The nicest Judge of all 3 shows - Page 2

Originally posted by: sweetmusic

I think all the judges in all the three shows this time arent that good. AVOI judges are extremely rude with too much personal ego and clashes. But regarding singing, I think they are right in most of their comments, but very discouraging to contestants

Indian idol judges are too lenient and compliment everyone and that really dilutes their judgement. Alisha is the worst of the lot.

SRGMP is a little better because of Ismail and Bappida. again VS are very inconsistent and get too excited. ofcourse HR the less said the better.

Asha Bhonsle was an excellent judge. She really gave excellent comments and tips onimproving singing. Thats what judges should do. Sonu Nigam was awesome also.

exactly my thoughts

I feel its JA.......He is not as rude as Anu and Anisha and not like Udit who agrees everything Anu says.......He is individual..He presents his own opinion everytime and is nice to the contestants 😃

ii judges r the best... javed is simply the best 😊 udit is next and then alisha 😊 other 2 shows judges - most of them r a liablility to the show than anything else 😛

i know abhijeet and aadesh are rude to the contestants

last time in srgmp05 ismail darbar was rude to his shishya's, but it made the contestant strong and prove themeselves.

being buttery,sugary and complimentary not make a good judge some times you have to be rude if the contestant is not singign good by getting this much of chance and in a platform like this.

i loved sonu's judgement in II,II2
i loved id's judgement in srgmp
fame gurukul all were good. shankar mahadevan, kk, and javed saab. they were criticising ,encouraging the contestants werever needed(they have not promoted qazi as a good singer, public onkly brought back him every time when he's in dangerzone.)

but this season all are interested in drama

i think there is a strict instruction to udit dont say any thing to bad singers, if you feels they are not good use some lekin here and there and say they are good singers.
even javed saab is also not doing his usual good job in II2