i have some question from my muslim friends if here - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

42

Views

3.9k

Users

11

Likes

67

Frequent Posters

zajedno thumbnail
Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail 9th Anniversary Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 7 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: HeavenlyBliss.

if anyone has any questions regarding Islam, you can check out islamqa.info/en

thanks😉
adni143 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: HeavenlyBliss.

if anyone has any questions regarding Islam, you can check out islamqa.info/en

thanks
Free_Rein thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#13
I have one muslim friend,i was asking questions to her out of curiosity regarding her rituals, i remember once she told that there will be judgement day after life for everyone(both muslims and also non-muslims),based on the sins they committed in their lifetime they will get judgement from Allah on that day and what comes under Sins and what not comes under sins is in Quran.

She also said all human beings in the world were muslims in the beginning but got deviated as non-muslims later, There was one hindu girl converted into muslim in our locality,regarding her my friend told that girl will definitely go to heaven even though she commit sins as she RECONVERTED/REVIVED into muslim,she said it should not be called "Conversion" because all human beings were muslims in the beginning so it should be called "RECONVERSION".After reconverted to muslim,they are like newly born child without any sins in front of Allah.

She also said some great scholars researched all the religions , holy books and came to conclusion that Islam is the only or best religion of all and Quran is the best holy book of all and they also followed islam after research
And also said God have no physical form or visible form,God is invisible and God is only one in this world ie., "Allah" and He give judgement on Judgement day for the all the human beings( muslims and non-muslims)in the world,If they follow Quran and Islam strictly,there would be less sins and they will get better judgement.
Also said,babas,peers,prophets should not be called "GOd" but should be just called " followers of God" as they had physical or visible form and they should not be worshipped.She doen't go to any "Dharga" as there are just samaadis of prophets or babas and they are not gods but just followers of god.

I heard some rituals from her like they shouldn't use chappals used outside in bathroom but should use separate chappals,i didn't clearly remember the reason but i was always curious to know various things from her,i only remembered this for now ,if i remember anything more i can tell later.

Regarding me,i am a hindu but don't follow any religion or rituals but i believe there is god and believe in god and i remember him and prays/asks him whenever i get into trouble and asks for some strength from him,I like to go to temples,churches etc., all the places of god.i have no objection to pray to any god of hindu,allah or jesus,I also remembered now that she also told Jesus is not a god,he is a prophet (follower of god).

If i offended any muslim here,pls let me know i will apologise and edit this,as i respect all religions in the world eventhough not following any of them.


Edited by ...Nihara... - 7 years ago
heavenlybliss thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: ...Nihara...

I have one muslim friend,i was asking questions to her out of curiosity regarding her rituals, i remember once she told that there will be judgement day after life for everyone(both muslims and also non-muslims),based on the sins they committed in their lifetime they will get judgement from Allah on that day and what comes under Sins and what not comes under sins is in Quran.


She also said all human beings in the world were muslims in the beginning but got deviated as non-muslims later, There was one hindu girl converted into muslim in our locality,regarding her my friend told that girl will definitely go to heaven even though she commit sins as she RECONVERTED/REVIVED into muslim,she said it should not be called "Conversion" because all human beings were muslims in the beginning so it should be called "RECONVERSION".After reconverted to muslim,they are like newly born child without any sins in front of Allah.

She also said some great scholars researched all the religions , holy books and came to conclusion that Islam is the only or best religion of all and Quran is the best holy book of all and they also followed islam after research
And also said God have no physical form or visible form,God is invisible and God is only one in this world ie., "Allah" and He give judgement on Judgement day for the all the human beings( muslims and non-muslims)in the world,If they follow Quran and Islam strictly,there would be less sins and they will get better judgement.
Also said,babas,peers,prophets should not be called "GOd" but should be just called " followers of God" as they had physical or visible form and they should not be worshipped.She doen't go to any "Dharga" as there are just samaadis of prophets or babas and they are not gods but just followers of god.

