An unbiased discussion - For music fans.. - Page 2

Few more important observation I made as

There r 2 types of voters 1-FIXED NUMBER
fans/relatives /friends of each candidate.

FLOATING VOTERS- this group who r the actual trump card holders ,vote only on unbiased basis.
It may be one vote each from this group THAT HAS DECIDED the EXIT Pattern.

Excellent topic Indya!

The most important observation that I have made is the improvement in quality of singing overall by all the contestants.This makes it a good contest and very difficult for the viewrs to vote.

But all said and done,I still maintain that Amey,Karunya,Meenal and Antara are the top 4.

Meenal has somehow very unlucky in being unable to conenct with the audience.Maybe she is too sophisticated for their liking.I dont know.Same goes for Amey.Karunya seems to be at a receiving end for some reason I cannot fathom.

Antara by far has been the luckiest one and has been surviving on sympathy votes thanks to her constant mentioning of her poor background and being a small town girl etc etc.She is a good singer I accept.But its time people stopped paying attention to other things and get carried away.

For that matter,Amey Meenal and Karunya look like they are from normal middle class families.ITs not like they are priviledged or they come from extremely rich families.

Anuj has a lot of potential.I agree with Indya...if he could come up with a true,from the heart performance,he could cause a few prob;ems for our top 4.

I wasnt too impressed with Sandeep to start with so I dont want to comment too much on him.

Ultimately its upto to the Indian population to think and vote wisely.It would break my heart to see our top 4 contestants leave the contest any sooner than they should be doing so and that too for all the wrong reasons.

smi.

Very good post.
According to me
ANTARA- Singing wise not as talented as Amey and Karunya>inproving day by day>reminds of abhijit sawant of Idol 1- in all probability the winner(1)
AMEY - Best Singer>trained voice Quality>average performer>mature>MY prediction - Runner-Up(2)
ANUJ - Not as good as Karunya and Amey - But the suprise package - Sony would not definitely like to be predictive enough to keep antara,amey and karunya in finals so wud favor Anuj>Huge North India Support(3)
MEENAL - Good Singer>Dignified Performer>maximum times
she came in bottom 3(4)
SANDEEP - Average Singer>Public sympaty and support(5)
KARUNYA - Excellent singer though may not be the best>but has to go out becuse lack of public support(6)

Good I agree with prabal_cog buddy on some points.
Yet who is better than whom is purely personal .

I agree too!! I hope that the nest one wins.....

I will go in alphabetical order.

AMEY has all qualities to become indian idol.but as in all previous reality shows,the best start with a bang .they sart at the top continue to keep the same standard,but fans cant keep voting tons every week and sustain the momentum(eg.rahulv,nihira,arijit).the judges give the same comments every week(they get tired of repeating themselves).others start, rumours of arrogance,overconfidence etc.these are the pitfalls.

ANTARA.she got noticed rightaway.the moment she opened her mouth to sing' kaisi paheli'(sharing split screen with an equally talented very pretty singer).she looked like someone who escaped from SOMALIA.we had an antara fanclub then can you imagine!!!!!?her voice is clear sweet and has masti(listen to ruki ruki or kaisi)Her thin frame comes alive with her singing.and that is what makes annu and sonu look so animated and excited when they give her their comments.she gives the impression that there are a bagfull of surprises in the future.dont underestimate her!!!!

ANUJ.his voice quality is again what made people take notice of him in the piano round.the disappointment and anger at his ouster was not because he was perfectly trained.people wanted to hear that voice again and again.that is why he was brought back.industry is looking for a unique voice(achhe gaane wale hazaaron hain).after last monday i think he is our abhijit sawant.his voice touches peoples hearts)

karunya.among boys youngest,just19.he is exceptionally talented.but girls will alwys look at him as their younger or older brother. there is an air of innocence about him,as though he is incapable of anything decietful.but people wont go ga ga over him.people vote for him when he is in bottom 3,because they feel protective.NOT enough to make him indian idol.

oh dear i have to go.rest later...