Sonu/ANu's Top 3 r Amey,Antara,n Karunya! - Page 3

Originally posted by: noname01

obviously antara!!! has she ever recieved bad comments? well yeah but even her bad comments are better than the comments the other contestants recieve. and she's consistent.

then karunya (who was also FLAWLESS) and amey.

sorry to meenal fans but didn't sonu said she messed up in the beginning a little? so does that qualify her as top 3? agreed she sings well but you have to only judge by that day's performance.

but must say that I was SHOCKED she was in the bottom three. 😡

Sonu said she sounded 'raw' in the beginning, kind of how she sounded in 'Aao Na' in the piano round. Sonu said he felt like she was going to mess up the song but she picked it up by the sargam and sang well. I still feel Meenal has a good shot at the top 3 as does Antara.

Btw, Antara did receive poor comments for Tu Rutha To a few galas ago.

i agree... let me hear antara sing a classical song and then maybe i'll see if she's actually better than meenal

so you are saying her last song was easy? 😲 😲 😲

totally disagree about that but agree that meenal does an awesome job each time. anyway its not like meenal's votes are going to antara...they are probably going to sandeep 😕

i think the 2 girls should be in the final 4 and one of them should be the 2nd II.

edited: whoa pplz, relax!! i like antara as well as meenal!

My top three are

1.
2. AMEY
3. MEENAL

Originally posted by: karunya- II2

My top three are

1.
2. AMEY
3. MEENAL

if karuyna keeps it up then he might deserve to be the next indian idol

Originally posted by: Kadwiphool

that's my point though, antara hasnt sung a hard song yet. meenal ALWAYS sings hard songs!!!! and i think she does such an awesome job each time!

No!!!

Antara sings HArd Songs too..

"Morni Baga Maan" is a hard song...U need a Fat voice n then suddenly Thin Voice...DONT FORGET IT WAS SANG BY GREAT "LATE JI"....NOW THAT MAKES IT HARD TOO....DEFFINATLY ANTARA DID SING HARD SONGS...EVEN ZARA ZARA WASN'T PRETTY EASY TOO...

annu is the senior most and most prolific music director in the music industry today.his contemporarieslike jatin lalit,anand milind,adesh shrivastav, nadeem shravean are left far behind.total number of hits in 2 decades is more than anyone now .

sonu is the no1 singerin industry today.

It surprised me that they were so dimissive about meenal yesterday.they only spoke of RAVI and Amey.she was standing in the middle and... nothing!!!they said that no performance of hers registered.what is their opinion on her voice?nothing...her singinging ability..no pointers.just some wishywashy comments.
dont worry too much about antaras ability to sing classical songs.IF meenal doesnt come up with a show stopping performance next monday.she may have to go.
let antara sing nasal,whine whatever...forget about matchmaking with amey.just concentrate on meenal and HER singing.

Originally posted by: karish89

No!!!

Antara sings HArd Songs too..

"Morni Baga Maan" is a hard song...U need a Fat voice n then suddenly Thin Voice...DONT FORGET IT WAS SANG BY GREAT "LATE JI"....NOW THAT MAKES IT HARD TOO....DEFFINATLY ANTARA DID SING HARD SONGS...EVEN ZARA ZARA WASN'T PRETTY EASY TOO...

THANK YOU!! 👏

I don't get it, why is everyone is so hard on Antara? b/c she hasn't been in the bottom three??? 😡 helooooooo, she sings beautifully!

come on people, keep both the girls in the show!! (hate on someone else...😆, J/K)

edited part: I just read the post that said something along the lines of meenal mailed sonu to stop commenting her?? WTH...that's so random! dude, that would only hurt her standings!! I so seriously DOUBT that.
and where would you get this information?

I don't think most people want both girls in the show.Some say Antara whines while others say Meenal gets votes cause she calls Amey hot. If people keep passing off comments like that, I wonder how long they will last in the competition. I want both in the top four, been saying this for a long time. But Meenal coming in the bottom three makes me upset...she doesn't deserve to be in the bottom three and the wishy-washy comemnts by the judges just annoy me even more.

yeah sonyaee, it's upsetting. 😭