Sony is Responsible for ................. - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

2.7k

Users

10

Frequent Posters

193980 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#11

@Priya & Siddh: I am too lazy to type😛 but concur with your views.

144398 thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: siddh_v



So true but they are going to keep on doing this till us viewers put a stop to this. We should boycott this show. We all know its a money making drama. The whole show is totally scripted . Yes the judges do a good job in choosing mostly accept one mistake which eats talented singers. Why dose Amey need to still struggle to come out with his album. We all think that he was talented. We did some drama which was started by the judges. Which was totally fake, we all made promises that we are not gonna watch sony tv anymore, what happened to that?? I am not pointing fingers because i was the first one there.

That is so true...And Where's Amey today and didn't anu malik promise him that he will give him a break??

What happend abt that??

siddh_v thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: priyagurung

That is so true...And Where's Amey today and didn't anu malik promise him that he will give him a break??

What happend abt that??



Oh didnt Anu Malik almost promise everybody in Indian Idol 2 that he will give Amey, Antra and Meenal a brake???? What happened to that???
Tabzy thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: Maya_M

@Priya & Siddh: I am too lazy to type😛 but concur with your views.

sme here...m enjoying readin the debate😛

greatmaratha thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 18 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: siddh_v



So true but they are going to keep on doing this till us viewers put a stop to this. We should boycott this show. We all know its a money making drama. The whole show is totally scripted . Yes the judges do a good job in choosing mostly accept one mistake which eats talented singers. Why dose Amey need to still struggle to come out with his album. We all think that he was talented. We did some drama which was started by the judges. Which was totally fake, we all made promises that we are not gonna watch sony tv anymore, what happened to that?? I am not pointing fingers because i was the first one there.



In some ways we all do our bit towards it, dont we. U filed a petition, got it to the notice of the media. On my part, I do not support anyone whom the Channel blesses with controversial stories... I did not support Abhishek after his parental sob story was flashed on prime time television in II. And in SRGMP, I stopped supporting Poonam after the Judges started making her out to be some kind of bhikari, by begging votes in the name of her poor economical situation. but yeah, it is difficult to completely boycott the show.

Shold not someone do something which will make the channels stop exploiting these young contestants such. I only recall the incident of Priyanka from II 1, where her father decided to withdraw her from the contest in view of the harsh demands and conditiions contained in the agreement. Kudos to that man.
Ms. Bholi Bhali thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 18 years ago
#16
thats interesting. I will post my answers shortly, just being busy on personal level. catch u guys later
abru07 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: Ms. Bholi Bhali

Sandeep's Failure!!!

Today after a long time, I was listening to Sandeep's album, "Mere Saath Sara Jahan" and I was thinking, how much sony has been unfair to him. His songs would have done great, if they were promoted, whole heartedly!!! There are many songs in the album, jin ki agar video banti tu, it would have rocked. They organized a flop album launch show and actually did nothing to promote him.

For Abhijeet, they made 2 music videos and promoted them big time. He was called for every possible show and party. every Sony event. whereas Sandeep was hardly seen anywhere. he wasnt called once in season 3. he got one video, which was not even the best one. and wasn't promoted at all!!!

I think it is Sony's fault that Sandeep didn't got the due popularity which Abhijeet has today, even though he is not a better singer then Sandeep (my personal opinion) It is coz of sony, that every other person from other channel stand up and make a mockery of II contestants. If you dont respect ur own family members, then why would other ppl will!!!

if they think Karunya was deserving, then see now he has come out with an album, and honestly speaking there is nothing exceptional about it. It is just another album.

I hope they dont do the same with Prashant, and suppress his talent, like they did to Sandeep's!



That's where I disagree! You can't compare a great singer like karunya to a below average singer Sandeep. Have you watched II2, every single performance of him was either mediocre or "not-so-great" and I am using those words because I don't wanna sound trashy....
While Karunya on the other hand, is a great flawless singer; you cannot ever compare them....

As far as Prashant is concerned, I am sure he's gonna be another sandeep.. Because again he was good but he was "not the best" in the competition
siddh_v thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: greatmaratha



In some ways we all do our bit towards it, dont we. U filed a petition, got it to the notice of the media. On my part, I do not support anyone whom the Channel blesses with controversial stories... I did not support Abhishek after his parental sob story was flashed on prime time television in II. And in SRGMP, I stopped supporting Poonam after the Judges started making her out to be some kind of bhikari, by begging votes in the name of her poor economical situation. but yeah, it is difficult to completely boycott the show.

Shold not someone do something which will make the channels stop exploiting these young contestants such. I only recall the incident of Priyanka from II 1, where her father decided to withdraw her from the contest in view of the harsh demands and conditiions contained in the agreement. Kudos to that man.




Totally agree its impossible to boycott the show totally. I just wished we had some kind of watch dog who could tell these channels stop this is not talent hunt this is exploitation of votes at the cost of poor contestants life and there self respect.

I so agree with u both Abhishek drama and Poonams drama was totally unnecessary but did u notice those two kids were so uncomfortable when that was ever shown. I mean there is like 99% of public who gets annoyed and grossed out by Himesh's love story drama then why do we still need it and an old guy like Bappida joining in the same is so out of place. I love Aneeks voice but i so want him to get out just because of this drama.

What is bad is none of this happens in American Idol so its not a concept issue its just a gymic by the channels in India for the wants of more and more votes.
siddh_v thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: abru07



That's where I disagree! You can't compare a great singer like karunya to a below average singer Sandeep. Have you watched II2, every single performance of him was either mediocre or "not-so-great" and I am using those words because I don't wanna sound trashy....
While Karunya on the other hand, is a great flawless singer; you cannot ever compare them....

As far as Prashant is concerned, I am sure he's gonna be another sandeep.. Because again he was good but he was "not the best" in the competition



👏
kothra thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#20

Well. its a money making show...

i hope they promote prashant

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".