Girls rating 1-10 - Page 3

Antara 10/10...she was the only one who wasn't a disgrace to the Indian Idol platform, she looked cute, sang well, performed well

Meenal 7/10...wasn't too impressed with her singing, performance was lacking but like her better than the others

Neha 5/10...nice performance and stage presence, singing was awful

Yeshashree 3/10...sweet girl but no x-factor, singing was shaky and pitchy, looks like she tried tho

Monali 0/10...this girl cannot sing, bad throat or not (ppl seriously need to stop using that as an excuse, if your throat is bad go home) she thinks too much of herself and has nothing to show for it

Yashashree should not have been there in the first place and i agree farah was being unfair to Minal's singing and as for Sohail he just kept repeating what the others judges had to say
what we need is a celebrity with a musical background not someone like sohail and farah has to be careful about her unfair remarks look what she did to chhote baba

ANTARA : 10/10
NEHA : 9/10
MONALI : 7.5/10
MEENAL : 7/10
YESHAHREE : 5/10


According to public Monali is liek Karunya abd throat & eventhough she will be in bottom 3 she wont out...her cry emotions all make her to get more votes...Meenal from Mumbai so many supports her too...Also sonu crowned her II title too...

Yeshashree is teh weak oen who cant perform or sing that much...Public interaction & energy is very less...

1.Meenal 9/10 I think she sang well she does need to improve her stage presence,but I liked her performance though I expected much more from her.

I did not agree with Farah she cares more about the X factor than singing I feel b'cos of her comments she may be in the bottom three.

2.Neha 8/10 I am not happy with her singing at all but she is an intelligent person she know's exactly what song will match her voice.She is the youngest contestant but has the most amazing stage presence.Her dance and her expressions both completmented the song.Overall the only best performance yesterday.

3.Antara 7/10 she completely let it go the song she chose was hard she shouldn't have moved so much especially on the high notes she should have concentrated more on singing.I really expected her to do well.

4.Monali 5/10 completely disappointed me I had great expectations from her she chose a good song but did not put any feeling into it.Her throat was bad no doubt but I think she was okay overall.

5.Yashashree 4/10 she was too screechy on the high notes she was really bad her performance was horrible she really needs to go.

Sohail was the worst judge he should not have commented on the Meenal's outfit I did not see anything wrong in it .Looks like it was a made up arguement between the judges and poor Meenal got to hear it.I hope the votes go in her favour and she is not out today. 😭

I would like to say something about Farah Khan, before I give my ratings.

She should quit Indian Idol this a not a dancing competition. Her remarks yesterday for Meenal looked more baised than anything else. She loved yasheshree because she dressed like the way she wanted her too, but what about singing???? If I were to have a Veto Power, then I would have picked Sonu Nigam, Sunidhi Chauhan and Alka Yagnik for Judges. Indian Idol judges are here to judge on there singing, sur, choice of songs etc.. I don't think they are here to judge on who looks good on stage, does s/he know how to dance... Come on get real...

In the Galas I wanted to see Jyotsna, Dilpreet, Abha, Meenal, Antara, Renuka Deshpande. Among the current I can handle Neha. Jolly is okay, but have my reservations since she was the reason why Jyotsna was out. Yasheshree didn't deserve to be here at all. Glad to hear that she is GONE

My Votes.
Meenal 10/10 (Great Performance.... One thing I like about her is that she is always smiling)

Antara 10/10 (Girl from an Unknown town... She is a great find)

Neha 8/10 (Delhi mein Jagaran mein Maa Ke Bhent Gaane wali... My Cha-Cha has seen her in Jagaran singing)

Monali 5/10 (No Comment)

Yasheshree 2/10 (Horrible Singer)

Originally posted by: bluepink

My rating for girls gala. 10 being the best and 1 worst.

Meenal: 9 (i don't understand farah khan's remarks. why was she rude?)

Yashashree: 4 (starting was horrible after that she caught up but then lost it again. beautiful song ka kachra kar diya)

Monali: 7 (a tough song. starting was excellent but she lost in the middle because of bad throat then she gained it back. but overall good)

Neha: 8 (very intelligent singer. she can sing only such songs.)

Antara: 10 (excellent performance)

Yashashree was worst. she needs to leave.

i think judges are confusing audience with their comments. their disagreement looks pre-planned. sohail khan was just agreeing with farah khan's comments. that guy doesn't deserve to be on judge seat.

yeah i agree....but u can relax..yashashree's gone!!

ok my rathings are

Meenal: 12 out of 10 (She was fantastic, I think she
should be indian idol 2. I don't
know Farah lost her mind. Farah
should go to mental hospitale.
And sohail. what should i say,
he can't even act. Whats he doing
in idols.
What I like about meenal is her inocentie,
simplacity, and her smile

Antara: 9/ 10
monali: 7/10
Neha: 6/10
Yashashree: 5/10

Originally posted by: sabarizvi

meenal 9/10
antara 7/10
neha 7/10
monali 5/10
yasheshree 4/10

Then who is 10/10 ? LOL

Originally posted by: bluepink

Yashashree: 4 (starting was horrible after that she caught up but then lost it again. beautiful song ka kachra kar diya)

😆

Dilpreet was more way better than yashashree. If Joly won't come then Dilpreet has chance but i donno how many people missing Dilpreet still..but i am missing her to be on Gala better than Yashashree 😡

1.neha...9/10
2.antara...8.5/10
3.monali-8/10..she sang good even wit her sore throat
4.meenal....8/10..she rocked..but was a bit unplished and her performance wasnt THAT good
5.yashashree....OMG!!no comment!