Mahabharat anyone??? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

1.3k

Users

10

Likes

19

Frequent Posters

Karaali thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: Amina-Zahra


Ab hum kar bhi kiya sakte hain? Hume to koi writer banata to hai nahi to inko hi jhelna bade ga 😆

Btw, today nothing to rant about in TPK? 😛 Not many people around there, I almost feel like a ghost, right now 😆


Nothing happening on the show so the forum is also quiet. This forum has so many FF and stories. keeps it busy.
Karaali thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: -Enigmatic-

Are you really serious ?
Omkara is like duryodhan
Pinky=kunti
Shivaay=Yudhishtir ?

Duryodhan had no morals & values..he was the most selfish.. & here omkara is the man of principles,he loves his brothers like anything else in the world.

Kunti was strongest,determinded woman but wasn't selfish .she had ethics,she was on the path of truth where pinky is most selfish lady in the world,she hates omkara.

Same to yudhishtir he had ethics ,he always stick to truth where shivaay can go to any extent to satisfy his ego & business.
Take a example of omkara & shivaay's arguments over that man ashok.

Only tej is a bad person from omkara's side but you are puttinv everyone from his side in bad light.

& not to forget shakti isn't like pandu.. in upcoming days his motives will be revealed..cos in 1st epi when dadi introduced shakti she said" pata nhin kyo aisa lagta hain jo woh dikhata hain woh hain nahin"

No mahabharta.. no ramayana..
I hope gul dont repeat this


Yes, I am serious. I do see a lot of similarities. I don't know if the show will go in that direction or stray more into brotherly bonding direction. Currently the CVs have kept all options open.

As for who was good or bad in Mahabharat, its all about the POV as it is a complex tale with complex characters. I don't consider Duryodhan bad or evil.

Edited by Katori - 9 years ago
Patharsitara thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 9 years ago
#23
no it is not similar mahabharat
tej:he does not blindly loved his son as dhritrastra loved duryodhan.he lived
whole life protecting duryodhan and covering his crimes.

shivay:yudhisthir was not angry young man.he was composed in toughest of situation.
pinky:kunti was not gossiping monger & show off style taunting others and enjoying
wealth.she lived most of her life without any privledge.

omkara:duryodhan??omg!duryodhan was opportunist ,selfish and ruthless.

duryodhan was evil character.he did not have mercy.i dont know why some
whitewash him.he was good to only his ppl.he was terror to others.
even ravan is saint in front of him.
i dont think omkara is going to be
negative because he is definitely most liked character now.cv will not
risk spoiling him.


most important is this show is clearly about brotherly love and sacrifices
not brother hate war like mahabharat.

IlaTanwar thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 9 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: Amina-Zahra

Hey, Katori 😉

Na, I'd say the similarities to Mahabharat are more superficial than anything. As you yourself pointed out one of the main differences: Omkara's character, he's devoted to his brothers and not interested in the business, not even in the least. Also, the comparison of Shivaay to Yudhistr doesn't really hold up, does it? From what I know, Yudhistr was "big" on morals/laws etc... whereas Shivaay is crooked. He can do anything for his family, even to satisfy his own ego, and breaking moral codes isn't that difficult for him - unlike Omkara.

Jhanvi, too, doesn't seem to be blind to everything going on around her, tbh. We didn't get that good an insight to her character, as of now, but she seems like a sharp woman. As for Shakti - I wouldn't be too sure about him. He seems subdued and guilt ridden due to something, but as they see, still waters run deep. I think there's more to him than meets the eye.

Anyway, I have to keep this short, lol xD Have to rush off. Eitherway, if they ruin the brothers' relationship (and I don't mean showing tensions and other difficulties, but really ruining it) - then that was that for me. The show's essence is the brother's love for each other, imho, if that gets lost along the way, no use to watching it for me 😆


Agree with your all point i am not finding any similarity... Specially Omkara as dhuryodhan not even a single trait is matched here...

Yeah about Shivaay too ...The person who usedx his power to arrest a girl in night which is a wrong and against the law the how could he be like yudhishter...

Shakti part too is right it is really a different who is something but portrays something else...

Yeah Essence is Obros hope the PH or cv don't ruin it...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".