Tie-Breaker Round: Sadhna Sargam - Page 2

Wow! Haven't heard this song in ages!!!!!!! A beautiful selection.

This song is a different one. Quite unique in my opinion. What beautiful singing done by her. She maintained her voice really well. Expressions were there, but somehow in some places she lost her track. In certain places there could have been more throw and emphasis with expressions which was lacking!

I think this song has a bit of a higher difficulty level than the other two songs. Maybe because its a faster track. When it comes to the singing though I don't think it was as strong enough as Alka ji and neither did I think it was as weak as Anuradha ji's. BUT since we can't rate .5's I'll have to go down and give her the 7, same as Anuradha ji's.

Without being biased at all, I really think and HONESTLY believe that Alka ji had a slight of a stronger edge with the tie breaker. But sadly the polls and ratings don't say so.

Final Rating: 7.5 but don't think its strong enough to get the 8 so unfort. 7

hey friends,

At first, the singing might sound very simple.

However, if you listen again and again, you will realize that the song required incredible finnesse. And I think Sadhna ji did full justice to it. The tremendous voice control and the laughter in the song really was well done and the harkats were OK, IMO. But there was some simplicity also within the song, which made her task a bit easy compared to the other songs in her previous rounds. I'll give her an 8!

Originally posted by: JaspalToronto

hey friends,

I guess we are not judging lyrics and background music of this track. Guys we need to understand that its a marriage song as gane ke bol are banno rani .. . .Neither I remember watching this movie nor this track but just now I listened to it twice. As far as Sadhna's singing is concerned she has done justice to this song. She has sung both aaroh and aavroh with perfection and her voice modulation is excellent with exceptional voice through and quality, thus she gets 9 out of 10

Good to see you here Jaspal paaji. 😊

Pros: great control on sur, including holding notes, high notes and harkats; kept up with the fast tempo; some nice variations; apt expression too; you can hear her smile/laughter in the main chorus.

Cons: went sharp once, I think it was on the second 'tumhe sayani' because she was trying to laugh on the line.

A very genuine performance with effective expressions. I agree fully with Jaspalji - it was an ideal wedding song, sung in sur. And it was challenging because of the high notes and fast tempo. Sadhanaji has shown great voice control in the way she easily slips from firmly held straight notes to delicate and intricate harkats.

If this song doesn't move you, that's not because the singing wasn't good enough. It's a typical wedding/celebration track and the composition/lyrics are not very rousing. Sadhanaji did full justice.

8/10, only because there are more challenging songs out there.

I love this track.. was happy to hear is after a long time...
It is a different track and Sadhna ji has maintained the expressions required for the song really well....
The tempo of the song is maintained well..
Actually this song may not appeal to people at the first go..but listen to it few times..it will grown on you...

Definitely 8 to 8.5 for me

I love this song and think she has done a great job in it! Good expressions as far as the song would allow. I feel all the songs in this round are more or less at the same level of difficulty so no extra marks for that!
9/10 from me!

Polls are closed!!!



Audience Avg: 8.8
Judges Avg: 7.0



Final Score: 7.9 (7.90)

Originally posted by: xobile

TIED with Anuradha!

Noooo

Now I'm okay with Alkaji losing. No more ties please!

woah another TIE? :O