Why Bhavya should be Chutki. - Page 3

Originally posted by: AnnzSageflower7

I've always stayed clear of speculating on the sisters because there was simply not enough clues anywhere in the story to link any of the girls together but threads of links be it , an innate camaraderie or similarities in spirit.

Each of the three women coming as wives to the brothers have their own character traits; Annika is protective &maternal, Gauri the pious one who's faith in goodness is unshakeable, Bhavya the courageous seeker of justice. These 3 look more impressive than the senior Bahus already.

Annika was left alone in childhood , probably by some mysterious tragedy that left her in charge of her little sister, which she thinks she has failed. She is ferocious in protecting Sahil, probably reflecting her now more powerful state of mind compared to the time she couldn't stop Chutki from being taken from her.

That's why she wouldn't dream of separating the brothers ever. Because she knows what that loss feels like deeply. But the sisters were left in a orphanage, presumably the same one by Mr Bajaj, I wonder what happened that she didn't go ask about Chutki.

Chutki on the other hand , was adopted into a family and would have to find her way back to the sister, and solve the mystery of her family's death. For this reason the best candidate for this person is Bhavya.

I feel Annika and Gauri are alike but their bond is in spirit not of blood. Bhavya on the other hand, strengthens Annika, teaching her patience and handling troubles smartly. i like the equation where Annika can be proud of Bhavya, and accept her counsel, Bhavya makes Annika better , more grounded. That's what family does .

Having said that, the journey back to the sister is Bhavya's to make, and to expose the tragedy that befell their family had to be at the hands of a cop no less.

I feel that Annika & Chutki were victims of Shakti Oberoi, that one sin that he keeps praying for penance from. To love Shivaay despite him being an Oberoi is my favourite theory for Annika. For Bhavya to be so vengeful and conflicted but being married to teddy bear Rudra, who's the Heart of the family.

phew i broke my theorizing bone there. Always fun to read your thought provoking posts Innika. Have a good Sunday ❤️

Originally posted by: ...Nihara...

Idk why but I feel gul will make all the 3 FL 's sisters😆 as it will be easy for her budjetwise also😆 that she can show everything in group,like group investigation,group mrg,group SR for all the couples😆.Overnight Nafratbaaz became sisters & suddenly the next day one of those sister Romi was not sister but sister-in-law😆,kuch bhi ho saktha hai in IB land😆

Originally posted by: -Ishqbaaaz-

@bold.. apparently that is the plan 😆 😆

no no no ... please no more "group romance" ...or should I say groupmance 🤢

Originally posted by: yellomellow

Interesting post. Personally, I prefer none of them being related. I hate long-lost sibling tracks in general, but if it must happen I prefer Gauri because I find her character more intriguing.

In DBO, I'm not sure I think Bhavya had a little brother. She has a personal vendetta against the Sultan because he had something to do with her family's death. She isn't a moral character she used Rudra without hesitation as a scapegoat while endangering him and his family to complete her mission. I was intrigued by the premise of a greyish ACP putting her duty first for the greater good, but the execution failed miserably. The silly fight scenes and overdose of the 90s song sequences ruined the impact for me. It's more an issue with the writing than the character or the couple. The reality is that the writers could have written a strong driven female lead, but they missed the mark. Watching from her DBO to IB I thought her character would improve and given substance, but her character is badly written. Honestly, if she was like you described I'm sure she would be a fan favorite or at least my favorite.

About Anika's past, whether she remembers anything or not is still unknown because of the inconsistent writing. Even during the NT track, she didn't remember Chutki till towards the end of the track. If your long-lost mother comes looking for you the first thing you would remember is your missing sibling. Even her nightmares and fear of the dark are completely forgotten only to appear at the writer's convenience. We still don't know when she was adopted or how she was treated by her adoptive parents. Her past was never explored so it's too soon to say she gave up on looking for her family. The way she stuck to Sahil despite all the horrible treatment makes it hard to believe she gave up on her own family. I think she might not even remember anything given the flashback about her childhood. She was old to remember her name, her parent's name, and where she lived so she could have easily gone home. She looked traumatized when she was found so she might have blocked it all out and only remembers bits and pieces. Or she might not have had the resources to investigate her past. Shivaay had to buy the orphanage to get her information so I'm not sure if they would have given her the file on her sister. She feared what her past held during the NT track, which suggests she doesn't even remember her own past. Her character is still a giant mystery.

As for Gauri, I believe she was adopted as a baby. I don't think anyone except the mother that raised her treated her well. Sadly, her past wasn't explored either in DBO. Gauri isn't exactly the cookie-cutter female lead, which is why I like her. The means justify the ends like Shivaay, but for her its not only exclusive to family members. She has no problem lying or playing dirty if it means winning over the bad guys,which is how I always wanted Anika to be in regards to Pinky lol. Personally, I think Gauri is more of a grey character than Bhavya will ever be because she commits and follows through with her plans. She played and used Svetlana to get a job, she took her money to spy on Om for her mother's treatment, back-stabbed Svetlana by helping Om, stabbed Kali Thakur with no hesitation, and took money from Om to help him rid himself of Svetlana for her mother's hospital bill. When dealing with villains she doesn't falter and fights fire with fire nor she is respectful (Bua Maa and Pinky confrontations), which leads me to believe she has experienced people like Pinky, Bua Maa, Tej and Svetlana in the past. Her childhood wasn't exactly the best since she couldn't even go to school, which is a sore spot for her. While she does feel guilty lying to good people it doesn't stop her from doing whatever she needs to do. There is a lot behind her innocent face and bubbly personality. Again, another giant mystery. She is similar in her kindness, but also very different in regards to her actions from Anika, which is why I like the dynamic of being sisters. Anika needs to be a bit more like Shivaay and Gauri sometimes its okay to play dirty and not everyone deserves respect.

It seems like the writers are keeping all their options open with the ladies, but it all will lead to the raaz the Oberoi seniors are hiding. The writers always change the story to fit the current track so it's possible what little background information given about the ladies will be ignored to make the sibling track work. So its possible that everything that was already shown will disappear and all three ladies will end up being siblings married to cousins 😆

Originally posted by: onlyrani

I think this is the dynamic the writers were going for with the introduction of her character. The siblings filling in the gaps for each other, but if you watched DBO its actually Gauri that has all those qualities you mentioned. Honestly, there is really no need to make any of them sisters. The writers could just focus on the FLs and give them all their own individual stories.

Since no one wants it I'm calling it now all 3 FLs will end up as sisters then the family secret will separate all the couples 😆

Originally posted by: NYCForever

interesting perspective!

and one of my fav writers is back, innika please complete your ff dear - want to read it 😉