I heard some rituals from her like they shouldn't use chappals used outside in bathroom but should use separate chappals,i didn't clearly remember the reason but i was always curious to know various things from her,i only remembered this for now ,if i remember anything more i can tell later.

Regarding me,i am a hindu but don't follow any religion or rituals but i believe there is god and believe in god and i remember him and prays/asks him whenever i get into trouble and asks for some strength from him,I like to go to temples,churches etc., all the places of god.i have no objection to pray to any god of hindu,allah or jesus,I also remembered now that she also told Jesus is not a god,he is a prophet (follower of god).

If i offended any muslim here,pls let me know i will apologise and edit this,as i respect all religions in the world eventhough not following any of them.



BOLD, everything else you mentioned is true but the chapals thing you said i am hearing for the first time...i dont think there is any such thing...just mere superstitions...anyone who knows anything about this then plz correct me
Free_Rein thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: HeavenlyBliss.


BOLD, everything else you mentioned is true but the chapals thing you said i am hearing for the first time...i dont think there is any such thing...just mere superstitions...anyone who knows anything about this then plz correct me


She definitely said some reason but i didn't remember clearly,something like they should remember Allah even during that time in bathroom also,so should wear separate one sorry if am wrong,i don't remember now.we can check it in google i guess.
adni143 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: ...Nihara...

I have one muslim friend,i was asking questions to her out of curiosity regarding her rituals, i remember once she told that there will be judgement day after life for everyone(both muslims and also non-muslims),based on the sins they committed in their lifetime they will get judgement from Allah on that day and what comes under Sins and what not comes under sins is in Quran.


She also said all human beings in the world were muslims in the beginning but got deviated as non-muslims later, There was one hindu girl converted into muslim in our locality,regarding her my friend told that girl will definitely go to heaven even though she commit sins as she RECONVERTED/REVIVED into muslim,she said it should not be called "Conversion" because all human beings were muslims in the beginning so it should be called "RECONVERSION".After reconverted to muslim,they are like newly born child without any sins in front of Allah.

She also said some great scholars researched all the religions , holy books and came to conclusion that Islam is the only or best religion of all and Quran is the best holy book of all and they also followed islam after research
And also said God have no physical form or visible form,God is invisible and God is only one in this world ie., "Allah" and He give judgement on Judgement day for the all the human beings( muslims and non-muslims)in the world,If they follow Quran and Islam strictly,there would be less sins and they will get better judgement.
Also said,babas,peers,prophets should not be called "GOd" but should be just called " followers of God" as they had physical or visible form and they should not be worshipped.She doen't go to any "Dharga" as there are just samaadis of prophets or babas and they are not gods but just followers of god.

I heard some rituals from her like they shouldn't use chappals used outside in bathroom but should use separate chappals,i didn't clearly remember the reason but i was always curious to know various things from her,i only remembered this for now ,if i remember anything more i can tell later.

Regarding me,i am a hindu but don't follow any religion or rituals but i believe there is god and believe in god and i remember him and prays/asks him whenever i get into trouble and asks for some strength from him,I like to go to temples,churches etc., all the places of god.i have no objection to pray to any god of hindu,allah or jesus,I also remembered now that she also told Jesus is not a god,he is a prophet (follower of god).

If i offended any muslim here,pls let me know i will apologise and edit this,as i respect all religions in the world eventhough not following any of them.


