Judges reaction

Page

kareena

@n_s_n_l

Beginner

Posted: 8 years ago

Hi all, am I the only one who found the judges reaction a bit weird when Maalavika was declared evicted from the show? I thought Sonu liked her during her stay in Indian Idol but yesterday his behaviour was quite odd, by laughing and all. Even though for every other singer they atleast 'acted' surprised on their elimination.

Quote

Frequent Posters

Raina

@Raina101

Dazzler

Posted: 8 years ago

Have you thought how a top performer got out?
If you have the highest judges score even the lowest audience votes would make her stand at number 3.

Clearly, she was axed in favour of someone else (most likely Rohit or KB). I'm sure the judges knew. If as a viewer I can calculate (such a simple calculation), you think the judges wouldn't know if they went by their calculation Maalavika would be safe?

Clearly, the top three have been decided by the channel. And hence the judges reactions were what we saw. They knew what was coming.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

fatssrilanka

@fatssrilanka

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: ~Raina~
Have you thought how a top performer got out?
If you have the highest judges score even the lowest audience votes would make her stand at number 3.

Clearly, she was axed in favour of someone else (most likely Rohit or KB). I'm sure the judges knew. If as a viewer I can calculate (such a simple calculation), you think the judges wouldn't know if they went by their calculation Maalavika would be safe?

Clearly, the top three have been decided by the channel. And hence the judges reactions were what we saw. They knew what was coming.

Yes, even I think so too. I think the channel shouldn't intervene in a reality show. But,my question is what was reason behind Malavika's elimination?

Quote

nmn6

@nmn6

Explorer

Posted: 8 years ago

Ya seems like something is fishy . Malavika was a great singer. Though I don't favour her more but still the fact is she is talented. I don't know how much this is true but some where I read that the channel got money from xyz to make KB as winner . But truly KB wasn't deserving to be in top 3 . Mohit, malavika any one would be great. No offence to anyone. I just mentioned what I read that's it.

Quote

beanaq

@beanaq

Explorer

Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: nmn6
Ya seems like something is fishy . Malavika was a great singer. Though I don't favour her more but still the fact is she is talented. I don't know how much this is true but some where I read that the channel got money from xyz to make KB as winner . But truly KB wasn't deserving to be in top 3 . Mohit, malavika any one would be great. No offence to anyone. I just mentioned what I read that's it.

OH Just common be normal!🤢 what do you know about singing? just leave that poor guy alone he is the BEST of all.

He can sing far more better than Malavika(she was my favorite😛) but no offense she has 17 years of training. KB👏 sang much more than anyone with zero training.

Edited by beanaq - 8 years ago

Quote

Dabulls23

@Dabulls23

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: ~Raina~
Have you thought how a top performer got out?
If you have the highest judges score even the lowest audience votes would make her stand at number 3.

Clearly, she was axed in favour of someone else (most likely Rohit or KB). I'm sure the judges knew. If as a viewer I can calculate (such a simple calculation), you think the judges wouldn't know if they went by their calculation Maalavika would be safe?

Clearly, the top three have been decided by the channel. And hence the judges reactions were what we saw. They knew what was coming.

I agree with you on most part. Rohit is 10000000% better and trained singer over KB. Some may think he is not a complete package.

Looking at that Maalvika and Revant make a total package. One of them should win than.

But Channel and judges promoting KB with all the sob stories abt his father. Lord I lost my father @ 3 and I don't sit and cry to garner sympathy. Its not KB's fault for this. Its channel using his info for votes. Shame on Channel and judges to give so much TV time to this one contestant. 😲😡🤢

Quote

kirti98

@kirti98

Navigator

Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: ~Raina~
Have you thought how a top performer got out?
If you have the highest judges score even the lowest audience votes would make her stand at number 3.

Clearly, she was axed in favour of someone else (most likely Rohit or KB). I'm sure the judges knew. If as a viewer I can calculate (such a simple calculation), you think the judges wouldn't know if they went by their calculation Maalavika would be safe?

Clearly, the top three have been decided by the channel. And hence the judges reactions were what we saw. They knew what was coming.

even i thought the judges were so normal. sonly only telling aww to malvika when she started crying. no one gave her tasalli also

Quote

Micky

@micky11

Navigator

Posted: 8 years ago

Originally posted by: ~Raina~
Have you thought how a top performer got out?
If you have the highest judges score even the lowest audience votes would make her stand at number 3.

Clearly, she was axed in favour of someone else (most likely Rohit or KB). I'm sure the judges knew. If as a viewer I can calculate (such a simple calculation), you think the judges wouldn't know if they went by their calculation Maalavika would be safe?

Clearly, the top three have been decided by the channel. And hence the judges reactions were what we saw. They knew what was coming.

Revanth #Anu Maliks favorite

KB# Farah

Rohit# Sonu nigam

So where could the top singer like Malvika go

She have faced judges unfair preferential treatment