Originally posted by: Cshafkat
<font face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif" size="3" color="#ff3300">I dont understand why these people are bashing Shivaay! It's Anika's fault for starting everything in the first place and obviously Shivaay would insult an idiotic woman who shows him attitude despite being lower in status. Anyone would behave the way Shivaay behaves with Anika. In fact I believe Shivaay is way too generous. After all that she did to him, he should shut down her canteen business or do something that makes her cry very badly!!</font>
I would like to humbly disagree with you. Let's go into detail shall we
1 - Anika's approach to the temple situation was wrong. She should not have made a scene by shouting. But I don't consider her intentions wrong. Where God and prayer is concerned rich poor black white Saint sinner , all are equal. Coming to the next part, Anika breaking the windshield was violent but her slapping the money back on him was not. He did the same to her in the presence of a long line of people and honestly I would have been disappointed if she didn't throw the money back at him. The rich may think that money makes them immune, but it does not.
2 - Gobar scene major fault was with Anika. Nobody sits in the middle of the road to repair their sandals. I won't justify it but I found it funny and had a hearty laugh.
3 - Rehearsal scene - here Shivaay was wrong. You do not malign someone and compare them to waste on the road just because you happen to be born from a rich sperm. What is Shivaay Singh Oberoi, if the Oberoi part of his name is erased. If that legacy is taken away from him. Nothing until he builds an identity for him. Anika on the other hand has an identity no matter how insignificant it may be, it is an identity she build block by block, day by day.
4 - Water throwing - Anika was wrong. She could have calmly shown him the truth and wrongfulness of his action. Agreed.
5 - Pool scene - Manhandling ( or womanhandling) is plain simple unacceptable, no matter for what end it is being shown. You don't throw someone into the pool and order for an apology. Anika is wrong agreed but physically abusing someone to get a sorry that is equivalent to goon behavior to me and I definitely will not fall for such a man . The romantic bgm played there was stupid. Sending to jail without stopping to listen to his sister was inconsiderate and to an extent wrong. Anika did enter without permission so yeah she should have known about the consequences but she also did inform Priyanka.
6 - Latest manhandling scene - I absolutely loathe the fact that Shivaay considers Anika untrustworthy just because she is lower middle class girl. That is the ego in his power speaking and I would celebrate gladly the day CV's will show a crack in that part. Shivaay needs to come crashing down to earth and learn bit more humanity.
So yes I maybe more in support of Anika but I don't agree with how these two are approaching situations. But then again human nature does not conform to any set standards now do they? 😊
Members Lounge
Mr And Mrs Parshuram
Dr Aarambhi
Indian Premier League
