my views abt this emon prashant issue... - Page 2

Some very good singers are voted out bu audiences for some issues..in every singing compitition..

& I think Emon did the same mistake..and day by day is losing his popularity..

Bcoz according to that days performance Prashant definately was not most bad one....

ya! letz forget the frst gala now....it was very tensionful period for all of us ....for many various reasons.....but i thnk the second gala will return back the magic n the happiness of II3...at least i hope so! 😳

Originally posted by: priyankumupal

I thought we were over discussing this and Prashant got way more votes than emon when it came to deciding if emon was jealous of prashant. true it may not have effected prashant in a negative way at the vote out, but he was sending a message to the world saying, look i'm a trained singer and prashant is just someone who has a good voice but doesn't have both training and the voice like I do, so I'm better, you guys vote for me, any one can get that. Prashant has much a chance of winning as Emon and I feel that emon knows this and identifies prashant as his biggest competition. So what ever way he can bring him down I guess he'll use it. I'm not saying emon doesn't have a right to express his opinion, he has a much right as the next person, but when you abuse your right and make it a weapon to hurt other people it's just not right. Prashant is a good guy who doesn't get badly affected by praise or criticism, so I think he will go far with his unique voice and he's pleasing personality.

i dont think that a contestent's views will in any way affect the ppl's views.....thats so obvious...n i think emon is stupid to think thats ppl will get convinced by what he says.....

i respect ur views...but i dont think he is jealous at all....

see there was no reason to say prashant should leave that day. Classically trained...well prashant already stated that he isnt classically trained singer but he still tries to sing. Which he did that day...he went in front and sang a difficult number and did well. PPl will take emons response as insecurity about Prashant. Because Abhishek isnt that famous like Emon. Chang is famous but cant make it top. Amit is catching the rhythm but isnt that far yet. Parleen also is famous but is a good singer but emon doesnt see him as threat. But prashants singing touches ppls heart. very good voice quality and huge support from all over the country. Even when hussain said ab main doh log ke nam batane ja rahahu, jiske liye janta dewani hogayi hai. Prashant....aur chang aap bhi.
He isnt jealous but is scared that he might cause him trouble. I used to think Emon is a down to earth guy. agar Emon ke jaga par prashant ne yeh saab kaha hota toh main Prashant ke khilaf main bolta. But here case is different..ok tell me if parleen amit abhishek prashant chang ne Emon ko vote out hona chahiye bola hota toh kya kehtey aap..reason---woh bahut over confident hai...so..mark this..emons popularity has degraded by little bit since the very first of the show. Richa key saath kya hua? first main woh bhi ishitarha thi but later on she faced troubles..yeah he is a damn good singer but there were lots of other singers who sang bad that day..like parleen,deepali,charu,richa,smita...could have taken theirs name because they werent outstanding..but Prashant/Amit/Abhishek/Chang were damn good that day. 👏

oh even i heard that Prashant is going to rock this weeks galas..cheers prashants fan.😳

Originally posted by: elegantjatti

yes emon may be trained singer but Parshant's voice quality is way better then Emon. Listen to Parshant in the previous videos and his voice is soooooooo soothing.....I see Parshant as an Indian Idol.... 👏
he came from a not so well background but that does not shows up in his performance....he is confident and he is improving a lot..Parshant proved that given the oppurtunity a normal average guy can rock too.....whereas Emon has benefit he is well trained but still the voice quality is not as good as Parshant's.....and the voice quality is something god gifted....emon can not make is any better by practising....but still Emon is way better then an average singer.....

I agree wid you....PRASHANT ROX!! Hope he wins II 3!!!!!!😛😛 But that doesnt mean Emon is a bad singer!! certainly not!😳He rocks too...but I like Prashant's and Amit's voice more!!😃😛 For me, Prashant comes first, then Amit and after him Emon!!😊

common people until and unless if someone is next of kin, only he will know about the extra quality upon someone who you know, rest everybody decides on seeing on the TV only and the performance at that very particular time. So based on this reality, since you people have started the dicussion, what you have given about the trained voice, actually for something to be well polished, firstly it should be natural and god gifted, who don't want to be a good singer by simply taking the training, but only few will have a success, the reason, firstly they are not gifted, secondly the training is not everything.
Now what you have positive points about EMON compare to PRASHANT, he has far more positive points, and the very very strong positive point about him is his unique god gifted voice. If someone listens to his voice without seeing the video one can easily say that the voice is of PRASHANT, and that of EMON, if someone listens one cannot say this is EMON, coz his voice is so common that everyone will be meshed up, who is this???????
See this is on great advantage of PRASHANT on EMON and Indian idol is in search of such a talent who has a unique voice not that who has similarity to others, where one disappears after a while.
And what is this about trained, common truly speaking it is this classical thing that EMON's voice has become so high pitched that only classical lovers would be able to listen, others the normal people like the aam janta loves melody not the irritating pitched voice, and in fact EMON's voice is really really pitched with less melody, compared with PRASHANT'S where every single word he sings carries melody, this is what the public wants guys, a soothing feeling to the ear and touchy to the heart.
if only i started to write what really has PRASHANT, the whole day typing won't be enough
so good is good guys, accept it, i am not saying EMON is bad, but who makes feel better is PRASHANT
Public don't want classical but wants melody and unicity
that's all

Originally posted by: roadies_4 fan

ya! letz forget the frst gala now....it was very tensionful period for all of us ....for many various reasons.....but i thnk the second gala will return back the magic n the happiness of II3...at least i hope so! 😳

yup!!! lets leave the first gala...and discuss about the 2nd!!😛😛

guys....jus leave prashant and emon alone! its like comparing 2 totally different voices....like comparing sonu nigam and sukhvinder sigh....or sumthing....even sukvinder's voice is high pitched...but the junta luvs his songs..he has given sum masterpieces like chaiyya chaiyya...beedi etc and his voice does not suit for soft/romantic numbers coz thts sonu's forte. n sonu cannot sing the blasted full energy numbers coz they do not suit him...jus because he cannot sing such songs...tht dosent make him a bad singer at all..both sukhvinder and sonu are terrific singers in their own way....similarly...if prashant's voice is melodious, emons voice is soaked in sur....he never looses his sur.
they have different voices...emons is more high pitched (ala KK, sukvinder singh) and prashants is more relaxed (ala udit narayan and sonu). u cannot compare them. both are gud in their own way...stop comparing both of them in trying to decide whoz better!

I 100% agree with u! 😛 I don't see what the big deal is...

what's the issue? I haven't heard anything about it... 😕

I'm a prashant fan and I've never 'bad-mouthed' emon ever.