Javed Ji and Alisha

I think these were the only 2 judges today who spoke the truth and I really admire them for that. I always thought Alisha based her opinion on good looking performers, but I don't think so anymore. I cannot believe Anu Malik said you need looks, performance and singing to win. I mean is this a beauty contest? So people who are not good looking should not get a chance to sing. I can't believe a music director like Anu Malik said singing should be 50%. If Sonu, Udit, Sunidhi, Kunal, Shaan sing 50%, would they be what they are today? And then the same judge is shocked with Emon in the bottom 3. Javed ji correctly gave it back to Anu Malik by saying that Anu likes Emon because of his singing. Everybody loves Sonu Nigam, Sunidhi, etc as a singer first and then a performer. Would the shows be house full if Sonu was not as good a singer? Would people like Sonu less if he was not as good looking? Definitely not. What good is performance, if the singer will not even get a chance to sing.

And then Udit who found it hard to choose between Emon and Ankita. I mean I'm sure being a playback singer, he knows who sung well. Couldn't he be honest?

From now I am just going to listen to Javed Ji and Alisha's comments. If Anu Malik is basing his opinion on who looks good, I might as well not listen to him anymore.

my thots exaclty....anu malik was disguting today!! 🤢
nd how did udit ji find it hard to choose between emon and ankita 😕 wats wrong wid dese judgessss??? 😡

I am with Javed jee! I salute him. 😊

From now I am just going to listen to Javed Ji and Alisha's comments. If Anu Malik is basing his opinion on who looks good, I might as well not listen to him anymore.


😆 😆 first frm know... i always only listen to javed jee 👏 👏 and never another.. coz no1 of them are honest at all 🤢

👏 👏 Agree with you! Very well said. 👏

guyz take ur memories back to wild card round. when these judges took ankita instead of other singers saying that she has blend of both and particularly it was javed saab who told that, so why do they keep on changing their views. i personally think that from the very first day they should have chose only singers not so called performers.

now if u compare the indian idol singers with other contest singers they stand nowhere except for one or two. i think they need to reflect and their review judgement.. or quit judging..

Aaj zara Anu ji ke hosh hi udd gaye the 😭

But Well caught by Javed Ji, loved his style of rebuttal when he caught anu saying Emon should be in the contest, over Ankita 😆 😆

10000% agree to what everyone said

Originally posted by: pl5891

guyz take ur memories back to wild card round. when these judges took ankita instead of other singers saying that she has blend of both and particularly it was javed saab who told that, so why do they keep on changing their views. i personally think that from the very first day they should have chose only singers not so called performers.

now if u compare the indian idol singers with other contest singers they stand nowhere except for one or two. i think they need to reflect and their review judgement.. or quit judging..

thats true & padhmanav shld hav entered throught wildcard

Yes I agree, Javed Akhtar and Alisha Chinai were totally right today!!! Anu Malik was really disapointing!!! He was talking about LOOKS!!! And Deepali is a very beautiful girl, I mean she's not as beautiful as an actress, but overall, being a simple girl not from the industry, she's a very pretty girl!!! She has a cute face, a cute smile!!!
ATLEAST MUCH MORE BEAUTIFUL THAN ANU MALIK!!!! Hahahahahahaha!!!