Best Solution to get Deserving Winner

The only solution i could think of in order to get the most deserving person win idol is to limit the voting to one per id. (which prolly will never happen since sony is all about making money, i mean which channel isnt? )
Any other suggestions?

another solution - judges select talented contesants other than bathroom singers for top 10 like in srgmp and svoi

from srgmp mauli who entered bcose of performance
svoi - sumitra

but both were far better than ankita,prashant,

get really good judges who noe everything about music...and think about ONLY music...

sum1 like sonu/vishal/shekhar..

and den make them decide the bottom 3's of each week's gala...and den do sms voting for ONLY those bottom 3...

like how famegurukul was....i thut that was the bestttttt voting system..

unfortunately...the rong ppl always went into danger by the judges (biased judges 😡) and den the wrong ppl always got saved by the junta..

but if we have good judges, unbiased judges, and those who onli care about singing...who can select good singers ONLY to be in the finals.....then there shud be no problem of having rong contestants being saved...if all are good..😃

no x-factor stuff at all...no thinking about "u have spark"...cuz if u sing well...spark will come by itself...

this way...sony can make alot of money as well...and we can have a good deserving winner... 😃

Originally posted by: srk_lover

get really good judges who noe everything about music...and think about ONLY music...

sum1 like sonu/vishal/shekhar..

and den make them decide the bottom 3's of each week's gala...and den do sms voting for ONLY those bottom 3...

like how famegurukul was....i thut that was the bestttttt voting system..

unfortunately...the rong ppl always went into danger by the judges (biased judges 😡) and den the wrong ppl always got saved by the junta..

but if we have good judges, unbiased judges, and those who onli care about singing...who can select good singers ONLY to be in the finals.....then there shud be no problem of having rong contestants being saved...if all are good..😃

no x-factor stuff at all...no thinking about "u have spark"...cuz if u sing well...spark will come by itself...

this way...sony can make alot of money as well...and we can have a good deserving winner... 😃

But thats not gonna work yaar. People dont get enough of Kekta thats why they want all the masala in II too and if it dosent work then the TRP's will be low anyways they are low.😆😆😆

Originally posted by: siddh_v

But thats not gonna work yaar. People dont get enough of Kekta thats why they want all the masala in II too and if it dosent work then the TRP's will be low anyways they are low.😆😆😆

not really....i think indian idol has sumwhere made a place in everyone's hearts....even if ppl say itz standards have dropped low, itz the worst of all reality shows...etc etc...ppl styl noe of it...and wont mind watching it if itz worth watching....

but itz wen the standard of singers is bad....the trp's drop..

if they get all good singers....each giving excellent performances...the trp's will rise...and ppl will love watching it (i.e. srgmp this year....excellent singers giving great performances....and the show has made a special space where viewership is concerned)...yeah sure theres himesh there to create drama....but ppl dont watch it for his nonense do they?? thas wat HE thinks...tell me....wud any sane person turn on the tv and say...oh srgmp is on...i wanna watch himeshji talking on and on and on....no rite?? they watch it for the singers and their performances which are expected to always be good...

svoi also has excellent singers....but itz viewershop isnt so strong..and the show isnt soo popular...despite having good singers....and that show is fulllllllll of kekta's masala's....but styl...the format/judges isnt too impressive..

and ii3....the show is popular with or without masala....but becuz of itz weak singing and performances....as well as judges favoritism....itz doing bad...we need good judges with good singers...

and srgmp has everything....good viewership..good singers...good judges who think about singing first....den x-factor (love story/poverty isnt really x-factor..thas just their personal life being brought on stage)

so if ii can also get ONLY good singers...with better judges....it will get itz reputation back...as much as ppl say i will not watch ii4....they styl will to see if theres any improvement...like wat happened with ii3 lolll

reality shows are ahead of kekta serials....IF they are worth watching 😃

u'l neva get da deserving contestants out of those musical reality shows... .

first of all . i got a feelings dat no grl would eva win da crown of any musical reality show s long s public voting exists..

2nd thing is dat Sony woudn change da format 2 get a desrving contestant, coz they hv already earned their revenues frm those public voting.. imagine if there were 50-50 voting system through judges and public, prashant's fan's woudnt b voting so dedicatedly coz they know dat evn with their blind voting dey had chances 2 loose.... they voted for prashant coz they knew dat dis is da only way 2 make deir fav contestant win.....and prashant is like a jackpot for SONY so was QAZI, so they wudn change da format coz they kno dat they r goin 2 get a lots of votes from regional support...

n whoever wins the title and whoever doesnt, does it rilly matter.. we hv dose musical reailty shows goin on every yr.. do india need so many singers??? and how wud they make a mark in da industry where there are still so many good singers struggling??? i request every one jst 2 watch da shows and don bother voting coz u never see a desrving contestant win da shows, and da reality show makers are just making moeny out of fooling u....

get rid of alisha and javed, bring back sonu and let atleast 50% should be from the judge not only the janta

Lol..
There would never be indian Idol again..lol if we plan our selves😆 😆

no info about the participants

e.g. location, family history, age, etc.

Introduce the top twelve on the day of the final.

This way people will vote for the best.