Originally posted by: sree07
@pamk06 hi there... I think I am replying to your analysis first time. I read it almost every day. Hats off for all the hard work. 👏.
Regarding ASRs character butchering , I like to disagree with you a bit. The kid Vs ASR scene reminded me of a previous temple scene. The mighty cold hearted ASR who bend his knees in front of a kid to get a kiss from her 😊. At that time, ASR was at his fiery best. He was not the mellowed down version, we have currently. Still the interaction was cordial and affectionate to some extend. It was one of the character defining scenes of ASR. Yest episode just touched on the previous one.
The pretense or the great wall of ASR is always up when he has got audience. Here his interaction with kids was as natural as possible in the seclusion of the pool side. The emotions naturally flow from irritation, slowly turning to curiosity and then amusement. And at any point of time, I did not feel that ASR came out of his way to reach the kids. He was reacting within his comfort zone. That's so ASR. My POV.
"Oh I forgot, love has mellowed him down, right? He just cannot afford to make Khushi more upset or should I say Khushi's supporters so what if the cost is his plants or his sister's marriage???"
Relating the softness towards kids, with that of khushi is kind of over-refinement, I would say. I did not feel that the softness is directed to khushi in any level. The nikil kido and asr interaction was a stand alone piece IMO. No other emotion rules over that convo.
Sree,
Thanks for you reply. I will try to answer your reply.
That daywhen he interacted with that girl, he was at the emotional low, its was his parents death anniversary and that was expected, that was OK, he wanted to do some good. and he did but that had no connection with today
If as you say if we take today kid's scene as a standalone, just a interaction between the kid and ASR, and no audience then why did he react so viciously during the kanya puja...that time also there was no audience...but he bombarded the whole house, even his sister for a simple model.
Today, they were his plants, I agree with all emotions he showed, but my question is why is ASR showing them. Before he reached to water the plants, he was irritated with the fact that there were kids at home, shouldn't the absence of his plants blow his top, isn' that the ASR we know.
The ASR that i know at this point Should be angry, frustrated that his wife is having an affair with his brother in law and then she has the audacity to not talk to him, he wpuld be thinking that she is the one who is wrong and she is acting all righteous as if he is the one at fault... and in this temper he would not have cared how he interacted with the kid, and would definitely not interacted in the way he did...
The scene was good but just all wrong..but thats my POV.
Edited by pamk06 - 13 years ago
Love Friendship Dating and Relationships
Bindi
