Vartika, Charu, Shifa

Hi Guys,

I feel that these girls are so much talent.

Keep in mind that these are middle class girls; If these are given chance, they can do much more better. I think they are so talented. Even though I was not a fan of these girls, but today they really touched my heart. I think they are the winners of today's round.

Plz leave ur views

what does being a middle class girl have anything with their performances 😳

yes these 3 were awesome...but i think puja stole the show 2nite..

You are not analysing the term "middle class".
i am from middle class family and I know that Parents can't do much for extra talent except educating them. They can put their children in good schools but can't send them to good dance or music school or musical shows in order to get confidence to go on a stage.
I am saying that beside all those things they performed really really well.

Originally posted by: gill1

You are not analysing the term "middle class".
i am from middle class family and I know that Parents can't do much for extra talent except educating them. They can put their children in good schools but can't send them to good dance or music school or musical shows in order to get confidence to go on a stage.
I am saying that beside all those things they performed really really well.

Well, Shifa has been learning classical music since she was very young and based on some post, she has performed on stage when she was 2 1//2 yrs old 😳 ... Also, I believe most of them do have some kind of musical/singing background ... it's not that they learnt music on their own and nobody was aware that they r good and suddenly they appear in Indian Idol ... I m sure they must have performed, if not on big stages or platforms, atleast in their school or some smaller platform, where other people have seen their talent ...

yah i agree dese three were really gud 😃

i too agree with you guys .

Some of them do have long training in music. Of course sometimes when you come from a small town, or a middle class family, you might be learning since childhood but not from a good teacher. But most of these girls have some training or the other. Shifa is learning from Ravindra Jain, Richa learnt since she was seven, Priyanka sounds like she has classical training etc. The only one I know of so far who is completely untrained is Prashant from the guys. Rehan doesn't sound like he has much training either. But I think all the girls are trained. In many middle-class families, it is usual for the girls to get some musical training while the boys may go for sports or something. But I agree with you, they were pretty good, and should get even better with a little experience. 👏

yep the galz performed really well betta than the II2 piano round girls