The end of Ishana the character

vivacious_gurl thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 9 years ago
#1
Well a lot has already been discussed about this topic and the discussions have become heated... I'm not here for another heated discussion... I'm here to put forward my thots...
First n foremost... If vrushika Mehta was being replaced then the articles wud hv said VM being replaced... But all articles say VM quit... That means either they reduced ishana to a sidekick or they did away with the character...

Ppl r questioning what did pH do for two years of they cudnt write ishana n her story well... OK now do u all know that most shows have pilots shot? Recently Shaleen malhotravhad shot pilot for a show but for main show he was replaced with arjun bijlani ... There are atleast 10 shows which come to the channel every month with some or other pilot... Do all of them get airing... Nopes... The results of pilot r seen n then they take the show... However some phs directly start the show if the channel is confident about their concept... Some shows after working for 2/3 years n shooting pilots do not even see the light of the day.. All I am saying is even after hard work for two years, some concepts don't gel well with audience... Wider audience did not like ishana the character... Here we r discussing vrunal chemistry but truth be told vrunal hardly did scenes together... Just 4-5 scenes... N those will not hold for future... I totally understand vrushika's fan's agony and ishkara/vrunal shippers agony but mistakes from creatives in judging what ppl may life too happen... Look at another show at same time slot... They had to bring back the old lead... Coz ppl. Dint accept the new one n trps were dipping... Similarly trp wise ishana dint make sense...

Vrushika has been gracious to understand the creative differences and is moving ahead... Why can't fans too accept it and move ahead... Frankly even in online viewers only few loyal vrushika fans loved ishana as a character... I for one dint like her character at all... Bela Mala was very irritating.. N being a con girl ishana herself was so not for me... Vrushika is a talented actress n she took the role of Ishana after knowing what was in store coz actors r given brief of their character for next one month or so... So Knowingly she had taken the decision to be a part of the show... If her character wasnt accepted by viewers positively the Creatives r bound to change it... N she has accepted it... Please accept it... N be with her for her new projects... Stop bashing PH and producer or channel... Coz sometimes things don't work... N u hv to take decisions which may jot be good for everyone but may b best for the show...

This is an end to ishana the character as per me.. So either they will introduce a new lead for Om or they may redeem ridhima and show Om that Grey's exist as ridhima to me isn't evil... She just has been using Om's name and isn't really the social worker she pretends... She is just a show off rich girl

# Please no bashing or hate posts... This post isn't intended to hurt anyone's feelings... Let's all remember that behind the mask at IF there r real ppl and I request all fans to remember that u r bashing real ppl by handing behind the mask and that's very cowardly... If u really think someone is at fault.. Go n meet them in person... This virtual bashing is just so uncool

Created

Last reply

Replies

7

Views

2.6k

Users

8

Likes

22

Frequent Posters

popeye thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 9 years ago
#2
I respect your opinions and you put them across very well.
I for one do not want to see Omkara with Riddhima. I agree she isnt evil but I would like to see Omkara's love story start from the beginning anf not half way inbetween
I agree Ishaana was not well characterised and was juvenile but I think she can be redeemed. If not Vrushika then by another actress. I feel that Om can see her vulnerable side and see her fight for her family and herself and can still fall for her. I dont think her character is beyond redemption. I still think Vrushika would be good and I hope they give her a chance and she reconsiders. Otherwise I would like to see Ishana the character in the show played by someone else
1098676 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#3
When Gul actually showed Ishana scenes properly that we can say that audience did'nt accepted Ishana??? Gul never gave Ishana's character to develop or Ishkara to shine in the show. As for Kasam, Shivani was given a time of 1 month with maximum screenspace to get accepted by audience but still she failed. That's why Kratika came back but it's not the case with Vrushika or Ishana. Gul never gave her proper screenspace so how will audience accept her bcoz of her favroutism??? TRP did'nt got effected by Ishana as she was just a cameo.
RudrakshPreesha thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#4
i want a new FL for omkara new character, new name, new BG!!! or SvetKara anyday!!
Edited by OlicityQueen - 9 years ago
TheTroubleMaker thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 9 years ago
#5
I just do not understand one thing, SO much hatred for Gul, so much name-calling, accusing her for always being biased and claiming that she can never handle her shows well...calling her all sorts of name and still wasting precious time to get attached to her shows after "supposedly" knowing her so well ??
Does VM care? Does Gul care? They would probably be laughing and enjoying😆 And Its VM who has quit, its her decision not someone else's.

Ishana was never meant to be a successful character from the start...some could see it well in advance and some have realized it now!

Well, looking forward to some great Ishqbaazi coz I for one m loving the show and still as excited and hopeful about it😛

Edited by Crazy4Mayur - 9 years ago
manny136 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: OlicityQueen

i want a new FL for omkara new character, new name, new BG!!! or SvetKara anyday!!


I liked the bg lol but yeah if they r done with ishana get a new character some one good n if gul likes to recycle she can look back to her previous heroines. With the malika track what i lked about it was the family rivals aspect. Lets have a girl who is connected to oberois enemy n omkara falls for her n she hides her identity n obviously he feels betrayed. I wouldnt even mind if the entire family goes against the girl even dadi coz the enemity is pretty big, maybe back in punjab where their family comes from etc I would love for her to have an evil bro like in geet, man brij was cool 😆. We already have orphan anika, family friend soumya now we need an enemy romeo juliet type of thing going. Rhiddima is ok but as a couple they both seem too nice, no sparks n in shows ppl want to see a love story start n grow not be smack in the middle of it.i just want a clean break up, rhiddma is just confusing all sweet at one time n whiny n fake in another she is not fl material.
geet.a thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#7
Thank you so much for this di!
As usual, people just start bashing the Ph, writers, and every random person even remotely connected with the show. It's hilarious sometimes.
I wonder how and why it's so easy for some to forget these are not just titles, they are human beings with real feelings.
I never liked Ishana a lot and like you said, itna kuch khaas hua bhi nahi tha.
Haha the rest, i dont even want to get started on the bashing that goes on in the name of criticism about Gul and others.
As always the solution is simple: don't like it, don't watch it.
If you do not like the way a certain producer works, stop watching.

Anyhoo, i think this was a much needed post and im glad you made it!

Love
tehzeeb101 thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#8
But I loved Ishaana and VM so much! Ishkara had so much potential! From their fight you knew their story would be unique and intense. I can't believe they just scrapped everything. It would have been nice to finally see a grey female lead. I don't like what the writers are doing. Shivika has become boring and they are moving way too fast. There is no build up to their love story, Anika is falling way too soon! The whole script and plot has gone weak. I don't even feel like watching it anymore.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".