exactly my case is even same
and i feel all hindus whom i encountered has same thoughts
and as i said that i am or was somewhat having cordial relation with that muslim batchmate in start she also used to say all this
but as i said slowly slowly in 3 years she fully renovated herself that when i saw her after lowng time as we work in different department i wasliterally shocked and it took me 2 minute to recognize her and when i talked to her she said all those thing
anyway i even have always lots of question regardig muslim religion but feel afraid to ask as i said my that friend i asked her once in first year and she even got offended and gave only one reason that its written and cant be changed and then she somewhat got rude so i stopped my question there only but now she herself talk to me sometime when we meeet and discuss on this topic
anyway i even respect other religion and love praying everyone and every rituals but as a hindu i question my religion alot and thats how i even question for muslimi feel that everyone says female should be given respect and make certain laws to protect female and we have reached an era about where all male female are treated equally who came from an era where women was merely treated like animals so i feel a time will come in future evolution will occur and it will make female stronger than male and that time if we follow todays law then that would be unjust to male
and this is purely my feeling
i hold a lot respect for Allah, prophet, God, Jesus or any founder of religion as they brought change in society and done their best to uplift it at that time but i cant follow or believe or support in blind beliefs associated with any religion
like in this show i love the way zara is promoting islam and it is true
i feel prophet the time when he founded the religion there women would be treated abnormally and alot brutal activity was going on and he decided to find a way which can end that and you cant just write everything and it will spread he would have written quran with alot thinking so that suffering ould be reduced and it would reach to most people and bring change in that society
anyway i feel that if i cant change my father and mother blind beliefs then i feel its really hard for us to undertsnd them and them to us because all human being are different and their thinking are even
i have came across two muslim friends personally first my crush who was really very much liberal and he was much like us always and other was my batchmate
and have met many of my father friend but they all are army not hindu muslim as in army all are really friendly and everyone love and like to learn others culture
anyway i love discussing on this topic i dont know about quran but i read philosphy and our all itihash and many books and i love knowing the reason
like from my childhood days only i never elieved karna as surya putra or any pandava as devputra and i used to tell my mother even this that time only when i was abou 5 or 6 years old basically from very start i used to question each and everything although and fther never taught me as they themselves believed


adni143 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: ...Nihara...


She definitely said some reason but i didn't remember clearly,something like they should remember Allah even during that time in bathroom also,so should wear separate one sorry if am wrong,i don't remember now.we can check it in google i guess.

heavenlybliss thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: ...Nihara...


we have supplications before entering and when leaving the bathroom, but we are not permitted to say his name or recite anything holy while in the toilet😳
She definitely said some reason but i didn't remember clearly,something like they should remember Allah even during that time in bathroom also,so should wear separate one sorry if am wrong,i don't remember now.we can check it in google i guess.

Free_Rein thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#19
@adni143
Yeah i checked the same site coincidentally even before you posting the link😆 and read the entire thing there.

I am more of a scientic person i believe only if it is proved scientifically 😆and don't believe blindly,i doubt a lot of things in all the religions and i don't like to doubt so i don't want to follow any religion😆,sometimes i doubt whether there is a god and don't want to doubt it so i remember god only when am in trouble😆,i feel believing there is a god will always have a positive outcome,so i want to be optimistic and want to get positive vibes in low situations😆,i can shift entire burden on something more superior to me definitely gives me strength in those situations,so i like/choose to believe in god.

I also have a lot of doubts regarding Sun,moon etc., in puranas😆,how sun had a physical form😆,how kunthi got pregnant and gave birth to karna by simply enjoying looking at the sun😆,and also how Sita devi born from the earth scientifically😆,how a fish got pregnant by simply swallowing sweat of hanuman and gave birth to other human/god 😆 and if you ask i have doubts about shani show😆,Shani is nothing but saturn na?Saturn along with other 8 planets originated from sun itself scientically but according to that show how a sun and saturn took a physical form?😆,Is it merely a blind belief ?😆
Edited by ...Nihara... - 7 years ago
adni143 thumbnail
8th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: ...Nihara...

@adni143

Yeah i checked the same site coincidentally even before you posting the link😆 and read the entire thing there.

I am more of a scientic person i believe only if it is proved scientifically 😆and don't believe blindly,i doubt a lot of things in all the religions and i don't like to doubt so i don't want to follow any religion😆,sometimes i doubt whether there is a god and don't want to doubt it so i remember god only when am in trouble😆,i feel believing there is a god will always have a positive outcome,so i want to be optimistic and want to get positive vibes in low situations😆,i can shift entire burden on something more superior to me definitely gives me strength in those situations,so i like/choose to believe in god.

