Both Sreeram and Rakesh deserves to be in top 2

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

xobile

@xobile

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#41

Finally the discussion is over! I knew someone would eventually need to stop to get something to eat or use the toilet.

🤣

Quote

Manik_mia

@Manik_mia

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

#42

Originally posted by: xobile
Finally the discussion is over! I knew someone would eventually need to stop to get something to eat or use the toilet.

🤣

I was waiting for them to stop. 😆

I usually do not read if any comment is more than one paragraph.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

sushrutapandey

@sushrutapandey

Navigator

Posted: 15 years ago

#43

Originally posted by: loonyleo
Madam,

My point exactly. That's why I mentioned if he was good enough he will be noticed in time just like they were. SPB was not born as THE SPB. Nobody begins big as you rightly said, there are rungs and what I am saying is he was already on the ladder maybe at a lower rung. If he is not good, nobody can save him even if he wins II. Only time will tell.

What my issue is that there are very talented people trying to reach the lowest rung and that is the spot our guy took. Sony should help these people trying to reach the lowest rung first. Can you for sure say that there was nobody in the auditions who was talented enough for the top 17 other than the ones finally selected? Each seat counts.

By the way, thanks for the "rung" analogy, it helps visualizing this issue even better 😃

Your point would be valid if there was any decent way of identifying the lowest rung. For example, Shivam trains with Suresh Wadekar. In this case, he is training under a reputed Bollywood singer. That might lead a lot of people to vote for him and it is an indirect endorsement from Suresh Wadekar.

And secondly, what should lower rung singers( not the lowest) do if they feel they are stagnating in some place. What frame work mechanism is available for them to get ahead if shows like Indian Idol abandon them.

And thirdly regarding the vote base, the format of II and the nature of it is that you need to acquire a voter base to win. A north Indian like Rakesh or someone like Prashant Tamang will acquire it by being from a particular region. However, he will have the disadvantage of being an unrecognized singer. A south Indian like Sreeram will not get the support of the North Indian masses. Instead he will make use of what little popularity he has in his own area for the purpose.
I don't think you can hold it against a contestant when the format of the show demands that very thing.

Quote

sushrutapandey

@sushrutapandey

Navigator

Posted: 15 years ago

#44

Originally posted by: xobile
Finally the discussion is over! I knew someone would eventually need to stop to get something to eat or use the toilet.

🤣

Sorry, I was away all afternoon and I restarted it again😳😭

Quote

Shree Pavanaputra Mynampati

@loonyleo

Beginner

Posted: 15 years ago

#45

Originally posted by: sushrutapandey

Sorry, I was away all afternoon and I restarted it again😳😭

LOL, no issues. I don't want to discuss 😊. Everybody has said their peace. I don't agree with you all but decided that nothing was worth going over the points again and again. You believe in something and I in something else.

I am not holding anything against any contestant but against the selection process. Enjoy the contest.

Edited by loonyleo - 15 years ago

Quote

thewiseone

@thewiseone

Explorer

Posted: 15 years ago

#46

oh man...lol...i guess i was a bit late. 😆debate maine shuru ki thi aur khatam kisi aur ne ki. lol. oh well. it took me a while to read everyone's posts. and i think kallu_be, SlumGOD, and sushrutapandey have handled it well and they kinda said all i wanted to. lol. thank u guys! i have nothing to more to add. i dont wanna rekindle the debate again, so let it be. lol.😆

@loonyleo: by the way, my username is "thewiseone" not "thewiseguy." lol. just informing.

Quote

rths

@rths

Navigator

Posted: 15 years ago

#47

Originally posted by: sheeba1990

oops, sorry
Edited by rths - 15 years ago

Quote

Shree Pavanaputra Mynampati

@loonyleo

Beginner

Posted: 15 years ago

#48

well, it's online and I came across it. You too can google it. Now I don't know how it got there but it does not seem like someone just uploaded it.

Quote

rths

@rths

Navigator

Posted: 15 years ago

#49

Originally posted by: loonyleo
well, it's online and I came across it. You too can google it. Now I don't know how it got there but it does not seem like someone just uploaded it.

sorry i misread it ,as it was said by sheeba.i know all is available in 8pm news .com as well,which i initially gave her.my above post which i edited was not for u but for sheeba
😳

Edited by rths - 15 years ago