impact and zing............

Many seem to suggest that singing should be the sole criteria, I disagree Indian Idol is also about attitude and x-factor too .

To be honest, amongst the girls only Ankita and Charu have that impact when they come on screen. Impact plays a very important role in judgement along with good singing.

They should have the zing and that boom impact when they come on screen , I am not talking abt beauty, I am talking abt that stage presence that is very essential esp for these kind of shows where we vote for them seeing their performance and not merely listening to them with eyes closed.

the rest however good they may be in singing fail to create any impact for me atleast . I am talking abt te girls only

there are so many beautiful actresses and actors but the ones who succeed are the ones who have that star presence and the impact and stage power on screen.

thats why I said , the one who balances the both would win.

amongst the guys

Parleen seems to be a natural in performing

Amongst the guys, Chang, Abhishek,Amit seem to have that presence. Prashant has a very charming presence.

Yeah I agree with you..Indian Idol is about performing and singing.Only performance wont do any good if somneones singing is totally flat and off key.In that sense Ankita is not good atall.Charu I agree has that screen presence that can create some sparks.Except judged by todays episode I liked Puja,Emon and Amit

agree wit tina.. 👏 nd i always beleive indian idol is not jus abt singing 😊 ..

I also feel the same...it's the combination of Great singing & great screen/stage prescence that makes the Ideal Indian Idol...

Only singing..then we have VOI & SRGMP challenge!