Alisha is not fit for judge. - Page 4

Originally posted by: Applicant

Alisha is not a good singer.

Oh come on, don't you think the way she sang few lines of late Nazia Hassan's song was so in sur and key that it would have put Nazia to shame 😆 😆 .

Originally posted by: Applicant

Anu Malik he is composer so fit for judge,
Udit Narayan is a very good singer who knows how the song needs to be sung, so he is fit for judge.
Javed he is lyricist, so he knows the word, how it needs to pronounce though it is little bit different in singing style, he is fit for judge.
Alisha is not a good singer. She is only a pop singer whose songs are not that popular except one Mr. India, so how come Sony picked her to be a judge when there are many great female singers like Asha, Lata and many more. Is she just picked because of her dress-up and flirting character or what?

o really!
if she was that bad; why wait for the finale round to accuse her of all that. Now that she actually said Prashant sang badly?? or Amit is good??
I don't think you are allowed to attack the judges' personal character on IF. Moreover that makes you sound bad..

Well it was completely wrong in alisha's part to say "tumhari har gunaah maaf , you are number 1" to amit when in the same song prashant clearly outclassed him. May be she likes amit but that wasnt a right moment to say such things.

Originally posted by: anish_vince

she is racist and never liked prashatn..

the truth is PRASHANT WAS BETTER THAN AMIT TODAY.. .and thats the BOTTOM LINE!

there we go with racism again!!😆

Alisha Chinnai is a totally out of tune, off key singer

SHE WILL FIT AS A JUDGE IF SHE BLINDLY PRAISES PARSHANT....

Originally posted by: no_quiero

Well it was completely wrong in alisha's part to say "tumhari har gunaah maaf , you are number 1" to amit when in the same song prashant clearly outclassed him. May be she likes amit but that wasnt a right moment to say such things.

SHE SAID SO MANY TIMES THE SAME SENTECNE IN WHOLE INDIAN IDOL GAla's for different CONTESTANT....THEN IT WAS OKAY..SO WHAT HAPPEN NOW..WHY HER TRUTH IS
SO HARD ON YOU.... ANY AMIT WAS BETTER THAN PARSHANT..ISHI LYE USKHE SABH GUNAH MANF HAI..

Given the potential and talent if we compare both the contestants, AMIT is leagues ahead.

If Alisha reiterates it then she is Right.

Amit's flaws are not which breaks a Singer, coz in real life they have lyric written on paper.

But if One does not know sur, taal , have diction problems, then that is a Problem.

Music is not a Game that we have Round One and Round two. It is a creative field. NOt all AR Rahman mucis or even Lata/Kishore Songs are HITs.

They create magic in a handful of them and they are remembered by them.

In AMIT's case we have many songs where he created magic on stage..

That is the bottomline'.

AMIT is a musician who has great potential with Unique voice quality.

Even in grand finale she didn't back up her racist attitude. At least she should spare this episode.

She herself is not a good singer for sure.

i think the word racism is used a little too much in this forum;
even if it doesn't fit in the situation.
😆 😆 😆