Shravan's Elimination- UNFAIR - Page 3

Originally posted by: LizzieBennett

Here's a link I found on twitter for the next episode promo stills. Shravan is definitely out it seems

https://twitter.com/lubna_mb/status/834033153983598593

Originally posted by: pjyo

😭😭UNFAIR 😲..😒.

Now i feel judges knew it last week itself ,thats why they praised him even more than usual ,anu's ,"if u ever need me in life " promises now make sense...🤔

😲 What! shocking, he was the best in Indian Idol. 😭 I wonder how do even votes count; apart from of course people giving regionalism, good looks more importance to right contestant 🥱 I realy hope, he can come back. if not, I hope he still makes it big, looking at Indian Idol's track record where more than winners most of the times other contestants have been successful in the long run. (with the exception of Abhijeet Sawant to some extent).

I think it was fair. Clearly Shravan has lesser fans and that he got lesser votes is no surprise.

Of course losing a talent like him is indeed sad. But blaming everything on the channel is being harsh. In bringing Manya back, they clearly had a hand since no audience was involved.

Depends on what you mean by "fair". It's certainly not fair that Shravan has been eliminated. Its also not fair that he has "fewer fans".

Not everyone appreciates the same style of music. So someone having fewer fans can't be unfair. Everyone is entitled to an opinion.
While based on talent Shravan should've stayed, but audience votes play an important part in Indian idol. Unfortunately not enough fans voted for him.
He has the judges approval, but we don't know his scores or whether he was rated number 2,3 or 7 by the judges. There is a possibility even at number 2 if he got the fewest audience votes, while someone rated 7 by judges got the highest votes, his being eliminated could be fair.

I'm not commenting on whether Sony is fair or not, but we can't blame the channel without proof.

I definitely don't enjoy the sob stories or unnecessary drama, but that's what probably sells. And the channel is obviously looking at their bottom line, can't blame them for that.

Having said that, I'm really sad to see Shravan go so soon. To be honest, i knew he wouldn't win, but he's left to soon.

I'm not trying to get into an argument with anyone, though I foresee some of my comments being blown out of proportion. I don't mean to target anyone. Just stating what I think.

And with that I'm not going to get into any conversation regarding this.

Originally posted by: LizzieBennett

Depends on what you mean by "fair". It's certainly not fair that Shravan has been eliminated. Its also not fair that he has "fewer fans".

He clearly had the judges' approval. And I did see a lot of support for him here on this forum. If the results are meant to be a mix of judges' votes and audience votes, how could he have been the one to go? What percent of the judges' vote count? Do they count at all? If yes, why are we not shown numbers? Where is the transparency? When everything is happening behind the scene and we are just told of the end result, it is hard to accept that it's all honest and aboveboard! That is why the finger-pointing at the channel!

When they can repeat sob stories ad nauseum and promote only those contestants who they think "sell" and get then TRPs, why cannot they manipulate the results?

I'm sorry but I will believe that the results are "fair" only when I have actual proof of it!

I also didn't expect him to win. But him going out this soon, especially immediately after Manya, reeks of unfairness. In fact, stinks!

its not fair to see shravan go especially after a great performance. Based on talent, he deserves so much better than some so called professional singers, no offence.

Next time if you guys wants to participate in reality show, please make sure you cook up some sob stories and plan that with your family and friends or do some cosmetic surgery so that you look like a movie hero or heroine.

If you don't like shravan is fine, but to say it's fair to get him eliminated it's just not reasonable. I would blame the channel for less promotion and secondly the audience who couldn't appreciate real talents.

Anyways all the best to shravan, this is not the end of the world, his music is here to stay...