1st piano round...not impressive.... - Page 2

Originally posted by: angierockzzz

No...I'm not saying that singers were bad...i mean some were good...some were less good....but overall they were all ok...but none of the songs...the background music..and the overall presentation of the show...was well...poor...maza nahi aaya...😕

Humm... i got it... somebody said the background music was not that good.. so obviously it won't sound good even if they sing good...

Originally posted by: purva

Some are saying most of the girls were good... some are saying most of them were not so impressive 😕

But i will also wait till i watch it myself... 😛

Better not to get affected by IF opinion so lets watch first then we will decide ...you never know and we all know IF is full of opinions and thats cool though😛

Originally posted by: tpam

i say the best piano in all 3 yrs if seen over all.. see if yu consider single performances like karus layi bhi na gayi yaa phir ameys tu hire then it is different bt every1 was gr888

yeaa ur ryt...every1 did an awesome job...overall ii3 has much better singers compared 2 da others...thnk god 4 that😃

I agree---it wasnt a very impressive piano round. Most of the girls were 'adequate' singers but no one was 'superb' or out of this world. None of the girls had a strong enough impact lik wht Amey had on me durin the piano round. I'll nvr forget the way he completely immersed himself in2 'Tu hi re'.

The problem I found was tht no one had an echo in their voice. (apart frm the girl who sang 'tujjhse naraz' maybe) There was no goonj or power in their voice---this could be coz of the jarring background score or maybe even the mike settings. None of them had a great throw in their voice. Most of them sing in tune so thts the bright side.

Some of them sing well but dont have gr8 voice quality, lik Shifa---she has a very well tuned voice (infact the best voice tuning of the lot) n sings with ease but I find her kinda nasal and her voice acutely sharp.

As for emoting---most of the singers were singin just for the heck of it n not adding the right feel to the words, esp Richa---i completely agree wit wht Javed Saab said abt her song: she was singing a love song as if she were mournign at a funeral. Sayin tht, since its their first time in frn of the camera--- they might be nervous so emoting aint tht easy. Charu got the naughty/teasing feel of the song she was singin but it just didnt make a strong enuf impact---maybe she could've added a more husky n sensuous tone to the song.

Ankita was good at the song she sang n she has gr8 spunk but I dont see pulling off something classical or melodious. I kinda doubt her versitality.

i dont really agree coz i really loved today's episode

almost all the girls gave their best😳

Originally posted by: breathing_irony

I agree---it wasnt a very impressive piano round. Most of the girls were 'adequate' singers but no one was 'superb' or out of this world. None of the girls had a strong enough impact lik wht Amey had on me durin the piano round. I'll nvr forget the way he completely immersed himself in2 'Tu hi re'.

The problem I found was tht no one had an echo in their voice. (apart frm the girl who sang 'tujjhse naraz' maybe) There was no goonj or power in their voice---this could be coz of the jarring background score or maybe even the mike settings. None of them had a great throw in their voice. Most of them sing in tune so thts the bright side.

Some of them sing well but dont have gr8 voice quality, lik Shifa---she has a very well tuned voice (infact the best voice tuning of the lot) n sings with ease but I find her kinda nasal and her voice acutely sharp.

As for emoting---most of the singers were singin just for the heck of it n not adding the right feel to the words, esp Richa---i completely agree wit wht Javed Saab said abt her song: she was singing a love song as if she were mournign at a funeral. Sayin tht, since its their first time in frn of the camera--- they might be nervous so emoting aint tht easy. Charu got the naughty/teasing feel of the song she was singin but it just didnt make a strong enuf impact---maybe she could've added a more husky n sensuous tone to the song.

Ankita was good at the song she sang n she has gr8 spunk but I dont see pulling off something classical or melodious. I kinda doubt her versitality.

I agree wit u...especially about the points about shifa, ankita, and overall the thing i missed most was the fact the singers weren't feeling the song..they were just singing it.....this is what i felt too

ONe more thing I felt was tht most of the girls ESP: Deepali and Aisha dont use their diaphragm enuf n therefore the power n throw of their voices is poor. They r projecting their voice from their throats but if they used their diaphragm to add tht extra kick, the feel would automatically come in2 the song coz their vocies would be a lot fuller then.

While I am impressed with some of the talent, I've got to say, I wasnt all that impressed with the performances...for instance, I remember during Season One, when Aditi Paul performed "Lambi Judai", you KNEW you were watching phenomenal talent. Even thinking about that performance gives me chills.

I was very puzzled with some of the song choices, because they were terrible. I'm not going to name those songs, because they might be someone's faves, but still. I was SHOCKED to see some girls such as Rashmi, Hashida & Richa, who performed so brilliantly on their first auditions, but were just about average here.

I'm really, really hoping some of the more talented girls get another shot and bring on their A games next time.

it was so gudddddd esp i lked vartika's, charu's, shifa's , aisha n smitha's..
vartika lukedddd so pretty today 😳 😳

Originally posted by: breathing_irony

ONe more thing I felt was tht most of the girls ESP: Deepali and Aisha dont use their diaphragm enuf n therefore the power n throw of their voices is poor. They r projecting their voice from their throats but if they used their diaphragm to add tht extra kick, the feel would automatically come in2 the song coz their vocies would be a lot fuller then.

Great advice! Looks like the music director forgot to mention that.