talent plus appearance

guys dont u think tht harshida performed n sang better than smitha

in the round previous to which harshida was voted out

harshida song aayo re maro dholna was much much better sung than smitha's song....

i think tht sometimes good looks can also be negative 4 tht person.people think that ...bas looks hain n dnt take them tht seriosly.

i dnt know wht ull feel but when we want an indian idol ....

(true that talent comes 1st) but dnt looks matter at all.

if not then y is all tht make over given to these singers in later rounds.

smitha's singing is not outstanding, she is collecting sympathy votes nw i think

after tht "i dnt look good" statement of hers.

harshida always used to sing same kind of songs
whereas smita sings different kinds of songs which tells how better she can sing so i think smita is better 😳

still yaar this isnt basis to judge
isnt ankita also singing same kinda songs...

n anothre this is appearance is also important.
comeon indian idol means complete package

Originally posted by: hanna_montana

still yaar this isnt basis to judge
isnt ankita also singing same kinda songs...

n anothre this is appearance is also important.
comeon indian idol means complete package

yeh i agree ankita is also singing same kind of songs n if she goes out that wud be quite deserving then

contestants have to improve their singing first appearance comes on the second number😳 we dont want a model or film actor/actress we want a gud singer😳 so singing is the main thing 😳