Poorvi's Aao Na Song - Page 2

Originally posted by: niladri05011993

poorvi is the best singer of this season's indian idol and it was proved yesterday and if u people think she coudn't sing yesterday's song then i think u have to learn classical music all over again. and i was utterly surprised by what asha tai said. i have lost all respects for her after yesterday's episode. it was a pure classical singing from where are u guys getting western flavour. i think u didn't hear what salim said that poorvi u shd stick to ur comfort zone of western style singing. that means poorvi was singing eastern style because salim is a music director and he knows that tone of voice more than asha tai as she is a singer.

Originally posted by: ami_31

Come on!! Who gave you the right to ask people to learn music. If you want to support Poorvi, well do it. But you're not supposed to start making personal attacks on people, since noone knows here who knows the music and who doesn't.

If people have different opinions than you or if they don't like your favorite singer, accept it.

Anyways, in my opinion, Vipul is a way better singer than Poorvi, and he has given 2 really awesome performances.👏

Thank you so much I appreciate that. Very sweet of you to stand up for someone you don't even know. Anyhow I agree vipul is better than poorvi IN MY OPINION. However poorvi's good too in those performances where she sings something equivalent to a rock song. But Indian idol is about finding a versatile singer and so therefore I feel like poorvi is not versatile enough to be in the top.

Originally posted by: ami_31

Come on!! Who gave you the right to ask people to learn music. If you want to support Poorvi, well do it. But you're not supposed to start making personal attacks on people, since noone knows here who knows the music and who doesn't.

If people have different opinions than you or if they don't like your favorite singer, accept it.

Anyways, in my opinion, Vipul is a way better singer than Poorvi, and he has given 2 really awesome performances.👏

You being a senior member of the forum I appreciate your task of warning me. But you are having double standards with people in against poorvi. She is being bashed left, right and center in this forum and none of the senior members are taking any action and when someone is standing up for her you are warning him. This is not expected of a senior member of a forum if otherwise this forum is made only for bashing poorvi and serving the interests of a few contestants.

Originally posted by: niladri05011993

You being a senior member of the forum I appreciate your task of warning me. But you are having double standards with people in against poorvi. She is being bashed left, right and center in this forum and none of the senior members are taking any action and when someone is standing up for her you are warning him. This is not expected of a senior member of a forum if otherwise this forum is made only for bashing poorvi and serving the interests of a few contestants.

Originally posted by: niladri05011993

You being a senior member of the forum I appreciate your task of warning me. But you are having double standards with people in against poorvi. She is being bashed left, right and center in this forum and none of the senior members are taking any action and when someone is standing up for her you are warning him. This is not expected of a senior member of a forum if otherwise this forum is made only for bashing poorvi and serving the interests of a few contestants.

Honey this has nothing to with being a senior member or a newbie. And I don't feel like poorvi is being bashed, she is just not appreciated for her SINGING ONLY. Bashing someone means you are saying wrongful things about a person/character. Most people here just don't like her singing not poorvi the person.

Poorvi is at least master of one trade, others are jack of all trades. I will go with Poorvi than going with other. Specially in this Indian Idol, all are strcitly very average singers, do not have any one strong genre, at least Poorvi has one strong genre. I am yet to watch this week episode. She sings outstand in her genre, she does full justice with her song. I saw she took harkatien too in that genre.

Didnt like Poorvi's Aao Na performance...But it was definitely a brave attempt provided the competition is getting tougher and tougher from here...Felt her flat at many places...

Originally posted by: HakkaBakka

Poorvi is at least master of one trade, others are jack of all trades. I will go with Poorvi than going with other. Specially in this Indian Idol, all are strcitly very average singers, do not have any one strong genre, at least Poorvi has one strong genre. I am yet to watch this week episode. She sings outstand in her genre, she does full justice with her song. I saw she took harkatien too in that genre.

Her attempt was not successful. She needs to do lot ot riyaz. This competition is not for her. It is good to be perfect in one genre but in her own genre, she is flat most of the time. Moreover, in competition, if an excellent singer does mistake, as per rules, that singer must be out.
IKaushik is a great singer but he also was lacking expression. Still he was better than poorvi and amit.