not feel the need to explain it to me', was enough to show that how badly he wants her to prove him wrong and throw it on his face that he has committed an error. That is Arnav Singh Raizada for you ladies, however many mistakes and misunderstandings he may make, He regrets and is guilty over them.

Anna,

Loved your take as usual. You understand Arnav and his situations very well. I see that you are not biased only towards Arnav or towards Khushi. Also, I have been following your posts and love going through them. You make it easy for me to be in love with Arnav. Loved how you have started with the quotes from Humsafar. If I may ask what is it!? Also love the 3 dialogues and the photgraph moment. Beautiully explained. I do agree that Khushi also needs to face her guilt, she is not right. Yes she may not have felt the need to explain to Arnav today, but she should know and realize her mistake and repent as well.

Tanthya and Doodleberry will wait for your analysis. Signing off for now.

Quote

ananya7736

@ananya7736

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

#49

Originally posted by: Arnav_Fan

Hi Anna:

Loked you analysis and totally agree with your point that Khushi needs to reflect on her own actions. She lost the higher moral ground the minute she seriously thought that Arnav is actively trying to murder her to marry Lavanya. All said and done, accusing someone of being a murderer is way more serious than accusing someone of having affair with a married man. There are after all, laws in every country about murder and murderers. So CVs really need to work on Khushi's redemption too so she can regain some of the moral upper hand she had till this murder fiasco. I really don't agree with her reasoning for keeping mum. As you rightly pointed out, trust of any sort is something that is seriously missing in their relationship.

Cheers.

Hi! I agree with you on this. Khushi is a flawed character and her repentance should also be shown. She cannot always be right. All said and done, her one error in judgement which keeps continuing over the time is what has led to this whole mess. What I really would like to see is that if Arnav has to repent, Khushi's track of repentance should also be worked upon. She has made mistakes and she should also be held accountable for it as well. If Arnav has made mistakes morally so has Khushi and both need to seek repentance from each other and most importantly Anjali.

Quote

SunoNa123

@SunoNa123

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 13 years ago

#50

edited in page2 😃

Anna loved ur post,.., Its awesome👏

"Pehli baar sach kehna bahut mushkil hota hai - par uske baad zindagi sirf asaan hoti hai - but pehli baar jhooth bolna bahut asaan hota hai - uske baad zindagi sirf mushkil hoti hai."

U reminded me of humsafar, i hv obsession towards this shw..😆

I hardly cry over tele shows, the only time i cried in IPK was when Arnav broke down in middle of road and in humsafar the day Khirad is bout to deliver her baby, my heart churned for her that day..😭

If Arnav and Khushi are in any situation today it is because of their respective mistakes and the above quote matches them to hilt.

So nicely put up👏

its bth of their mistakes, they bth lacked trust in each other, bth think the worst of each other, one decision bth changed the worlds of each other and turned it upside down..

Ur write up on dialogues, photograph, stars very well put up..

And i so so agree with ur Note to CVs as well coz i hv always had that stand..

Bth of them are responsible and are at fault, bth need to realize their mistakes and learn and grow better by learning frm their mistakes..