Why to compare II-1, II-2 and II-3 ???

I don't understand ... why the judges especially Anu and Javed ji had to compare the singers of II-1 and II-2 with II-3 ???? As viewers, we can ... but they are judges ... It's indirectly saying that II-1 and II-2 contestants were useless ... Honestly, I don't think we have even a single singer of the calibre of Amey and Karunya in this lot !!!!

i agree about the judges part...

i feel in the previous idol's there were just a few contestants who were exceptionally well singers...moreso excellent singers...the rest werent all that great..

this season...we have most of the singers being reallyy good singers...i actually wait for all the contestants' performances this year (with the except of maybe 2)....but last season...i onli waited for like 2-3 😆

the amount of good singers is more this season..but styl..all these good singers combined 2gether styl cannot match upto amey or karunya's level...that too amey adn karunya individually 👏

Originally posted by: srk_lover

i agree about the judges part...

i feel in the previous idol's there were just a few contestants who were exceptionally well singers...moreso excellent singers...the rest werent all that great..

this season...we have most of the singers being reallyy good singers...i actually wait for all the contestants' performances this year (with the except of maybe 2)....but last season...i onli waited for like 2-3 😆

the amount of good singers is more this season..but styl..all these good singers combined 2gether styl cannot match upto amey or karunya's level...that too amey adn karunya individually 👏

I agree with u on this ... but my point is, they are judges ... they could have just said that this time also the competition is very severe and stiff and u need to work hard ... why do they have to say that II 1st 2 seasons didn't have good singers ... becoz. eventually whatever they said implied that ... Also, they have generalized all the singers in II-1 and II-2 as not as worthy as II-3 without any exceptions .... that's the part I didn't like, especially coming from the Judges of this show ...

Originally posted by: finfreedom

I don't understand ... why the judges especially Anu and Javed ji had to compare the singers of II-1 and II-2 with II-3 ???? As viewers, we can ... but they are judges ... It's indirectly saying that II-1 and II-2 contestants were useless ... Honestly, I don't think we have even a single singer of the calibre of Amey and Karunya in this lot !!!!

i totly agree with you...yar....i know ii3 have good singers bt tht doesnt mean tht ii2 and ii1 have bad singres..i mean they were ossom...they r saying tht farah and sonu was always wrong choosing ppl from comparison...bt thts not right yar....

Originally posted by: finfreedom

I don't understand ... why the judges especially Anu and Javed ji had to compare the singers of II-1 and II-2 with II-3 ???? As viewers, we can ... but they are judges ... It's indirectly saying that II-1 and II-2 contestants were useless ... Honestly, I don't think we have even a single singer of the calibre of Amey and Karunya in this lot !!!!

As a group, II3 singers are a good. But II1 and II2 had some excellent singers.
I can sort of understand AM making the comment cos he's been a judge all three seasons. But the other three? Not really. I wonder if they followed both seasons from start to finish?
More than comparing to the II1, II2 singers, I think they're trying to hype the show and talent. With three music shows on the air right now, there's some tough competition for trps. Maybe they were trying to put Jolly Das down. I don't know, she was just one of the worst singers from last year's top 12.

I think Anu can compare, cause he's been there for all three seasons and he has the right to talk abt the old contestants as well...

I think that this time, especially the boys, ALL of them who are in the finals are very, very good singers. In the past, there were some individual exceptional singers, not necessarily as a group.. even the girls as well, are pretty good as a group.. although, I feel in the girls there are better individual singers rather than all of them together...

Although, I definitely have not seen a Karunya or Amey yet.. 😔 but we can't expect that always can we? So let's see, am sure we will get some really good performances later on!!

Originally posted by: srk_lover

i agree about the judges part...

i feel in the previous idol's there were just a few contestants who were exceptionally well singers...moreso excellent singers...the rest werent all that great..

this season...we have most of the singers being reallyy good singers...i actually wait for all the contestants' performances this year (with the except of maybe 2)....but last season...i onli waited for like 2-3 😆

the amount of good singers is more this season..but styl..all these good singers combined 2gether styl cannot match upto amey or karunya's level...that too amey adn karunya individually 👏

I agree with u there..this yr we have more on quantity but no so much in quality...so saying tht this yr is tougher is unfair....