Poll - Most Overhyped contestant by Judges

I feel Rakesh aka ROCKESH is definitely being more hyped by the judges (eventhough he is less talented than Shreeram) as they feel II5 is turning out to be one-way traffic due to a huge number of public votes in favour of Shreeram in the past few weeks.

Bakwaas and a fuddu POLL...
I dont give a Damn whose overhyped...I just enjoy the singing....
I feel that the most Over-hyped is Indian Idol itself.

Originally posted by: AmanMavi

Bakwaas and a fuddu POLL...
I dont give a Damn whose overhyped...I just enjoy the singing....
I feel that the most Over-hyped is Indian Idol itself.

agreed. well said

most hyped are the judges.do we get to see the experienced and classically trained people sitting in the judge panel ever? and not those who are without jobs ,fickle minded, have no idea of what they are saying and getting unnecessary hype.

@ rths
Sunidhi may not be classically trained but she definitely has immense knowledge of music...Salim is classically trained...
Anu Malik...well i cant say anything abt him...dnt like him much...

@amanmavi
Is it ?he gives such contradictory opinions about sur and taal and abt expressions in each gala.I wondered.
In every gala his expectations keep changing which is good ,but sur is most important and he tends to change his stance on that statement frequently,and when I find some contestants going off sur and almost becoming breathless and swallowing the words,he praises them along with sunidhi,so wondered?I found shivam and naushad going in some songs off sur and swallowing words,but I found them praising unreasonably,which I found it unfair to other contestants.
So thought he is not musically trained to give such statements.Thank u for letting me know.😊

Frankly ,want some senior judges ,sitting on the other side and judging the judges.like we see in wimbledon,the chair umpire overrules the linesmen's wrong calls.Just my opinion,

I am a bit sad in saying this" to err is human,but to repeatedly err is bias...."

I always felt judges should be practical and treat everyone impartially when judging ,can have personal liking towards a contestant,but that can be expressed off camera.

@ rths
I only find Sunidhi a reasonable judge....

Originally posted by: AmanMavi

@ rths
I only find Sunidhi a reasonable judge....

hmmmmmmmmmmmm,thats all I have to say if you think so about sunidhi.By the way your bro is good singer.He is indeed better than some singers from this season.you all seem to me to be coming from musical family.Good to see u posting videos of your brother.😊

Originally posted by: rths

hmmmmmmmmmmmm,thats all I have to say if you think so about sunidhi.By the way your bro is good singer.He is indeed better than some singers from this season.you all seem to me to be coming from musical family.Good to see u posting videos of your brother.😊

really who is Aman Mavi's brother?

@ rths...
Thanks a lot...well this video was just a mere practice of the song...his album is releasing...all the songs hav been recorded...
He composed this song in 2 minutes..And also the lyrics were quite difficult...The thing was some lines were short n some were a lil longer...
I will post his other vids...He sings mostly Punjabi songs...
And honestly am not saying this in air....He's perhaps one of the best singers I've ever heard in my life...
This is his Ye Haunsla..

its a mere 2mb link so please listen 2 it...if u hav tym...