Janta is wrong.......Smita rocks - Page 5

Originally posted by: Sound

Best is very relative....what is best suited to you is not to me....Who you like best might not be my favourite contestant

I think this platform is more than just a platform for strugglers. These 16-17 year olds are definitelt not struggling as of yet....IMO it's good for them that they are getting exposure at such a young age through this platform. They might go into playback singing eventually and I will say if that is the only criteria for judging, then Idol people should move this from television to the radio right from the start. No matter how idealistic I may want to sound, I am affected by their performance. I am not closing my eyes while watching the show. Good singers definitely deserve a chance but just singing is not the lone criterion here if you are getting chosen coz of your performance on stage. It is not a fashion show, agreed but it's not a pure talent show either. Coz had it been that, the public should not have been included coz not everyone in the public is an accomplishe musician to judge the good from the bad!

Just my 2 cents😊

👏wow Neetu!! you are the best... standing ovation for you... each word is true to the core.... I loved the red part mostt... it touched me😳😳

Originally posted by: S a r a h

👏wow Neetu!! you are the best... standing ovation for you... each word is true to the core.... I loved the red part mostt... it touched me😳😳

Aww thanks Sarah😳! Yours and Frenchy's post inspired me to go for my 2 cents
However, best to you might not be best for someone else😉😆

Originally posted by: at_ad

Smita this bogus II platform is not fr u gal...janta wants a Choclate hero like Sandeep or a joker like a Qazi..they expect only these from the platform..

please do not put dont or criticize contestants on the basis of nothing! they also have fans and u have to respect their sentiments.