Anu Mallick - Deciding Vote?

In II3, when there is a tie between four judges regarding a contestant, Anu Mallick gets the deciding vote. Is it fair?

Today there was a girl, (sorry dont remember the name) she was in white salwaar and anu didnt like her and javed saab did and they both had an agrument regarding it... then alisha say that she liked it but then uditji no like what to do and anu kinda force him to not go for her and jaaved saab in fact said that anu is influencing the judges and then uditji decided against her and she went cos in tie anuji gets the final vote and obviously he was adamant that she went... I thought she was good... good then that boy where also there was a tie but cos anuji wanted he was in.

So it is fair that anuji gets the final vote in case of a tie... how fair it is just cos he was in the previous edition of the idol.

I feel there can be chits of yes and no and pick one or a wheel cos no one person should have the final voting power. Unfair on other judges.

What you guys say?

yeh i too liked that girl's voice
but yeh im confused wat if two judges agree n other two dont then wat wud be the final decision 😕
its unfair if anu malik gets the final vote 😕

dat gurl was infact very good..
i also didnt like there decision..

First of all they should have gone for 3 judges panel... what was the need for 4th judge... In my opinion.. Alisha, Anu and Javedji were enough...

And now that there are 4 judges... i think Javedji should be the deciding judge... b'coz he is most senior of them all...

yah sweta,i agree with u this is unfair 😕 ..............why special veto power(deciding vote) to annu(the dumb shayar)????...........the other 3 judges wud feel insulted bcoz of this 😔 ......i havent seen the episode so cant comment on the specific contestants voice,have to wait for another 7-8 hrs.................cant watch here too as my PC's speakers r not working 😔 😭 😭

Originally posted by: purva

First of all they should have gone for 3 judges panel... what was the need for 4th judge... In my opinion.. Alisha, Anu and Javedji were enough...

And now that there are 4 judges... i think Javedji should be the deciding judge... b'coz he is most senior of them all...

yaah purva,i agree.............no need for 4th judge.........(baap-beta on diff.reality shows,Udit on II n Aditya on SRGMP.........aditya ke papa ko rest dete na,wo apne bete ka housla badhata SRGMP pe.....)

they have been anu malik this power because he was the judge in the previous 2 seasons also!

btw sersly its not fair...why a special power to him? 😕

Originally posted by: mcm226

yaah purva,i agree.............no need for 4th judge.........(baap-beta on diff.reality shows,Udit on II n Aditya on SRGMP.........aditya ke papa ko rest dete na,wo apne bete ka housla badhata SRGMP pe.....)

Aur nahi to kya.... aur Aditya ko zaroorat bhi hai... i read that he was quite nervous giving his first shot... he is too young na... he needs Papa's support... 😉 😃

hehe.. uptil now almost everybody in this thread dont want anuji to have the final say.... what audience understands, why doesnt II3 Producers....

jago jago bhai... change the rule.. well... I think now it is too late or is it the same for the remaning rounds? hmm... and if they change the rule regarding anuji's veto power now he may walk out.. what fun.... 😆 😛

Originally posted by: purva

First of all they should have gone for 3 judges panel... what was the need for 4th judge... In my opinion.. Alisha, Anu and Javedji were enough...

And now that there are 4 judges... i think Javedji should be the deciding judge... b'coz he is most senior of them all...

There was no need for a 4th judge. They created a loop hole to give an edge to Anu Malik's wacky decisions. In my opinion all judges should be equal and no one should be given right to final vote casting whether based on seniority of age or experience on the show.