The nicest Judge of all 3 shows

As far as judging goes, amongst all 3 shows, Udit seems the best balanced. He isnt overtly rude like Abhijeet😡, nor disbalanced like Aadesh🤡. Neither is he inconsistent like Alisha, nor is he too vocal and confrontative like Anu. Regards HR ... less said the better. And V😎S🤔 have a long way to go.
Lekin (as his own style), he can be a bit more assertive. It is hard sitting beside such personas like Javed Akhtar🤓, but after all he has been at the top for 2 decades now. His humility, and encouraging smile have won him a lot of admirers.😃😃

sonu was the best but right now i think javed saab is the best...he gives the best comments without being rude....i still wish he werent this nice..

Originally posted by: *payal*

right now i think javed saab is the best...

javed saab definitely is extremely perceptive about lyrics, accents and emoting. he also has a terrific sense of humour. However i feel udit wud be a better judge when it comes to sur and taal, the backbones of any song.

sonu nigam was the best...

i only watch indian idol so i wouldnt be able to tell you in all three shows 😃 but im currently dissapointed with all three judges in indian idol...

I think all the judges in all the three shows this time arent that good. AVOI judges are extremely rude with too much personal ego and clashes. But regarding singing, I think they are right in most of their comments, but very discouraging to contestants

Indian idol judges are too lenient and compliment everyone and that really dilutes their judgement. Alisha is the worst of the lot.

SRGMP is a little better because of Ismail and Bappida. again VS are very inconsistent and get too excited. ofcourse HR the less said the better.

Asha Bhonsle was an excellent judge. She really gave excellent comments and tips onimproving singing. Thats what judges should do. Sonu Nigam was awesome also.

javed saab is the best cuz he actually points out the mistakes unlike alisha whos always like acha tha 😕
udit jii is an okay judge!

Originally posted by: Chief Saab

javed saab is the best cuz he actually points out the mistakes unlike alisha whos always like acha tha 😕
udit jii is an okay judge!

agree! also udit narayan is the worst. he starts with a 'mujhe yeh kehna hain ki' and u think he will give some useful tips and he ends with a 'bahut achche'. how stupid can that get?

Sonu was the best, he use to talk very polietly with the contestants, and he was never rude with anyone at the auditions either! he always kept his calm! and he looked very cute and adoroable! Udit is also very polite and nice, but he isn't as cute, charmning as Sonu, and I don't look forward to him that much! Javed is good with his sarcastic comments! but I find Anu Malik much more rude this time around! and Alisha is ok, umm i think she is rude too, compare to Farah, Farah only gave comments about to look good and X factor. I miss the previous trio, but these 4 are also good! and nice! much better then Adesh who idiotically come up to the stage and insult the contestants [:x] if they have so much problem why don't they audtion the talent themselves?

Originally posted by: .:Aphrodite:.

Shekhar's the best judge then Javed Akhtar then Vishal then Ismael Durbar

I don't like rest of them

sadly i disagree.....even tho i love shekhar.....but.....he hardly gets to talk

so how can he be the best judge? yes encouraging wise...and being sweet and all....he is the best....but judging....i mean actually giving judgements....he doesnt do that often....

ill say ismial, bappi da and javed saab are the best rite now.....even anu malik has a good sense of judgement...in his own style...this is from the current lot...

uditji hardly passes a good judgement 😕

but evergreen is evergreen....sonu will always remain the best judge!

I love shakky but he hardly gives views 😕 its vishal who is doin all talking..

but no one can ever beat HR..he is jus like a talkin machine 😕