The II Judges have to accept partial responsibility for someone like Yashashree making it in the Finalists… at the expense of more deserving singers like Dilpreet, Ritu, Renuka, etc...
They can't just pass the buck onto the public, saying "We are shattered"…. like they had nothing to do with this !!!!!
They (judges and Sony) want to look like good Samaritans… like their giving an opportunity to less privileged people… AND that's great, but pick people who fit the bill
This girl Yashashree did not have the talent to even be in the Top 28… let alone top 12. Just watch her struggle through her one line in "Zindagi Daud hai", and you'll see that she was the weakest candidate in that batch… 😕 😲
Once you bring someone into this arena, be prepared to accept that person in the Top 12… If the judges did not think Yashashree was fit to be in the finalists, they shouldn't have placed her in that position…
My advice to the judges… next time around, when you choose the top 28…Try to picture that person winning the INDIAN IDOL title… and then decide
That would be more practical than going to the temple and praying that the "right" people go forward…
CID