I also have a lot of doubts regarding Sun,moon etc., in puranas😆,how sun had a physical form😆,how kunthi got pregnant and gave birth to karna by simply enjoying looking at the sun😆,and also how Sita devi born from the earth scientifically😆,how a fish got pregnant by simply swallowing sweat of hanuman and gave birth to other human/god 😆 and if you ask i have doubts about shani show😆,Shani is nothing but saturn na?Saturn along with other 8 planets originated from sun itself scientically but according to that show how a sun and saturn took a physical form?😆,Is it merely a blind belief ?😆

not every question but i can answer your some question from whatever i read and understood
kunthi go pregnant from different rishis who was from surya dynasty or indra dynasty and asif it would have been told that she got pregnant before mmarriage then noone will like it so vyasa turned it around and the mantra thing which is told researchers say that she got sexual education from him and they both flown in emotion
pandu not left just because he was give shrap he left because he cant become father as kunti and pandu was married from 7 years and was not having childand many other thing was written through symbolism so it could reach common peple throuh generations
about sita devi it may be that she was daughter of someone from janakpuri or around villages and her parent simply put her under the earth and she was found by janak as there were news that how a child survived in earthquaje even after living underground for years
and about hanuman it was time of evolution so maybe it was possible satyavati of mahabharat was also born from a fish
like in ramayana it is mentioned that himalya has alot herbs and today even it is believed that there are which we dont know as even now it is preserved by nature and this is the reason ganga river even after so much pollution is still different from others
and about saturn or any other planet story is in purana whih is considered rishi muni tried to give their knowledge about formation of different planet from their discoveries by naming it as agod but it is till a hideen fact that in the story whom they are referring actually the fact is even today scientist are even not able to reach where rishi munis reached very before and thus they mock those writing as faiytale the day when they will discover those thing they will believe it themselves like they realised bigbagng theory our yga or our ayurvedic science and many other and the scientist who are able t understand this you can read that how they write to preserve hnduism or their written thing as it is very deep that we cant imagine now but as it is said everything is unimaginable not impossible like i said about frog in the welll
like the bigget example our nalanda university who has alot discoveries and it is believed that there every type of medicine or best way of usage of vedas were written but it got burnt
like indra dvta t is said for run you should pray indra devta actually there is scientific region actuall we dont know actual puja that time the praying and the ritual were performed in such a way that it generate cloud seeding and thus rain happened but in our blind believes we today even are doingsso
we dont know the climate weather or people of that time what exactly they were what they were made of exactly or how was the earth environment that time
this is the reason i am reffering to evolution witime thing changes we cant apply something now which was valid years ago because years ago noone thought that areoplane would be discovered or many other thing but right now we are totally in different era indifferent urrounding and a protective law
so i feel noone should be taught how to respect female but everyone should be taught to everyone and eveything
i know some boys are ill mannered and done alot of missbehaviour but due to those boys disciplined and nice boys get the punishment even after not doing anything and if a time will come when female would dominate in power and even will get more strength and can even produce babies then what you think where male will go with todday laws made for female but those male will becaome like previous generation female and even worse than that as female has got god greetttest gift of carrying a child even
and there is alot of fact which we can understand only if we can imagine but believe me the day if anyone can understand vedas they will know about whole universe and thier history and vishnu is not some physical body it is the shape and name assigned to whole universe and thats why it is written that he lives in mahasagar maily they are tring to refer the whole universe oi some liquid energy like you can consider air even as liquid body and brahma is jusst a galaxy and part of universe or vishnu and thus there are many brahmands which is in this universe or a part of universe
and thus there are many such thing referred through this theory which are unimaginable for us to imagine so we tell it as fairytale
anyway right now i even am reading all those thing as i love doing in part time and i even dont know many other facts


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".