dont u think amit was flat.... - Page 2

i dont thnk he went out of sur ....though he didnt touch my heart so nicely too....i mean you dunno i hear in dino 10 times a day (till d frst para,i love d frst para 😛 )....n d beauty of words the song has was not so like maintained by him....there are words on which soham stresses which he was not....but itz absolutely fine....coz i am goin in depth...sorry i am quite biased towards in dino 😛 ....but watever he sung was really good. 😊

so i guess its only me who thinks this..ok then fine 😕

btw even a single member didnt felt his voice was kinda bhari and flat 😕 when he said in dino

ab i dont kinda remember yaar....but i thnk he was in sur.

hey don't start topics like this, We Amit fans have heart attacks when we see stuff like this, that song has a beginning which is very low, so when you start on a very low note and then suddnley have to go for a high note it sounds like your going flat, he didn't go flat even at one point. he sang like an angle. i'm sure you felt that he sang flat at the beginning but he didn't, you can ask someone who has studied music and they will tell you that to change your voice from a low note to a high note very quickly is very hard, i was very shocked to see such a topic.

Originally posted by: priyankumupal

hey don't start topics like this, We Amit fans have heart attacks when we see stuff like this, that song has a beginning which is very low, so when you start on a very low note and then suddnley have to go for a high note it sounds like your going flat, he didn't go flat even at one point. he sang like an angle. i'm sure you felt that he sang flat at the beginning but he didn't, you can ask someone who has studied music and they will tell you that to change your voice from a low note to a high note very quickly is very hard, i was very shocked to see such a topic.

nah! in dino doesnt have a low note startin....it has a calm startin maybe....n i dunno if u call that a low note...but even if we do....then the song never has a high note...the song is neither low nor high note....high note-low note transition is like in laree chootee....goin from low to full on high....in dino is a co mapretively easy song....everyone sings it...n they dont go out of sur....most of them😉....jabki they r not singers.

Originally posted by: * Taurean_21 *

so i guess its only me who thinks this..ok then fine 😕

btw even a single member didnt felt his voice was kinda bhari and flat 😕 when he said in dino

Yes - you are the only one - I think you are trying a bit too hard to find some flaws in a flawless performance - and u can see the results - not a single member supported you

Originally posted by: roadies_4 fan

nah! in dino doesnt have a low note startin....it has a calm startin maybe....n i dunno if u call that a low note...but even if we do....then the song never has a high note...the song is neither low nor high note....high note-low note transition is like in laree chootee....goin from low to full on high....in dino is a co mapretively easy song....everyone sings it...n they dont go out of sur....most of them😉....jabki they r not singers.

It actually does have a high note, play it on a piano and see, when the song goes in dino dil mere mujesai hai kehera ha(this part of the song is very low), (and here comes the high note)Tuuuuuuuuu kwaba saja, it's very hard to sing that part without sounding a little flat, i admit the rest of the song goes at a netural pace but this part is though not hard can sound a little flat to your ears. i'm not saying it has high low notes all over, just at that point it does have one, and that part though not hard to sing can sound as if it flat. in a studio they would correct that sound deffect easily but here the poor fellow has to do his best without any sound help. so let's cut him some slack.

I listened to his singing for about 50 times not and it's my opinion(just mine) that it's not a flat note.sorry if you guys don't agree with me😕

Originally posted by: * Taurean_21 *

so i guess its only me who thinks this..ok then fine 😕

btw even a single member didnt felt his voice was kinda bhari and flat 😕 when he said in dino

I completely agree with you. As a singer myself , i noticed the same and I had written the same in my analysis post. He started off badly off-key infact but then picked up really well.

dont feel isolated, u are right on, he def went off-sur at the start .

ok taurean you got one wid you...... 😉

Originally posted by: priyankumupal

It actually does have a high note, play it on a piano and see, when the song goes in dino dil mere mujesai hai kehera ha(this part of the song is very low), (and here comes the high note)Tuuuuuuuuu kwaba saja, it's very hard to sing that part without sounding a little flat, i admit the rest of the song goes at a netural pace but this part is though not hard can sound a little flat to your ears. i'm not saying it has high low notes all over, just at that point it does have one, and that part though not hard to sing can sound as if it flat. in a studio they would correct that sound deffect easily but here the poor fellow has to do his best without any sound help. so let's cut him some slack.

I listened to his singing for about 50 times not and it's my opinion(just mine) that it's not a flat note.sorry if you guys don't agree with me😕

i knew u wud be referring to these lines as high n low notes....though i am not a singer or watevr.....but the word tuuuuuuuuuuuuuu is not exactly a high note....maybe u go a lil' high there but itz more of stressing n stretchin ur voice....like u can have a breathin problem there.....maybe.

thats what i am sayin....gaane me aise bahut jagah the jaha word ko kheecha hai....like tuuuuuu khwab saja....n in para1...kuch rang to bharuuuuuu.....more streess on uuuuu....n he didnt give that stress....i was singin along wid him....but then i saw he left that part of stretching the notes......so he didnt actually sing in dino in d right way......accordin to me....the part which contained all d beauty of d song was left.