Girls rating 1-10

My rating for girls gala. 10 being the best and 1 worst.

Meenal: 9 (i don't understand farah khan's remarks. why was she rude?)

Yashashree: 4 (starting was horrible after that she caught up but then lost it again. beautiful song ka kachra kar diya)

Monali: 7 (a tough song. starting was excellent but she lost in the middle because of bad throat then she gained it back. but overall good)

Neha: 8 (very intelligent singer. she can sing only such songs.)

Antara: 10 (excellent performance)

Yashashree was worst. she needs to leave.

i think judges are confusing audience with their comments. their disagreement looks pre-planned. sohail khan was just agreeing with farah khan's comments. that guy doesn't deserve to be on judge seat.

Antara 10/10: BANG ON!!! Antara ur a sweetheart!!!

Neha 7/10: Good peformance, Singing was lacking

Meenal 5/10: Average!!!

Monali 4/10: Nasty!

Yashashree 2/10: Disgusting!

Meenal 9/10 : I dont agree with Farah. Its too much to expect the singers to dance AND sing and do both well, all the time. Its not always possible in tough songs. Meenal sang well and the performance was not exceptional, but decent.

Antara 8/10: Concentrated too much on dancing and performance and compromised on her singing. Shes a better singer than what she delivered yesterday.

Neha 7/10: Over performance, I feel she sang ok but she went overboard with the expressions etc.

Monali 5/10: Bad. Sore throat or not. Karunya had a sore throat last week, big deal. Wrong song for Monali I'd say.

Yashashree 3/10: She should leave now. She doesnt deserve the Gala rounds anymore.

Meenal 8
Yashashree 6
Monali 7
Neha 7 1/2
Antara 8

1. Antara ( has got potential to become a good stage artist and a good singer)

2. Meenal

3. Neha ( ask her to sing a normal, subtle song and she will fail.She can be a good stage artist but never a good singer)

4.Yashashri ( Lacks self-confidence, should stay away from stage, but yes, can become a good playback if she chooses her songs well. Actually there is no difference between Neha and Yashashri, both can sing a typical type only )

5.Monali ( good potential, but today's performance was bad )

According to me I for me,

MEENAL 9/10(she did well)
NEHA 7/10( It was shocking performance,din't expect from her)
ANTARA 6/10(she was concentrating more on performance then singing guess wanted to compete with Neha)
MONALI 5/10( could have done better)
YASHASHREE 4/10 (Not great)

And btw, ask farah if she can dance as well as sing if she can, I know she cant, I agree that performance is important but still this show is regarding your singing talent, if you r good at that performance can always improve.

Meenal.....9/10 Nice i liked her.Farah khan had definitely lost her mind. 👏
Antara.....8.5/10 As every1 said she cud have done betta if she concentrated more on singing rather than jumpimg around d stage like a kangaroo. 😆
Neha.......7/10 She did a good job but i really don't like her voice.Its very harsh and funny.
Monali.....6/10 She alaways does well but this time she was a bit of a disappoinment.Cud have chosen a betta song. 😭
Yashashree.....4/10 Don't know y she is even in d galas 😕

i think judges were confusing audience.

Meenal: 9/10.
Antara : 8/10
Too much focus on shakes and moves of the body.
neha : 7/10
(she can only sing certain type of songs, standard expressions in voice and face)

Monali: 6/10
(just becaus of her throat otherwise, she is good)

Yashashree: 3/10 MUST LEAVE....lacks confidence and not indian idol material.

My ratings r

1)Meenal-9/10.She sang really well.Farah has lost it
2)Neha-8/10.She surprised me.She chose the rite song.Good 4 her.
3)Antara-7.5/10.Overall good performance
4)Monali-5/10.I used 2 like her.But bad throat and bad song choice
5)Yeshasree-3/10.she shud leave

I really didnt miss Jolly 😉