1st piano round...not impressive.... - Page 3

Originally posted by: xmuqix

i loved it
da best yet
every1 was good overall 👏 👏 😃

i agree with you muqi.. overall performance was very good.

Originally posted by: tpam

i say the best piano in all 3 yrs if seen over all.. see if yu consider single performances like karu's layi bhi na gayi yaa phir amey's tu hire then it is different bt every1 was gr888

i agree with u here... we shouldnt be comparing with these 2 performances..

KARU & AMEY were superb in the piano round..

The best part is

There was no PIANO in the piano round😛😆...

Its not a piano round anymore 😭

I also agree to the fact that the band was the culprit. Piano round should be pure "Piano" so that the singer can't hide any mistakes!
The ealrier (II1 & II2) piano rounds used to bring out the deficiencies & strength in the voice throw & overall singing of the contestant. This is not the case here.

Any way the contestants will be singing in the galas with full music (although not "Live" band) so why this band now?

And above all I was missing Anu Mallik's "caustic" comments & Sonu's words of advice!

Originally posted by: angierockzzz

Maybe i'm the onli one who feels this way...but the 1st piano round of the girls was absolutely unimpressive to me.....none of the singers blew me away....one or two were good..but noone gr8...and it cld be tat there's too much music in the background goin on...it's kinda overshadowing the singers......but for someone like me who was lookin forward to the piano round...maybe my expectations were too high...but i'm absolutely unimpressed..hopefully tommorow's guys' round will be betta......😕🤢

You are not the only one I too felt more or same like you :)

Originally posted by: varmap

I also agree to the fact that the band was the culprit. Piano round should be pure "Piano" so that the singer can't hide any mistakes!
The ealrier (II1 & II2) piano rounds used to bring out the deficiencies & strength in the voice throw & overall singing of the contestant. This is not the case here.

Any way the contestants will be singing in the galas with full music (although not "Live" band) so why this band now?

And above all I was missing Anu Mallik's "caustic" comments & Sonu's words of advice!

As much as I would not like to admit it, I was missing Anu Malik and his comments too.

Aww Sonu....😭😭😭

ok if you're going talking about the contestants here then i beg to differ.
those were one of the best group to pick from. i mean it really is soo confusing to zero in on 1 person. and thats gotta be a good thing! 😃

the set.. was great 😊 although it was a lot more colorful last time..

the judges comments.. to be honest even javed sahab dissapointed me..
but you know.. maybe they're told to go easy on the comments for now 😕 ...just hoping theyll be stronger in the future because even i was able to pinpoint some mistakes they would just say ohhhh bahut acha tha, bahut acha tha for

and the band... its supposed to be the PIANO rounds!!! 😡 they totally ruined my mood when A) everytime it would be time to go to break and then time to come back from break B)not knowing how to play when Alisha was singing and then keep playing after that!

but over all... i really liked today's episode 😳

Originally posted by: varmap

I also agree to the fact that the band was the culprit. Piano round should be pure "Piano" so that the singer can't hide any mistakes!
The ealrier (II1 & II2) piano rounds used to bring out the deficiencies & strength in the voice throw & overall singing of the contestant. This is not the case here.

Any way the contestants will be singing in the galas with full music (although not "Live" band) so why this band now?

And above all I was missing Anu Mallik's "caustic" comments & Sonu's words of advice!

yeahhhh...the band was way to loud and also not melodious and also i hate to say it...but i missed anu malik and his 'teekhi' comments as well...i neva thought that encouraging judges and ones who praise so much can be soooo boring..i hope anu comes back soon...and not to mention sonu..ofcourse the show isn't the same without him....udit is a dudddd...🤢

Hun, have you seen - Charu, Priyanka & Shifa's performance?..or are you watching the wrong show? 😆

Originally posted by: xo-Krupa-ox

Hun, have you seen - Charu, Priyanka & Shifa's performance?..or are you watching the wrong show? 😆

I guess you are watching Indian Idol 5 😆😆😆jk so take it easy 😛

Originally posted by: starsgo

ok if you're going talking about the contestants here then i beg to differ.
those were one of the best group to pick from. i mean it really is soo confusing to zero in on 1 person. and thats gotta be a good thing! 😃

the set.. was great 😊 although it was a lot more colorful last time..

the judges comments.. to be honest even javed sahab dissapointed me..
but you know.. maybe they're told to go easy on the comments for now 😕 ...just hoping theyll be stronger in the future because even i was able to pinpoint some mistakes they would just say ohhhh bahut acha tha, bahut acha tha for

and the band... its supposed to be the PIANO rounds!!! 😡 they totally ruined my mood when A) everytime it would be time to go to break and then time to come back from break B)not knowing how to play when Alisha was singing and then keep playing after that!

but over all... i really liked today's episode 😳

Well, the reason it's difficult to zero in on 1 or 2 performances is because some of them were above-average and some were average; and not because all of them were exceptional performances ... I would anyday prefer to watch couple of exceptional performances rather than watch all average or above-average performances ... one performance like that of Amey or Karunya just makes my day ..... ofcourse just my thought 😳 ....